2008/09 Grading Contest: Round 1 Results

[herc2000]

One good thing, I think by this all my VF- comics have just become NM- by CGC's standards!

[General Zod]

That's insane. I'm re-submitting one of my books that I thought looked EXACTLY like that condition. Jeez Louise, I got hosed!

[THE_BEYONDER]

Even though I went with 7.0, I can't believe 56 people gave that better than 6.5.

I thought this place was known for tight grading.

I gave it a 6.5

I would have been ridiculed shamelessly if I called it a VF-

 

6.0 here . I bombed, but that book just does NOT look like a 7.5. Or a 7.0 for that matter.

 

 

[COI]

Yeah, apparently those of us who guessed CGC's grade can't grade, which in turn means CGC can't grade.

 

Why are people paying premiums for slabs then?

[mar-vell]

looks like a classic CGC 7.0 to me. If i was offered a chance to purchase this book at a 7.5 price i would pass.