CGC vs XXXPHOENIX grading contest PART 6 : 112 books just graded!

Hello to everybody!

CGC just finished grading my 112 books....let's compare their grades with my forecasts!

MANY MONTHS AGO I submitted 112 MODERN books to CGC...they were received between 8/8 to 8/12 2011...and it took 2 MONTHS to switch from verified to graded status...As soon as I receive them I will add them to my numerous registry sets.

Hey CGC...hire more graders please!

Most of these come from my personal collection. They were all purchased as NM books before the CGC era...Anyway you can easily guess how hard it is to build a high grade comic book collection with the unique&only option of buying my books via (air)mail... to ITALY!

You can't imagine how many dealers just throw the NEW books in padded envelopes without further protection...

This is what I got! 43X 9.8 , 32X 9.6 , 19X 9.4, 10X 9.2, 4X 9.0, 2X 8.5, 1X 8.0, 1X 7.5 .

As usual most of my forecasts were pretty exact and remained in a +/- .2 range in comparison to CGC grading standards...with few unexplainable exceptions (check the *).

I will keep in my collection all books graded 9.4 or higher and few of the 9.2.

TITLE ISSUE FORECAST CGC

Alpha Flight 19 9.4-9.6 // 9.8

Alpha Flight 28 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Amazing Spider-Man 303 9.6-9.8 // 9.0 * WHY?!

Amazing Spider-Man 305 9.6-9.8 // 9.4

Amazing Spider-Man 314 9.6-9.8 // 9.4

Amazing Spider-Man 316 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Amazing Spider-Man 323 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Amazing Spider-Man 388 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Amazing Spider-Man 500 9.4-9.6 // 9.8

Avengers 1II 9.6-9.8 // 9.6

Daredevil 319 9.6-9.8 // 9.4

Daredevil 321 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Daredevil 323 9.6-9.8 // 9.6

Daredevil 324 9.6-9.8 // 9.4

Daredevil 325 9.6-9.8 // 9.6

Earth X 0 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Earth X 1 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Earth X 0DF 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Fantastic Four 1II 9.4-9.6 // 9.2 * WHY?!

Fantastic Four 254 9.4-9.6 // 9.4

Fantastic Four 255 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Fantastic Four 257 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Fantastic Four 260 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Fantastic Four 267 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Fantastic Four 285 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Fantastic Four 1A 9.6-9.8 // 9.4

Ghost Rider 15 9.4-9.6 // 9.2

Ghost Rider 15A 9.4-9.6 // 9.4

Hearth of Darkness1 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Hellstorm 1 9.4-9.6 // 9.8

Heroes Reborn the Return 1 9.4-9.6 // 9.8

Heroes Reborn the Return 2 9.4-9.6 // 9.4

Heroes Reborn the Return 3 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Heroes Reborn the Return 4 9.4-9.6 // 9.4

Heroes Reborn the Return 1A 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Heroes Reborn the Return 1B 9.4-9.6 // 9.0 * WHY?!

Heroes Reborn the Return 2A 9.4-9.6 // 8.5

Heroes Reborn the Return 3A 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Heroes Reborn the Return 4A 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Incredible Hulk 331 9.2-9.4 // 7.5 * WHY?! * WHY?!

Incredible Hulk 333 9.2-9.4 // 9.4

Incredible Hulk 334 9.2-9.4 // 9.4

Incredible Hulk 335 9.2-9.4 // 9.6

Incredible Hulk 336 9.2-9.4 // 9.8

Incredible Hulk 337 9.2-9.4 // 9.4

Incredible Hulk 338 9.2-9.4 // 9.2

Incredible Hulk 341 9.2-9.4 // 9.2

Incredible Hulk 342 9.2-9.4 // 8.0 * WHY?! * WHY?!

Incredible Hulk 343 9.2-9.4 // 9.4

Incredible Hulk 344 9.2-9.4 // 9.2

Incredible Hulk 345 9.2-9.4 // 9.6

Incredible Hulk 346 9.2-9.4 // 9.6

Incredible Hulk 393 9.4-9.6 // 9.8

Incredible Hulk 400 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Infinity Gauntlet1 9.2-9.4 // 9.6

Infinity Gauntlet2 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Infinity Gauntlet3 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Infinity Gauntlet4 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Infinity Gauntlet5 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Infinity War 1 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Infinity War 2 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Infinity War 3 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Infinity War 4 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Infinity War 5 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Infinity War 6 9.6-9.8 // 9.6

Marvel Fanfare 1 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Marvels 0 9.2-9.4 // 9.4

Marvels 1 9.6-9.8 // 9.6

Marvels 2 9.6-9.8 // 9.6

Marvels 3 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Marvels 4 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

New Mutants 88 9.6-9.8 // 9.4 * WHY?!

New mutants annual 5 9.2-9.4 // 9.0 * WHY?!

New Warriors 1A 9.6-9.8 // 9.6

Nomad 1 9.4-9.6 // 9.8

Sleepwalker 1 9.4-9.6 // 9.2

Spider-Man 1 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Spider-Man 10 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Strange Tales 1 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Tales of Suspense1 9.6-9.8 // 9.6

Tales to Astonish1 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

The secret Defenders1 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Uncanny X-Men 214 9.4-9.6 // 9.0 * WHY?!

Uncanny X-Men 216 9.4-9.6 // 9.8

Uncanny X-Men 217 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Uncanny X-Men 218 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Uncanny X-Men 223 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Uncanny X-Men 227 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Uncanny X-Men 228 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Uncanny X-Men 229 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Uncanny X-Men 233 9.4-9.6 // 9.4

Uncanny X-Men 242 9.4-9.6 // 9.4

Uncanny X-Men 254 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Uncanny X-Men 255 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Uncanny X-Men 297 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

Uncanny X-Men 298 9.4-9.6 // 8.5 * WHY?!

Uncanny X-Men 299 9.4-9.6 // 9.2 * WHY?!

Uncanny X-Men 301 9.6-9.8 // 9.4

Uncanny X-Men 302 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Uncanny X-Men 304 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Warlock Infinity Watch1 9.4-9.6 // 9.8

Web of Spider-Man90 9.6-9.8 // 9.8

Wonder Man 1 9.4-9.6 // 9.6

X-Factor 3 9.4-9.6 // 9.2 * WHY?!

X-Factor 4 9.6-9.8 // 9.6

X-Factor 7 9.6-9.8 // 9.2 * WHY?!

X-Factor 8 9.6-9.8 // 9.6

X-Factor 9 9.6-9.8 // 9.6

X-Factor 10 9.4-9.6 // 9.8

X-Factor 23 9.4-9.6 // 9.4

X-Factor 25 9.6-9.8 // 9.2 * WHY?!

X-Factor 26 9.6-9.8 // 9.6

CIAO!

FEDERICO