5th Annual March Madness CGC Grading Tournament- Seeding Round

[Nostalgic Attic]

I think the reason you have to put your team name in the PM is that NA is using emailed copies of them instead. An unread PM doesn't matter. Right NA?

 

Oh, and grades sent!

 

That is correct...I haven't had a chance to respond to all PM's...there are alot of teams and grades are pouring in.

[Max Carnage]

I think the reason you have to put your team name in the PM is that NA is using emailed copies of them instead. An unread PM doesn't matter. Right NA?

 

Oh, and grades sent!

 

That is correct...I haven't had a chance to respond to all PM's...there are alot of teams and grades are pouring in.

 

Thanks - I just made the Subject "Grades" but the team name is in the message itself.

 

David

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Just sent mine!

 

[Wilson3d]

Just sent mine!

 

[SolitaireOne]

Seeding grades begrudgingly sent...

 

[musicmeta]

Working late, but I just sent my grades in..Had to grade fast..Uhh! I doubt I make the cut this year!

[Loki]

Almost forgot about this... Last minute grades sent!

[Rob]

Grades in!

[Nostalgic Attic]

2 hours left...unnofficial count is 63 players so far......

[Aces]

2 hours left...unnofficial count is 63 players so far......

So number 1 might get a 1st round bye...

[drewincanada]

Make that 64.

 

Got my grades in under the wire. Five minutes, 10 grades. About 30 seconds per book.

 

I hadn't been reading the thread in CG, so I didn't know the books had been posted here. I kept looking in the "Spare a Grade" forum and figured the contest hadn't started yet.

[marmat]

And the results are.........

[Nostalgic Attic]

65 teams this year

 

 

We will have one play-in game for the #64 and 65 ranked teams.

 

I will be establishing the rankings today and will post the play-in game in this thread.

 

Here are the grades for the Seeding books:

 

CTK #47 W 9.6

Defenders #34 OWW 8

Fantastic Four #55 OWW 9.0

Fantastic Four #61 OWW 8.5

Incredible Hulk #118 COW 7.5

Jungle Action #6 W 9.2

Master of Kung Fu #18 Cr-OW 9.0

Strange Tales #147 W 9.2

Thor #132 OWW 9.0

TOS #70 OWW 7.0

 

[Nostalgic Attic]

I modified the scoring on the original post. Please take note. (I had copied and pasted a scoring system from 2 years ago and it was updated last year):

 

Spot on= 3 wins

Within .5= 2 wins

Not within .5 = 1 loss

Not within 1= 2 losses

Bonus= The third spot on grade will be granted 1 bonus win, fourth= 2 bonus wins, fifth through tenth= 3 bonus wins.

 

[Nostalgic Attic]

Below are the teams who I have recorded grades for (in no particular order). If you submitted grades and don't see your name, please shoot me a PM.

 

joeklecko- NE

Cimm- SE

Prodigy 44- NE

Oakman 29- SW

trmoore54- SW

Shadow- NE

Pirate- SE

Jessebrook1- SE

Etanick- SE

MARMAT- NE

TSIMANGA- NW

Zuckuss2003- NE

Max Carnage- NE

TheGeneral- SW

Aces- NE

Hibou- NW

comicdonna- NE

Black Lantern- NE

Aszumilo- SW

porky- NE

Designer Toast- NW

Trev- SW

Columbia Comics

Liaton 9000- NW

divad- NW

sckao- SW

Jeffro- NE

s-man- NE

Flee-Marquette- SE

AlexH- NE

Dr. Balls- NW

ckp1680- SW

WEBHEAD- NE

Jeffreykli- NW

Wilson3d- SW

B3AST- SE

Warlord- NE

maloney414- NE

ARK- NW

thirdgreenham- NE

genrizod

spideyfan76- NE

BorderlineHoarder- SE

mldynes- SW

Dice X- NW

Toro- NE

eeb03- SE

AJD- SW

BlowUpTheMoon- NE

JazzMan- NW

Burntboy- NE

thehumantorch- NW

Theagenes- SW

Canickus- SW

Solitaireone- NE

Arcade- SW

Musicmeta- SE

Flatrock02- NW

Loki- NW

Rob- NE

Dollarbill- SW

grinin- SE

Comicdey- NW

DrewinCanada- NE

frankbearss- SW

 

[drewincanada]

I modified the scoring on the original post. Please take note. (I had copied and pasted a scoring system from 2 years ago and it was updated last year):

 

Spot on= 3 wins

Within .5= 2 wins

Not within .5 = 1 loss

Not within 1= 2 losses

Bonus= The third spot on grade will be granted 1 bonus win, fourth= 2 bonus wins, fifth through tenth= 3 bonus wins.

 

 

So much for grading on the fly.

One spot on.

Four within .5

One not with .5

And... yikes... four not within 1

 

Final score: 2

 

I suspect I'll be participating in the play-in game.

[Black Lantern]

Wow, I think I will be at the bottom of the list. I undergraded last year so I though I wouldn't have to grade to strict this time, only to get punched in the face again because now I overgraded most of them.

[marmat]

I dont remember last year rules, if a books is a 9.6 and I gave 9.2, I am within .5 or not? I guess not, but please feel free to confirm

[Comicdey]

I graded 7 quickly via iPhone and random guessed on the last three I couldn't see images for....definately won't be the top seed going in.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Final score: 2

 

I suspect I'll be participating in the play-in game.