CGC Green Eggs Grading Contest Round 1 Results

[Timely]

I am really really really surprised that the Batman 17 is a 3.5. I gave it a 2.0

 

I gave it a 2.5 myself, so personally I do not think you are too far off the mark. (thumbs u

[marmat]

I am really really really surprised that the Batman 17 is a 3.5. I gave it a 2.0

 

I gave it a 2.5 myself, so personally I do not think you are too far off the mark. (thumbs u

 

I am sure that the same book, if resubmitted 100 times, will gets 99 2.5 or worse.

I have a WDCS 1 at CGC right now and I was hoping for a 3.0, but after seeing the Batman 17, I hope to get a 5.0 at least

 

Moral of the story, buy the book, not the label

[Anfield Fox]

I am really really really surprised that the Batman 17 is a 3.5. I gave it a 2.0

 

I gave it a 2.5 myself, so personally I do not think you are too far off the mark. (thumbs u

 

You can't anymore grade now you've left CGC.

 

P.S. I gave it a 2.5 as well

[Twistty1]

How the Frick did half the people here give the Avengers 6 8.5 or higher with all the chipping at the bottom!?

Come on! You guys are suppose be better than eBay graders.

 

Because it was cut off and looked like a little bit of rippling of a slightly over hanging cover to me.

 

I have 8.0s in my collection that have that. I couldn't tell it was chipping without my microscope. Ill be more scrutinizing next round. (thumbs u

[youfoundjake]

Was it a stain or chipping on the 6?

[Hado]

Round 1 is best left forgotten.

Speak for yourself. For one brief shining moment I'm ahead of board heavyweights like Toro.

This may be the only round I'll want to remember!

 

+1

[Arkham]

Wow. That's not the result I was expecting to see.

[youfoundjake]

Was it a stain or chipping on the 6?

anyone?

[thirdgreenham]

chip chip chipping

 

[youfoundjake]

chip chip chipping

I freaking knew it!!