Are "acid-free" backing boards truly acid-free? Time to pH test & find out!
28 28

414 posts in this topic

mschmidt   
  • Member
  • 19,841 posts
  • Location: Illinoise

Discussions about the safety of various comic book storage supplies seem to crop up on this board relatively frequently, so I figured it was about time to put on the science googles and actually test a bunch of different backing boards in order to see which are truly archival-safe - and which, to put it nicely, don't quite live up their manufacturers' lofty claims.

 

Why is this important, you might ask? Well, as the paper in our beloved comic books ages, it generates a whole slew of deteriorative by-products/contaminants - most of which are highly acidic. The acids actually speed up paper degradation, so it's a rather vicious circle - as the acids build up within the paper, the production of new acids is greatly accelerated. If this build-up isn't stopped (or neutralized), the acids will eventually eat through the very molecular bonds that hold the paper fibers together - and all you'll be left with are brittle pages that turn to dust when handled.

 

Enter ... huzzah! ... archival storage solutions that slow down & impede this process.

 

In order for an item to be considered "safe for archival storage" (or "archival-safe"), it needs to be infused with a 3-5% alkaline buffer throughout (this buffer is typically calcium carbonate, CaCO3) which serves to absorb & neutralize the deteriorative by-products generated by the paper as it ages, and it also needs have an alkaline pH (eg. be acid-free).

 

Even though the terms "acid-free" and "archival-safe" are used interchangeably by the backing board manufacturers, they're not the same thing - acid-free means that your item was initially manufactured with a pH of 7 (neutral) or slightly above (alkaline). But as this does not guarantee that your item won't become acidic at a later date, a much more apt description would be "acid-free at time of manufacture".

 

For a much more in-depth explanation, check out this article on the Conservation Resources website:

Archival Papers

 

Anyway ... with that said, let's start testing to see which backing boards live up to these criteria.

 

__________________________________________________________________________________________

 

Test specifics:

 

overview-phtester.jpg

 

- Test were performed with a standard pHydrion pH pencil with distilled water.

- I used two different pH pencils - one pencil for the top line on each board, one pencil for the bottom line.

- All boards were cut in half, so I could test both the front & the back.

- All boards marked as "New" were taken from the middle of an unopened pack.

- Each test was allowed to sit for 15 seconds, then immediately scanned.

 

A small note about pH: 7 or thereabouts is neutral with everything below that considered acidic. The pH scale is a logarithmic progression based on the power of ten - so an item with a pH of 5 would be 10 times more acidic than an item with a pH of 6, and 100 times more acidic than an item with a pH of 7.

 

__________________________________________________________________________________________

 

Items tested:

 

The description under each item is from either the manufacturers' website or their packaging.

 

overview.jpg

 

Not shown in this photo - the Bill Cole Life-X-Tenders, the Bill Cole Thin-X-Tenders, and the BCW Extenders. Couldn't find the packaging for these, unfortunately.

 

1a) BCW's standard board (New)

1b) BCW's standard board (Used, 1 1/2 - 2 years old)

"24 point solid bleached sulfate"

"Coated on one side with a buffered with 3% calcium carbonate" (can't help but wonder if they jumbled up this description on purpose)

"Certified acid free - independent lab tested"

 

2) BCW's Extender (New)

"Will help prevent yellowing, retards the aging process, and absorbs and neutralizes the contaminants in comic book pages"

"Coated on 2 sides"

"Certified acid free - independent lab tested".

 

3) Ultra-Pro's standard board (New)

"Archival quality - acid free"

"24 point board stock, White, coated on one side"

"100% Archival Safe"

 

4) Hotflips' Comic Vision board (New)

"24 pt. board, coated one side"

"Archival quality" (on packaging)

"100% archival safe" (on website)

The old packaging for this board described it as being "acid-free" - this has been removed from the new packaging (as it should be).

 

5) Miller Hobby's standard board (New)

"24 point solid bleached sulfate, coated on one side"

"Acid free"

"Can be used for archival matting, mounting, and backing"

 

6a) E Gerber's Half-Back (New)

6b) E Gerber's Half-Back (Used, 1 1/2 - 2 years old)

"24 mil, acid-free, 3% buffered backing board"

"Meets strict U.S. Government standards for archival storage"

"3% calcium carbonate buffer throughout, maintains a neutral pH"

 

7) Bill Cole's Thin-X-Tender (New)

"24 mil thick acid free backing board"

"Archival quality protection"

"Impregnated with a calcium buffer resulting in an acid free, alkaline pH content of 8.5 throughout"

 

8) Bill Cole's Life-X-Tender (New)

"30 mil thick 3 layer board consisting of an activated charcoal layer (absorbs and neutralizes pollutants and by products of comic book paper) sandwiched between two acid free backing boards"

 

9) Old Board 2

Unknown age and unknown manufacturer.

 

Just for fun I also tested two pieces of Micro Chamber Paper - one was brand-new, and one has been sitting inside the front cover of the Megaton #3 CGC 9.2 shown in the picture above (as that was an old red label modern and CGC changed their labels back in 2003, that piece has been in use for at least 7-8 years).

 

__________________________________________________________________________________________

 

Test images:

 

Everything was scanned on my trusty Epson Perfection 3200 with no corrections done in Photoshop. As I realize it might be hard to make out shades on a computer screen, I took the liberty of writing down the pH value that, to the best of my vision skills, corresponds to the colored strip on the board.

 

phtestresults.jpg

 

__________________________________________________________________________________________

 

Test results:

 

As was to be expected, of the new boards every single coated backing board (BCW, Ultra-Pro, Miller Hobby and Comic Vision) failed the acid-free test - the coated/shiny side was in every case either pH neutral or pretty close to it, but this was offset by the heavy acidity of the uncoated side.

 

In contrast, every single buffered board (E Gerber and Bill Cole) passed the acid-free test - on these boards, both sides were pH neutral (or slightly alkaline), and as these boards are buffered throughout (not coated), the entire board can therefore be considered acid-free.

 

In regards to the used boards, the contrast between a coated & a buffered board is strikingly evident - whilst the 2-year old E Gerber half-back shows hardly any change in its surface pH, the shiny coating on the 2-year old BCW backing board has broken down & both the front and the back of the board is now acidic.

 

Even more telling is the measurements on the used "unknown board" - as you can see from the scan, the back of this board was heavily yellowed/tanned, and had a ghost-like impression from whichever comic book had been placed in front of it. Yet the pH values were very similar to the ones taken from the 2-year old BCW board which showed no external signs of degradation. As such, it's pretty safe to assume that just because a coated backing board isn't yellowed or nasty, doesn't mean that it isn't acidic.

 

One thing I found particularly interesting was the test of the Micro Chamber Paper (MCP) - even though the used piece had been absorbing the acids from a comic book for 7-8 years, the alkaline reserve in the paper hadn't diminished noticeably and there was no evidence that this paper was now "inert". This doesn't mean that the MCP will last forever - but it does show that CGC's estimate of a 7 year lifespan is probably on the rather conservative side.

 

__________________________________________________________________________________________

 

Conclusion:

 

The manufacturers/dealers who claim that their regular, coated-on-one-side backing boards are "acid-free", "archival quality", "archival-safe" or "acid-neutral" are either lying or misinformed.

 

These boards are all, at best, "acid-free on one side at time of manufacture" which tells you that at some point some part of this particular board was rendered acid-free, but that the rest of the board will happily contribute to the acidic environment inside your (sealed) comic book bag.

 

This does not mean that your comic book will spontaneously combust if it's put inside a bag with one of these boards - but it does mean, without a shadow of a doubt, that these boards will actively contribute, on a molecular level, to the decay of your comic book from the moment they're placed inside the bag.

 

As a matter of fact, it would be safer for your comic book to store them in a bag without a coated backing board.

 

Think of this way: if you treat just one side of a piece of wood with a water-proof sealer and then put the wood in a bucket of water, will the water not damage the wood? The water-proof sealer on the one side will certainly halt the destruction, but, ultimately, the water will thoroughly penetrate the wood.

 

So, in conclusion: The only true archival-safe (and acid-free) backing boards in this test are the buffered boards manufactured by E Gerber & Bill Cole.

 

__________________________________________________________________________________________

 

"Pants on fire" Award for the BCW Extenders:

 

liar-liar-pants-on-fire.jpg

 

Even though both sides of this board tested to be pH neutral, the BCW Extender is simply a thinner version of the regular BCW backing board which is then coated on both sides (not buffered throughout) with a thin alkaline solution. As such, the BCW claim that this board will "prevent yellowing, person_having_a_hard_time_understanding_my_point the aging process, and absorb and neutralize the contaminants in comic book pages" is complete & utter bogus.

 

What makes this particularly griveous is BCW's claim that you should use these Extenders like Micro Chamber Paper - eg. place two of them inside each book, one behind the front cover, one in front of the back cover. Considering the thin coating on the BCW Extender will wear off over time, what you're going to end up with is a pair of highly acidic time bombs, destroying your comic book from the inside.

 

And this doesn't even take into the account the 10 mil thickness of the Extenders which is almost certain to cause undue stress on the staples, and could eventually lead to the staples being torn out of the paper.

 

Shame on you, BCW.

 

(And thanks to grinin for the info on the BCW Extenders).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


kdoginohio   
  • Member: Seasoned Veteran
  • 11,305 posts
  • Location: Behind You!

"There's a board in Daddy's arm were all the money goes"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
sckao   
  • Member: Seasoned Veteran
  • 15,280 posts
  • Location: San Francisco Bay Area
:applause:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Boozad   
  • Member: Seasoned Veteran
  • 21,990 posts
  • Location: England.
"Pants on fire" Award for the BCW Extenders:

 

liar-liar-pants-on-fire.jpg

 

lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
maloney414   
  • Member
  • 4,025 posts
  • Location: WTB Custom Title

Mr. Wizard would be proud! Cool experiment. (thumbs u

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
thunderstick   
  • Member
  • 421 posts
  • Location: Vancouver, BC

Many thanks for conducting these invaluable tests. I was in the process of searching for methods to actually test the boards I just started using, myself.

 

Your test results are no surprise to me, at all. These are all made in china. Say no more?

 

I'm fortunate that my books spent decades in unboarded bags. I just started using boards a few weeks ago, and as such, your tests confirm my suspicions all along.

 

Unless I see some tests that contradict yours, mschmidt, the boards are all being permanently removed.

 

Thanks again for providing such a thorough test.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BeachBum   
  • Member: Seasoned Veteran
  • 12,225 posts
  • Location: Stay 9.8 thirsty my friends.

Thanks for the report Mike.

 

I put everything in Gerber MyLite 2, but I use both Half-Backs and Bill Cole Thin-X-Tenders for backing boards. Glad to see they both passed with flying colors.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Conan_Aficionado   
  • Member
  • 5,372 posts
  • Location: LAND OF SAVAGES

This is great!!!

 

I think this pretty much proves that E. Gerber products are the best.

 

I think this is great information for the high end collector, but what does someone like myself with a small not too valuable a collection do.

 

My question is at what point is my comic collection worthy of being Gerberized. Most of my comics are coppers and early 90's drek. I have maybe 200 comics worth over $5 bucs, 100 over $10 and maybe 30 comics over $20(of about 1000 in total). What's worthy? Granted my collection is small enough that i can Gerberize everything over $5. (you serious collectors stop laughing at me...lol)

 

Another question, is it the board acids that interact with the comic of the acids that the inks and cheap paper in the comic that interact with the boards? Seems to me whether you board or not, the comic itself is probably releasing more acid than the board. Eight years ago I purchased new boards to replace the old ones. I only got around to doing about 100 or so and still had an open pack of boards that remained unused for nearly eight years. To my surprise, the boards remained relatively white compared to the ones that were used eight years ago.

 

I've spent the last couple of weeks rebagging and boarding my comics and came up with some conclusions. I would rather have them in bags than not in bags. I would rather have them supported with boards than not with boards and store the comic to the coated side rather than to the uncoated dull side. Of course, it seems prudent and wise to rebag/board every few years. Call me ignorant, and i'm sure you will, but for my personal collection, I've seen little side effects leaving them in the same bag and board for 10 years or more.

 

As a matter of fact one thing that disturbed me was the one comic in my collection that was stored in a mylar and was maintained in the same mylar for the last 15 years had tanned somewhat. It was a mylar without the folding flap, it was open ended. The top of the comic had started to brown/tan and the top of the pages of the comic had also tanned. I think air might have something serious to do with tanning pages more so than the board.

 

This was my recent experience rebagging about 1/2 of my small collection.

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jayman   
  • Member
  • 13,524 posts
  • Location: NJ (The Home of Comics!)
Discussions about the safety of various comic book storage supplies seem to crop up on this board relatively frequently, so I figured it was about time to put on the science googles...

 

Great report but those science googles are a bit strange! :baiting:

108476.jpg.8dfe8c1db9e45417c33e9aacc2509914.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Green   
  • Member: Seasoned Veteran
  • 13,223 posts
  • Location: Begging AND Choosing

I came to the conclusion all boards were acid free. My test was licking them and waiting an hour.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
thunderstick   
  • Member
  • 421 posts
  • Location: Vancouver, BC
I came to the conclusion all boards were acid free. My test was licking them and waiting an hour.

lol Those were the days.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
28 28

  • Welcome! Sign up and jump in!

    Membership and use of the boards is FREE! The knowledge available on these boards about comic collecting is an amazing resource for less experienced collectors. It's also a great place to talk about expert comic collecting topics with other experienced collectors. We hope that you find what you came looking for here, but more than that, we hope you find your new comic collecting home.

    Don't let the friendly banter and close knit community put you off. You're only a few posts from being part of the gang!

    After you sign up, introduce yourself! We'd love to know more about your collecting.

  • Upcoming Events

    • 17 November 2017 04:00 AM Until 25 November 2017 04:00 AM
      0  
      Visit the "Official 2017 CGC Chat Boards Holiday Gift Exchange Sign-Up Thread" for all the details.
      CLICK HERE FOR LINK
      But clicking is a lot of work, so for those interested, the details can be found below.

       
      Welcome to the 2017 CGC Chat Boards Gift Exchange
      For those who are new to the Program or otherwise have a very bad memory, the idea is simple. Basically you will give a gift to a fellow board member, and also receive a gift yourself from a different boardie. This way, each person will get to interact with two fellow boardies in the Gift Exchange Program. It does not matter what seasonal Holiday you celebrate, what creed or religion you claim, this Gift Exchange is more about giving and getting a gift than celebrating a specific holiday. We are celebrating comics and our community. Times may currently be tough for some, but it is worth pausing to recognize the importance the CGC community brings to each of you.
      Some Details on the Gift Exchange Program
      How much should my gift be for? Up to you. There are people that send gifts that have values that are all over the place. $15-20? Sure. $50-$100? Sure. You are certainly welcome to send more expensive gifts, but the gift should be worth at least $15. Lots of people just give something from their own collection, so the cost is negligible.
      Does my gift have to be new? No
      Does it have to be comic related? Yes
      Am I supposed to sign who my gift was from? Yes, you should - your identity is only secret till they open their gift.
      Do I have to wrap my gift in a Holiday fashion? Yes. Extra points for wrapping it in the Sunday Comics
      Am I supposed to wait until Christmas to open my gift? Yes, unless you celebrate another holiday in which case, follow your traditional holiday gift opening program
      How will I know who I am Santa for? You will receive a PM your recipients details once sign up is over.
      When is sign up over? Friday, November 24th at 11pm (ET).
      PMs with your Secret Santa information will be sent out over the weekend. Everyone who signs up will have their PM by Sunday night (11/26).
      What if I miss sign up but want to participate? PM me, we will try to work something out.
      What if I never receive my gift? There will be people who will be assigned as a back up Santa. Everyone who signs up will get a gift... sooner or later.
      Who is eligible to participate? You are eligible if you registered for the CGC boards before November 9th, 2016 and/or have a post count of at least 150 by November 9, 2017, provided that you are a member in good standing with the community, i.e., not on the CGC Chat Board Marketplace Probation List.
      (This way, those who have become active members of the CGC Chat Boards after the change in Feb. 2016 may still participate.)
      What and when is the Holiday raffle? People will be donating comic related prizes that will be given away after the Holiday is over in a blind drawing. More details about that will be in another thread.
      Participating in the exchange does not automatically enter you into the raffle. Anyone who wants to be part of the raffle must donate an item. This assures everyone who joins is guaranteed to receive a prize. If you don't join in with the gift exchange, but would still like to join in with the raffle, just donate a prize to the raffle and you'll be entered. Not participating in the gift exchange? Not donating a prize for the raffle? That's okay, as well
      If you decide, after submitting the form, that you would like to donate something simply bump our PM.
      The rules are simple, but need to be followed to make sure everyone who signs up gets a present by Christmas. If you sign up, please follow through and don't wait until after the fact to fulfill your duties. 
      To officially "sign-up" Fill out the questions below then PM this info (cut and paste fashion) to me... HollyJollyOne <---- linked here 
      ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      **Please make sure to create the PM with your BOARD NAME AND 2017 as the title.**
      CGC Board name:
      Real name:
      Mailing address:
      Collecting preferences (what you might like to receive):
      Who were you Santa for last year:
      Who was your Santa last year:
      Would you be willing to ship to board members outside the United States?
      Do you live outside the United States? If yes, what's the fastest way for your Santa to ship to you?:
      Would you like to participate in the CGC Holiday Raffle?
      What is that Raffle Gift? (description and/or url with a link to the item)
      Would you be willing to be a back up Santa in case some cannot follow through?
      ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      And that's all there is to it!
      Happy Holidays everyone!
    • 02 December 2017 03:00 PM Until 04 December 2017 01:00 AM
      2  

      Check out the Rules/Tips/FAQs as well as the VCC XXXVIII Discussion thread for more details on the changes that are occurring to the look and feel of the VCC.
      Make certain to bookmark The VCC Convention Hall and check us out Saturday December 2nd - Sunday December 3rd right here on the CGC Chat Boards.
      We hope to see both new and old faces in attendance for the final show of 2017.