• Announcements

    • dena

      Try the new CGC Journals!   03/22/2017

      CGC has launched a new and improved CGC Journals! Available on CGCcomics.com, the new CGC Journals improves upon the popular platform to write blogs and discuss them with other members. The new CGC Journals has an improved design that makes it significantly easier to post and read journals from any device, including smartphones and tablets. Adding images has been made much simpler, and the CGC Journals now give users the ability to create polls and "like" other entries. A popular feature of the old CGC Journals was the ability to open an entry to comments from other users. This feature has been retained and enhanced — users can now comment on the same page as the original Journal entry, creating a seamless experience. Best of all, the same login can be used to post Journals, make comments and access the other features of the CGC website. Old CGC Journals entries will be migrated to the new CGC Journals soon. In the meantime, users can make posts to the new CGC Journals. To get started, create a Journal and make an entry. Unlike the old NGC Journals, you create a single Journal and then add new entries to it. Your Journal can be customized with a cover photo, and you can choose to make it available to all users or only to the users that you select. You can also choose to receive notifications whenever people comment on one of your entries. Scroll below for helpful tips on using the new CGC Journals or go to the new CGC Journals now >   Instructions / Tips To get started, you must first create your Journal and then you can add entries to that Journal. Choose Journals from the Browse menu if you are not already on the Journals page

        Click Create a Journal

        Name your journal, add a description, add a photo, and choose if you want all users to see your journal or if you would like it available to a specific audience only. Click Continue to move on to the next step where you can add you first entry!  

        Click Add Journal Entry to add a post to your journal

        Commenting on another user's Journal is easy. After selecting a journal to read, scroll to the bottom of the page where you will find the field where you may enter your comments and see the comments others have posted.
    • Brittany M.

      CCS - Updated Turn Times!   03/28/2017

      CCS has updated its turn times! Here is where CCS is operating for each tier of service:   Quick-Press: 6 weeks (30 Business Days) Regular Press: 8-9 weeks (40-45 Business Days) Fast-Track Press: 4-6 weeks (20-30 Business Days) Standard: 3-4 weeks (15-20 Business Days) Express: 3 weeks (15 Business Days) Walk-thru: 2-3 weeks (10-15 Business Days) Screening: 5-6 weeks (25-30 Business Days)    

Stronguy Reviews The Marvel Bronze Age
28 28

203 posts in this topic

As some of you may recall I completed my Marvel Bronze Age set a couple of years ago. I've been slowly reading my way through them but it's taking forever. I've got 2 kids and I like to fight so there's not a lot of free time.

 

I'm pretty familiar with all of the mainstream titles and their story lines. I've read entire runs Avengers, X-Men and stuff like that. What I thought I'd focus on is the in-between stuff. Things like The Cat, 2001: A Space Odyssey... you know, the stuff that not many people read.

 

So, in this thread I'll start posting reviews of some of the more interesting books or runs I find. Some of these things completely fly under the radar so this should be an interesting experiment. Posting will be in a random order at first because I'm already through a long box and a quarter. Gee, only 15 more boxes to go.

 

Forgive me if I ramble. Some of this stuff is really bad.

 

Click here to add this thread to your watch list.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Champions

Issues 1-17

October 1975 - January 1978

 

Rating: 2.5/5 (thanks to issues 11-15)

 

The formula is simple... take some B-listers who can't float a book on their own, mix in some really bad writing and stick them in LA. That's pretty much what the Champions is all about.

 

The first 7 issues of this run are really bad. Bad plot, bad dialog (Tony Isabella), bad art (Don Heck)... just bad. One interesting thing to note was issues 1-3 were originally intended to be a Giant-Size book and contain Black Goliath. Instead they decided to make it a bi-monthly book and move BG to his own equally as sucky book.

 

I really like the whole idea of fan turned pro but, honestly, is there anything that Tony Isabella wrote in the 70s that didn't just blow? And Don Heck's art... geesh! I've got a lot of respect for DH's work in the early days of Marvel but by the mid-late 70s it was becoming really dated. Fortunately issues 3, 6, 7 and 8 had George Tuska art. Some panels of his work are absolutely beautiful and, at times, he overcomes Vince Coletta's ham-handed inking and you get something really nice.

 

At issue 8 Bill Mantlo takes over writing and things get much better. The stories have a much better flow and there is a great drop off in suckatude. In fact, I would say, some of the stories are pretty decent (by mid-70s standards).

 

The real gem is in issues 11-15 when some guy named John Byrne starts the art. Talk about a quantum leap forward. These books are worth picking up just for his work.

 

Alas, as with all great things this series comes to a screeching halt with issue 17. Not even Byrne's solid work (with a little help from Bob Layton) could save it.

 

Edit: I guess I blocked this out because it definitely one of the low points. For the first few issues Angle gets a really nifty man-cruising outfit. This things is fit for nothing more than making a some quick trips up to San Francisco and picking up a "friend" for the weekend. It looked like he should have been trying out of a role in Barbarella or something. Marvel got several letters asking about it and they said it was changed from his blue X-Men costume because there was already too much blue on the page with Black Widow and Ghost Rider's outfits. I guess the feedback was so bad they eventually switched back to the old design but changed the color to red. Better run out and pick up a copy because this might be the next minor Bronze Age key. :insane:

 

Angel-Champion.jpg

 

Pros:

-- Black Widow... I've always had a thing for a red head in skin tight, black leather (I assume it's leather... it least that's what I'm going with).

-- Moments of greatness from George Tuska in spite of Vince Coletta.

-- Bill Mantlo taking over in issue 8.

-- John Byrne's art in issues 11-15

-- A cool story with Magneto and Dr. Doom in issue 16.

-- Angle switches to the red costume he'll have for the next 10+ years.

 

Cons:

-- Tony Isabella's horrible writing.

-- Don Heck's dated art.

-- Vince Coletta man handling George Tuska's art.

-- No one being able to draw a guy with a flaming skull for a head (except for Byrne).

-- Angel and his homoerotic attire.

 

Champions.jpg

 

Edited by Stronguy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You read the whole series? :insane:

That would have pushed me over the edge.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dude, I totally love the idea of this thread! I'll read every review you post.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dude, I totally love the idea of this thread! I'll read every review you post.

 

+1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And as a request, I'd be curious what you think of Super-Villain Team-Up and Invaders. Wouldn't mind Kull and Red Sonja either, as I'm far more familiar with Conan 1-115 than I am those series.

 

Oh, and Peter the Little Pest.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great thread. Keep 'em coming. Can't wait for Howard the Duck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dude, I totally love the idea of this thread! I'll read every review you post.

 

+ 1 (thumbs u

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not sure I can think of anything worse than Tuska inked by Coletta. :sick:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm curious to any opinions on whether Ghost rider helped or hindered this book???

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'm curious to any opinions on whether Ghost rider helped or hindered this book???

 

Ghost Rider was the weakest character in the book. It was obvious that he was there just to draw in readers. It seems the only thing he did was show up, flame out, shoot some Hellfire at something, realize it didn't have any effect then get person_without_enough_empathyslapped into unconsciousness. Had this series come out 10 years later it would have been Wolverine instead of Ghost Rider.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great Thread!

 

I really like the whole idea of fan turned pro but, honestly, is there anything that Tony Isabella wrote in the 70s that didn't just blow?

 

I remember his original Black Lightning run as being very readable for the time. Of course, I don't think I've re-read it at any point in the last 30 years, so maybe I'd be in for a bad surprise if I attempted what you're doing. :eek:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2001: A Space Odyssey

Issues 1-10

December 1976 - September 1977

 

Rating: 1/5 (issues 1-7)

Rating: 3.5/5 (issues 8-10)

 

I've got to break this into 2 different reviews. Issues 1-7 are a completely different series than 8-10.

 

Issues 1-7

What do you do when you want to woo Jack Kirby back to the House Of Ideas? Well, why not turn him loose and let him do any old thing he wants. That appears to be what Stan decided to do. The result... one of the most polarizing series in the Bronze Age. You either love it or hate it. There is no in-between and, judging from the letters, it was no different in 1976.

 

"I am the Monolith. I was around when there was suckage and I remain when there is great suckatude." So here's the plot. Something happens in the distant past... a cave man organizes a gang war and beats down his cave neighbors. Next thing you know a similar thing is happening in the distant future... a space man is organizing a gang war and beating down the neighboring planet. In the end the future guy dies and transforms into that fetus from the 2001 movie.

 

Someone should have made Jack Kirby actually read this stuff when he was sober. It doesn't even qualify as bad sci-fi. The dialogue is pathetic. The only high point is all of the classic Kriby art (if you like that stuff... and you really should). Mike Royer does a nice job of inking Kirby and giving it that "someone inked this with their index finger" feel you get from Kirby's 70s work.

 

Pros:

-- Great Kirby art. Lots of cool splash pages.

-- Nice inking by Mike Royer really letting Kirby come out.

-- It only lasted 7 issues.

 

Cons:

-- Everything else.

-- It lasted a whole 7 issues.

 

Issues 8-10

 

X-51, Mister Machine, Machine Man

I'm not sure if these were really that good but if you read the series all at once like I did they are light years better than 1-7.

 

The story is pretty standard. Robot gets created, becomes self-aware, runs away and gets chased. Nothing to get all excited about but some how it really works. I enjoyed the packing and the serial style of writing. Kirby and Royer art is solid. Obviously the story was a hit because Mister Machine went on to his own series (Machine Man) 6 months later.

 

These issues are worth picking up out of the dollar box for a decent read.

 

Pros:

-- More Kirby and Royer art.

-- X-51 is a compelling character.

-- Nice mix of sci-fi ans superhero.

 

Cons:

-- Typical poor Kirby dialog.

-- Only 3 issues long.

 

2001-A-Space-Odyssey.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'm curious to any opinions on whether Ghost rider helped or hindered this book???

 

Ghost Rider was the weakest character in the book. It was obvious that he was there just to draw in readers. It seems the only thing he did was show up, flame out, shoot some Hellfire at something, realize it didn't have any effect then get person_without_enough_empathyslapped into unconsciousness. Had this series come out 10 years later it would have been Wolverine instead of Ghost Rider.

 

(tsk):sumo:

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'm curious to any opinions on whether Ghost rider helped or hindered this book???

 

Ghost Rider was the weakest character in the book. It was obvious that he was there just to draw in readers. It seems the only thing he did was show up, flame out, shoot some Hellfire at something, realize it didn't have any effect then get person_without_enough_empathyslapped into unconsciousness. Had this series come out 10 years later it would have been Wolverine instead of Ghost Rider.

 

(tsk):sumo:

 

 

Disappointing, I know. Had this been in the 90s Ghost Rider would have been a chick with double-Ds, a costume with lots of pouches and a head band, and drawn by Rob Leifeld. His character in the Champions was for nothing more than selling more copies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What do you do when you want to woo Jack Kirby back to the House Of Ideas? Well, why not turn him loose and let him do any old thing he wants. That appears to be what Stan decided to do. The result...

Sadly that pretty much sums it up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

If you are taking requests, how about MTU between 30-50? I remember these as being really good for the most part, especially the ones where Spidey and company got stuck going back and forth in time on Doom's Time Platform. :cloud9:

 

At least they were really good when I was seven. That's what scares me about this thread. I'm afraid a lot of stuff I have such fond memories of . . . isn't so hot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not really taking requests, I'm just posting as I read them. It's pretty much going to be alphabetical. Right now I'm reading Chili. Yeah, you heard me... Chili. Fortunately it's a quick read and kind of entertaining.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At least the part where they visit Stan in the bullpen should be entertaining.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
28 28