I submitted my Hero Initiative 100 Blank Cover to CGC and they refused to grade it. This was the email I received:
"Dear XXXX, We were processing this invoice of 3 books to be graded. I just wanted to let you know that we will not be able to encapsulate the Walking Dead #100 Heroes Initiative blank sketch cover. As requested by the Hero Initiative, these books are only to be graded with sketches done for their charity. These covers are not supposed to be circulated in the market without one of their commissioned sketches, therefore, we will return the book back to you ungraded. If you have any further questions or concerns, feel free to call me in Customer Service at the number below. Best, Alexandra Vargas "
I then wrote a letter to them for further explanation:
"Now at this moment I have 25 books of mine being graded at your company. My understanding was that I was having my book graded to determine their condition and encapsulated to protect them. I don't understand how that has anything to do with how the blank cover was acquired. I don't mind having something added that states that this cover was not released to the public or that is was not meant to be available without a sketch but to deny grading just because The Hero initiative says so seem ludicrous. How about The Walking Dead 100 Lucille unsigned edition. That cover was not supposed to be released without the signature of Kirkman, yet it was still released and graded by your company. It seems like denying a book to be graded just because some other organization says so it just plain wrong. I did not think my fees for CGC were to police how books are released to the public but rather to be graded based on their condition and encapsulated to preserve that grade. I really hope you reconsider your decision and we can try to find a middle ground on this situation. Looking forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely,
XXXXXXXX"
Then I received the official response from Eric Downtown:
"That book is technically property stolen from Hero Initiative and they asked us not to grade them. As a courtesy for the phenomenal work they do for our industry, we will honor that request.
The Walking Dead Lucille edition copies that were released erroneously were graded only after we got permission directly from Skybound and Robert Kirkman himself.
I am sorry, but we will not knowingly grade something we know to be stolen. If you had a friend that sneaked a book past us then he got lucky, be assured that it will not happen again now that we are aware that these books are out there."
I went so far as to meet with the person in charge of the Hero Initiative in person at Long Beach Comic Con and offered to donate $1,000 (the amount I paid for the book) to their charity since I feel they got cheated out of the profit made by the person who sold the book to me. He refused and said that they will not allow any of them to be graded. Seems so stupid to turn down $1,000 for your charity just because of a huge ego, but I guess that's their official stance. Maybe one day CGC will get off their mighty high horse and realize that its just another variant and just grade the damn thing.