Enjoyable little presentation....
My belief is that before you can really do 'impressionistic' type of art, you really should be grounded in the fundamentals, if not absolutely a master of them.
Moebius (Jean Giraud) spent many years on 'Blackberry', completely MASTERING a look from a genre not even a part of his native land...
Before venturing into a more abstract form. It gave it substance, and thus artistic merit.
McFarlane began his career by learning the basics.... anatomy, layout, perspective, etc....
But since comics are somewhat a perversion of those techniques in the first place (and Todd never really mastered them anyway), his growth to the 'next level' or whatever you want to call it, is spectacular in it's flashiness, no question, and somewhat pleasing to some to look at... but in reality... artistic reality... it's overly unnecessarily busy and...kinda flat.
Of course, much like professional wrestling, it caught the eye of many young boys right at the onset of puberty and it SOLD incredibly well and.... well...
If you want to see the progression of a master, check out Picasso's "First Communion":
Picasso was FIFTEEN YEARS OLD when he painted that.
Look at the composition. Look at the realism. Look at the use of light and dark.
It's breathtaking, and far beyond anything most of us could ever produce.
The argument that you can "break the rules before you know them" doesn't hold water.
(PS. I thought it was "Blueberry"? Or is there a "Blackberry", too?)
Something that was not touched upon in the video was the advances in technology and the emergence of photography. While I appreciate the efforts of the masters - especially works that are not from observation, is it possible that the ability to capture the images of the world so exactly through photography released artists to move away from the strict discipline that was handed down for centuries? Or more to the point- allow the practice to be used in ways they enjoyed?
Now I am not saying that everything is art--- the squatting pee cop and the huge rock are just amusing if anything to me -- I agree with what he is saying there. But the world is so vastly different from the one where these masters worked. Is it really surprising that even legitimate art (however that is determined) has morphed into so many new levels of thinking?
As we always say here-- collect/buy what you like and be open to let others do likewise..