6th Annual March Madness CGC Grading Tournament-Round of 12

[BlowUpTheMoon]

 

Answer Key

 

CAP - 9.6

DD - 8.5

TFC - 5.5

WW - 8.5

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

1. sckao 48

5. pirate 37

 

3. oakman29 22

7. boboset 40

 

9. s-man 39

4. toro 55

 

3. porky 45

7. ARK 43

 

1. tsimanga 68

13. mydynes 53

 

6. Jeffreykli 43

8. comicdey 62

 

[oakman29]

My only hope is boboset sucked it too.

Guess I got my answer. Congrats bobo I'm rooting for ya'.

[Comicdey]

Tasty freeze ate my lunch

[Mike's Rack]

1. sckao 48

5. pirate 37

 

3. oakman29 22

7. boboset 40

 

9. s-man 39

4. toro 55

 

3. porky 45

7. ARK 43

 

1. tsimanga 68

13. mydynes 53

 

6. Jeffreykli 43

8. comicdey 62

[sckao]

 

Wow. comicdey is on FIRE!

 

Congrats Tsimanga for the high score this round.

 

 

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Tasty freeze ate my lunch

 

Tastee-Freeze ate almost every bodies lunch. Seven out of 12 contestants took a -5 on the book.

[sckao]

What is wrong with that book?

 

 

[Comicdey]

Wow. comicdey is on FIRE!

 

Congrats Tsimanga for the high score this round.

 

 

 

Looks like one of us is going home next round. Lucky you

[Comicdey]

I said 7.0 on it. Guess I should have looked closer

[BlowUpTheMoon]

What is wrong with that book?

 

 

If you look at the BC alone, you can see it has medium tanning. Compare the whiteness of the ice cream cone to the outer edges and you'll see a huge difference.

 

If you compare the BC of the TFC to the other three books, you'll see how bad it really is.

[Comicdey]

Yeah. Bad ice cream comic. I thought It was tapioca

[Boboset]

My only hope is boboset sucked it too.

Guess I got my answer. Congrats bobo I'm rooting for ya'.

 

Thanks Oak! I'll need all the help getting out of the next round.

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

I'll have the next round up later tonight, after the Sabres beat Pittsburgh.

[Boboset]

 

[thehumantorch]

1. sckao 48

5. pirate 37

 

3. oakman29 22

7. boboset 40

 

9. s-man 39

4. toro 55

 

3. porky 45

7. ARK 43

 

1. tsimanga 68

13. mydynes 53

6. Jeffreykli 43

8. comicdey 62

 

I love these contests but we lose so many good graders and guys I like every round.

 

Alas, parting is such sweet sorrow.

[porky]

Tasty freeze ate my lunch

 

Tastee-Freeze ate almost every bodies lunch. Seven out of 12 contestants took a -5 on the book.

 

man... i have a beauty of a DD37 with the same pq that's an 8.0. i knew it was gonna take a hit, but i didn't know it would be that bad.

[porky]

how did the cap not get hit harder with that dust shadow on the right front cover? i had it 9.4-9.6 to begin with, then noticed the shadow and lowered it down to a 9.2

[Boboset]

1. sckao 48

5. pirate 37

 

3. oakman29 22

7. boboset 40

 

9. s-man 39

4. toro 55

 

3. porky 45

7. ARK 43

 

1. tsimanga 68

13. mydynes 53

6. Jeffreykli 43

8. comicdey 62

 

I love these contests but we lose so many good graders and guys I like every round.

 

Alas, parting is such sweet sorrow.

 

+1

 

Signed, Ryan, who has the lowest score to advance past this round and yet has the nerve to send a trash talk photo to his next opponent.

[oakman29]

That F-ing Tastee Freeze book.