Ok, what's the lowdown on Nedors?

[jbcomicbox]

here is a nice cover....

[adamstrange]

 

Best.

 

Cover.

 

Ever.

 

or at least close.

(thumbs u

[MrBedrock]

Best

 

Ingels

 

Wonder

 

cover

 

ever!

[spillred]

Best

 

Ingels

 

Wonder

 

cover

 

ever!

 

That's just ghastly

[spillred]

here is a nice cover....

It's OK, but it would look much better in my box

[rjpb]

Timelies suck on the inside.

 

I can't recall any Nedor with a decent interior (might be an exception for early Frazetta stories) but some Timelys, with Everett and S&K, is eminently non-sucky.

 

Nitpicker. Nedors with either Meskin or Moreira on Black Terror can be enjoyable.

 

For the art - but the stories still suck. I generally make an attempt to read any GA book I pick up, but when I had a few Nedors I gave up on trying to read them - painfully bad.

[kelholt]

here is a nice cover....

 

 

That is one beautiful book. The red on the cover is as strong as I've seen.

Wow!!

 

Also, I would have to agree that Nedor stories are just a tough read. I guess that's the nicest way I can say it. Some great covers and interior art, but the stories themselves......not so much.

 

[adamstrange]

Lovely

 

[nearmint]

Just sold that one. The new owner is very happy.

[djpinkpanther67]

Why does #5 state DC Comics on the slab? CGC labeling error?

[nearmint]

Yes. That book was slabbed very soon after CGC opened its doors.

[Flex Mentallo]

Best.

 

Cover.

 

Ever.

 

or at least close.

 

top 20, I suspect for me

 

Yeah, but you like that DC stuff so there's no accounting for taste.

 

If I had a copy it would defintely be in my top 5 ever. But since I dont have one I dont really rate it....In fact I'm not even jealous! (Well okay maybe just a tiny bit...)

[Flex Mentallo]

here is a nice cover....

It's OK, but it would look much better in my box

 

 

Cor blimey guv'nor (as we in England like to say every time we see something impossibly beautiful that we simply must have)

[Flex Mentallo]

Best

 

Ingels

 

Wonder

 

cover

 

ever!

 

 

Crikey! (as we in England say when we are really really jealous of Mr Bedrock, because we want all the Nedors and we dont have any!)

[G.A.tor]

Best.

 

Cover.

 

Ever.

 

or at least close.

 

top 20, I suspect for me

 

Yeah, but you like that DC stuff so there's no accounting for taste.

but I did include my copy in my "best 10" comics from that thread before...I did a seperate "best 10" for my DC's

so, it equals "top 20" (thumbs u

[Flex Mentallo]

Best.

 

Cover.

 

Ever.

 

or at least close.

 

top 20, I suspect for me

 

Yeah, but you like that DC stuff so there's no accounting for taste.

but I did include my copy in my "best 10" comics from that thread before...I did a seperate "best 10" for my DC's

so, it equals "top 20" (thumbs u

 

 

But where would it be in your top 20 overall?

[Old Fashion PB and J]

The lowdown on Nedor is this. Alex Ross sparked a fresh interest with project super powers. Low grade Black Terror and Fighting Yank books became desireable for a bit. The HG copies are sweet though, and have some wonderful covers.

 

The "Bender" from Futurama cover is ok, but wouldnt make top 50 for me personally. But I do appreciate how sharp and well preserved Cheetahs copy is. But GGA doesnt do a thing for me.