Man, it's slow here..Grade this one..

[uclapeterg]

see, Goliath sees the same "creasing" that I see in the scan too..

[murph0]

It's slightly blunted..but there's no crease anywhere.. it's so slight you have to use the magnification scan to pick it up..guess that's one of the negatives of such a large scan..it overemphasizes points that aren't a big deal otherwise.

 

Brian

 

P.S. Is that your DD 1 9.0?

[drbanner]

These "grade this mo' fo'!" posts are great fun Murph, but so far they've all had various case scratches, been scanned in the bag showing various foreign debris, the case on this book was cracked, and your scanner has a bit of schmeg on it. In order to make these useful, you really should delineate any defects on the book, and point out which defects that "appear" in the scan aren't on the book...

[uclapeterg]

yes, Brian, it is my DD1.

 

I'll probably post all the books I have up on here sometime this weekend to give everyone a fair chance.

 

Thanks for noticing.

 

[CosmicBob]

Looking at the top, it looks like there is a crinkle in the cover. I would give it a 9.0.

 

But after reading the rest of the thread, if it's not a crinkle, I would give it a 9.4, possibly a 9.6.

[murph0]

Hey..so my cases have scratches on them..not much I can do about it. The problem here is the scan was jsut too big so it caused some maverick lines that don't exist on the actual book

Will you sell that DD 1 9.0 for a little over 3,000, Discount?

 

Brian

[drbanner]

my cases have scratches on them..not much I can do about it. The problem here is the scan was jsut too big so it caused some maverick lines that don't exist on the actual book

 

That's not a problem...the problem is you are asking us to grade a book with "apparent" defects that aren't really on the book, but you're not telling us they're not on the book! Capice?

[murph0]

I already said the white spots weren't on the book..I didn't even notice the crinkley part no idea how that happened.

 

Brian

[drbanner]

Ok...got any NM Hulks 102-200 for sale?

[greggy]

Ok...got any NM Hulks 102-200 for sale?

 

You disappoint me doc. Why haven't you completed your flagship run yet?

[murph0]

Just a NM+ 181.

 

Brian

[drbanner]

I'll buy NM Hulks all day long...doubles, triples, does it really matter when you're talking about the pre-eminent comic book title of the last 40 years?? I think not!

 

BTW, what about you?

 

How much for the NM+ Murph (is that a Murph grade, or a CGC grade anyhow)?

[greggy]

Yo, I had my beauties on display on my last CGC list. Of course I took in $1,375 for those 4 Hulk books but that's another story!

 

The rest of my numbers are not NM otherwise they would be graded. Actually, some of the later 100s may be but what do you have that I want?

[murph0]

heh, I'm just kidding..I do have two copies of the book one is VF the other is probable VF/NM to NM-. I don't own any other Hulk books b/c I never really liked the way the books read

 

Brian

[drbanner]

Allright, you're off the hook...but lmk if you want to sell/trade the 181.

[murph0]

I would be willing to part with the VF copy.

 

Brian