Grade this X-Men 1 for realitytrip

[Darthdiesel]

Just doin' a pal a favor and hosting pics...

 

 

[ninanina]

G/VG due to an accumulation of defects and general wear.

[Tomega]

Just doin' a pal a favor and hosting pics...

 

 

G+ 2.5 to g/vg 3.0. It is hard to tell from the qulaity of the scan but there appears to be some tearing, spine roll, and obvious creasing. On the stckwizard scale it would be a mint 9.9 except for those defects.

 

Tom

[Tomega]

G/VG due to an accumulation of defects and general wear.

 

Damn , I thought I was going to be the first to post on this one - we both posted at 11:17.

 

Tom

[DiceX]

3.0

[ubiquiti]

VG-

But a really clean copy!

You guys are being too hard on it.

Now my opinion could change with a higher res scan...but I can't see anything too severe.

[realitytrip]

Thanks to Darthdiesel for hosting the pics for me!

 

You guys are good. G/VG is the grade that the dealer I bought the book from gave it (back in '96). I pretty much agree with the grade, although it is VERY nice looking for the grade. The scans don't do it justice. While I am not planning on selling it anytime soon, I have been wondering whether or not to slab it for protective purposes (and better liquidity if it comes to that ). Do you guys think I would be doing myself a disservice slabbing the book? It IS a reader copy in most ways, so maybe I should leave it out?

 

Opinions encouraged.

Thanks

Keith

[ninanina]

VG-

But a really clean copy!

You guys are being too hard on it.

Now my opinion could change with a higher res scan...but I can't see anything too severe.

 

See above!

[ninanina]

G/VG due to an accumulation of defects and general wear.

 

Damn , I thought I was going to be the first to post on this one - we both posted at 11:17.

 

Tom

 

Yeah, but we're BOTH good.

[Ares]

I give it a 2.0

I got one back from CGC in the same condition and it got 2.0

[ubiquiti]

VG-

But a really clean copy!

You guys are being too hard on it.

Now my opinion could change with a higher res scan...but I can't see anything too severe.

 

See above!

Above where?

Looks like the same res scan.

[ninanina]

VG-

But a really clean copy!

You guys are being too hard on it.

Now my opinion could change with a higher res scan...but I can't see anything too severe.

 

See above!

Above where?

Looks like the same res scan.

 

realitytrips last post. Sorry, mine was supposed to be right under it, but someone posted a second before I did mine...hence the confusion. I am thinking he's already decided the G/VG grade was the correct one.