-
When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
.jpg.2901100a90dcec56fbee34774198aba1.jpg)
dragonmgmt
-
Posts
419 -
Joined
Content Type
Forums
CGC Journals
Gallery
Events
Store
Posts posted by dragonmgmt
-
-
Hello,Please add the following to "Silver Surfer (1982-1998)":Starmasters #1 (cert #3977609013)Starmasters #2Starmasters #3[On my slab, it is listed as "Starmasters" but on the "Silver Surfer (Master Set)" these issues are listed as "Star Masters"...just FYI.]Thank you!Slots added to set, titles changed in Master Set. 5/12/22
-
-
On 9/17/2021 at 3:37 PM, Figment said:
Regardless of what is decided or implemented, thank you to the admins and the board for considering the idea, and thanks all for their input.
I do think the simpler the algorithm, the simpler it will be to understand and accept. No solution will satisfy everyone, and complexity in this case may cause confusion. I do think that points should roughly reflect value, but I also think that a way of the ignoring temporary spikes of "hot, then not" may need to be considered. I'm also not sure I like the idea of capping the scores. I admit to having lots of books that hold relatively low point scores and might benefit if somebody else's were capped, but I also have some of those "grails" and would most likely cry foul if someone tried to have them clipped.
The fact that #1's and other key issues are priced, and have point values, beyond what seems reasonable or realistic is just the way it is. We all have to live with the supply and demand aspect of the hobby.
From a technical perspective it strikes me as relatively easy to add the additional columns and calculations, but I fully admit I have no clue as to the implementation details or server environments behind it all.
Another idea would be to simply say that a set must be at least x% complete before being considered for registry award ranking. I'm not sure what value is appropriate for "x", but something that would generally eliminate sets of "one or two".
Figment's idea of having set be x% complete before it is considered for registry award ranking, seems to me, to eliminate almost all of the abovementioned issues of points for keys and fillers.
I would humbly nominate this as the best solution thus far.
-
-
I actually increased the scores for both issues. 1/5/21. Thank you
Silver Surfer #3 (original run) lags behind other major issues in this series. See below for comparison between SS 3 (1st app Mephisto) and SS 4 (awesome cover but no 1st apps). The recent sales of 9.8s for these issues should be indicative of a point bump for SS3. SS3 9.8 sold for $38,400 in Nov 2020, and SS4 9.8 (Rocky Mountain pedigree) sold for $17,900 in July 2020.SS32018201912m90dLastPoints$ (12m)/Point9.838400384003840046678.2279849.6210052655250525029171.8049379.41055214924292900290017501.3889.288918111684172517258751.924571957711251108120313005831.9005158.54327148639829353912.20716183275216487959502452.6448987.52814175156687601463.52739772423684445685991233.6097566.5237305374417600884.256145264348433370784.4615385.5167232328397410704.6857145182267300300584.6034484.5150194240275275475.1063834130204230290330415.6097563.565176222274262356.3428573105166191220295.7241382.5157165132236.826087Compare these numbers with Silver Surfer #4SS42018201912m90dLastPoints$ (12m)/Point9.816800179001790076002.3552639.6371150746195720047501.3042119.4202526783350370028501.1754399.21428201721832400252014251.531939102815231685220522059501.7736848.583011651436199017006372.25431786639501133147014703992.8395997.5557673802101311502383.36974874666036907937662003.456.53744865717757751433.99300763474525096076001264.0396835.53214185145695141144.5087725316403408499550954.2947374.5225315357441450764.6973684270304330456674.9253733.5188277294300300575.1578953216241254270485.2916672.5173155214250385.631579 -
On 11/28/2020 at 6:57 AM, Rich_Henn said:
Silver Surfer #3 CGC 7.5 - $775
1st appearance of Mephisto
Blue universal label designation "From the Collection of Doug Moench"
Claim via PM. Thanks, Rich!
-
-
-
-
-
Please add a set for "Fantastic Four: Antithesis"#1#1 - McGuinness Variant Cover#1 - Pichelli Variant Cover#1 - Variant Edition#2#2 - Comics Elite "Virgin" Edition#2 - Comics Elite Edition#2 - Ross Sketch Cover#2 - Ross Variant Cover#2 - Variant EditionSet created on 2/23/21. Thank you.
-
-
On 10/2/2020 at 9:49 PM, dragonmgmt said:
Please add the following to "Silver Surfer (Master Set)":Howard the Duck #2 - regularHoward the Duck #2 - Fowler Variant CoverHoward the Duck #2 - Hembeck Variant CoverHoward the Duck #2 - Variant Edition (cert# 2133488009)Howard the Duck #2 - Sketch CoverHoward the Duck #2 - Second PrintingHoward the Duck #4 - regularHoward the Duck #4 - Cho Variant CoverHoward the Duck #4 - Variant EditionHoward the Duck #5 - regularHello @dragonmgmt,
Unfortunately, our system does not list a Silver Surfer appearance in these 3 issues and I did not see any other references. Please PM me with any details and I will gladly reconsider. Please note that the variants will share an issue as they do not receive their own slots in "Master Sets."
11/6/20
See attached images for Howard the Duck #2, #4, and #5 appearances by Silver Surfer.Thank you for providing the images. Slots added on 11/25/20
-
-
Please add the following to "Silver Surfer (1982-1998)":Marvel Comics Presents #1Marvel Comics Presents #50Marvel Comics Presents #69Marvel Comics Presents #97Marvel Comics Presents #172Marvel Comics Presents #173Marvel Comics Presents #174Marvel Comics Presents #175Thanks!Slots added on 11/10/20. Please note that CGC has not graded #172-174 so they were not added.
-
-
On 8/20/2020 at 8:34 AM, dragonmgmt said:
Please add the following to the "Silver Surfer: Black" set:Silver Surfer: Black #5 - 2nd Printing (cert #3697150011)Slot created. Thank you
Who do I need to talk to if this cert # is not showing up in the census? Please advise.Hello @dragonmgmt,
Please email our CGC customer service team at the address below. Please provide an image of the book and label along with a dated item (newspaper, computer calendar, etc) to show that it is currently in the holder. The book looks to have been deleted from our system and the details will need to be restored by an expert.
submissions@cgccomics.com
-
Please add the following to "Silver Surfer (Master Set)":Howard the Duck #2 - regularHoward the Duck #2 - Fowler Variant CoverHoward the Duck #2 - Hembeck Variant CoverHoward the Duck #2 - Variant Edition (cert# 2133488009)Howard the Duck #2 - Sketch CoverHoward the Duck #2 - Second PrintingHoward the Duck #4 - regularHoward the Duck #4 - Cho Variant CoverHoward the Duck #4 - Variant EditionHoward the Duck #5 - regularHello @dragonmgmt,
Unfortunately, our system does not list a Silver Surfer appearance in these 3 issues and I did not see any other references. Please PM me with any details and I will gladly reconsider. Please note that the variants will share an issue as they do not receive their own slots in "Master Sets."
11/6/20
-
-
Please add a set for Rocket (2017)Rocket #1Rocket #1 - Animation EditionRocket #1 - Jusko Variant CoverRocket #1 - Mack Variant CoverRocket #1 - Movie Variant CoverRocket #1 - Variant EditionRocket #2Rocket #2 - Variant EditionRocket #3Rocket #4Rocket #4 - Variant EditionRocket #5Rocket #6Set already exists. Thank you
-
Please add the following to "Silver Surfer (Master Set)":Guardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019)Guardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Comic Mint EditionGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Crain "Virgin" EditionGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Crain Variant CoverGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Den of the Damned "Virgin" EditionGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Den of the Damned Comics EditionGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Deodato Sketch CoverGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Deodato Variant CoverGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Lim Variant CoverGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Parel Variant CoverGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Parrillo "Virgin" EditionGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Parrillo Sketch CoverGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Parrillo Variant CoverGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Premiere EditionGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Ribic Variant CoverGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Sketch EditionGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Skroce Variant CoverGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Variant EditionGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Wrightson Variant CoverGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Young Variant CoverGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Second PrintingGuardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) - Third PrintingAll available books have been added to the Guardians of the Galaxy #1 (2019) slot. Please note that these will all share one slot.
-
-
-
Please add the following to the "Obama Master Set":I added the books highlighted below. Please note that I only added the ones that I could confirm contained Obama on the cover. Our data does not list him as a character in the other issues and/or we have not graded them. If you have evidence, please DM it to me and I will adjust.
The Other Dead #1The Other Dead #1 - Retailer Incentive EditionAddedThe Other Dead #1 - Subscription EditionThe Other Dead #2Created slot but it is empty since CGC has not graded the bookThe Other Dead #2 - Subscription EditionThe Other Dead #4AddedThe Other Dead #4 - Retailer Incentive EditionThe Other Dead #5Created slot but it is empty since CGC has not graded the bookThe Other Dead #6(I didn't see Other Dead #3 on the census...usually it's not possible to add unless it's on the census but maybe you got a failed prescreen of it or something...so if you can, add it too)
(And also, I sent Matt G a PM about this set...please check inbox. Thanks.)
new 2022 threads for score fixing, build set, and add to set?
in CGC Registry
Posted
Can we get new (i.e. unlocked) threads for fixing, building, and adding sets? Please advise. Thanks.