• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

The DEGREE of KEY (or books on your KEY list)
2 2

111 posts in this topic

These are tops on my want list

Golden-I will probably never own any of these.

 

1- Detective Comics #27

2-Batman #1

3-Reform School Girls

4- All-American Comics #16

 

Silver-The last seven big Silver keys I need.

 

1-Fantastic Four #1

2-X-Men #1

3-Tales to Astonish #27

4-Daredevil #1

5-Strange Tales #110

6-Brave and Bold #28

7-Showcase #4

Bronze -Only need these three to have all major,minor Bronze keys

 

1.-All Star Western #10

2-Vampirella #1

3-Iron Man #55

 

Copper-If you can't tell which book I'm focusing in on in the Copper age.

 

1- Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #1

2-Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #1

3-Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #1

4-Albedo #2

 

Modern

1-Walking Dead #1

2- Batman Adventures #12

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Golden

 

(1) DC #27

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

 

Silver

 

(1) AF #15

(2) ASM #14

(3) Hulk #1

(4) Xmen #1

(5) TOS #39

 

Bronze

 

(1) Hulk #181

(2) ASM #129

(3) GSXM #1

(4) ASM #121

(5) Marvel Spotlight #5

 

Copper

 

(1) TMNT #1

(2) TMNT #2

(3) ASM #300

(4) Iron Fist #14 35 cent

(5)

 

Modern

 

(1) Walking Dead #1

(2) Walking Dead #2

(3) Walking Dead #3

(4) Walking Dead #100

(5) Sixth Gun #1

 

:whee:

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Golden

 

(1) Action Comics #1

(2) Detective Comics #27

(3) Marvel Comics #1

(4) Superman #1

(5) Batman #1

 

Hard to argue anything different. Maybe...just maybe Captain America #1 over Marvel Comics #1.

 

Silver

 

(1) Amazing Fantasy #15

(2) Fantastic Four #1

(3) Showcase #4

(4) Incredible Hulk #1

(5) Brave & the Bold #28

 

I think the first four are written in stone. Number 5 is a wild card that could have gone a lot of different ways: Adventure #247, X-Men #1, Amazing Spider-Man #1, Tales of Suspense #39, Journey into Mystery #83, or even Avengers #1.

 

Bronze

 

(1) Incredible Hulk #181

(2) Giant Size X-Men #1

(3) Amazing Spider-Man #121

(4) Amazing Spider-Man #129

(5) House of Secrets #92

 

This list would be dominated by Marvel in my opinion. So many great books to choose from of fairly equal significance and value. Other contenders might be Green Lantern #76, Batman #227 and #232, All-Star Western #10, X-Men #94, many more.

 

Copper and Modern are practically worthless to me, though I'd probably throw out New Mutants #98 and Walking Dead #1 as the top of the crop.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Golden

 

(1) Action Comics #1

(2) Detective Comics #27

(3) Superman #1

(4) Batman #1

(5) Captain America Comics #1

 

Silver

 

(1) Amazing Fantasy #15

(2) Fantastic Four #1

(3) Avengers #1

(4) Amazing Spider-Man #1

(5) Journey Into Mystery #83

 

Bronze

 

(1) Incredible Hulk #181

(2) Amazing Spider-Man #129

(3) Giant Size X-Men #1

(4) Iron Man #55

(5) Amazing Spider-Man #121

 

Looks generic when it's typed out like this hm

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'll play. :smile:

Golden Age:

  1. Action Comics #1
  2. Detective Comics #27
  3. Superman #1
  4. Batman #1
  5. Captain America Comics #1

Silver Age:

  1. Amazing Fantasy #15
  2. Fantastic Four #1
  3. Iron Man #1
  4. Thor #126
  5. The Incredible Hulk #1

Bronze Age:

  1. The Incredible Hulk #181
  2. Doctor Strange Vol. 2 #1
  3. Black Panther #1
  4. Giant-Size X-Men #1
  5. Iron Man #55

Copper Age:

  1. The Dark Knight Returns #1
  2. The Dark Knight Returns #2
  3. The Dark Knight Returns #3
  4. The Dark Knight Returns #4
  5. The Killing Joke

Modern Age:

  1. Spawn #1
  2. Superman Vol. 2 #75
  3. Infinity Gauntlet #1
  4. Avengers Vol. 4 #12
  5. Guardians of the Galaxy #1

Some really tough calls... :flamed:

Edited by TwoPiece
Hulk #1 is Silver.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, TwoPiece said:

I'll play. :smile:

Golden Age:

  1. Action Comics #1
  2. Detective Comics #27
  3. Superman #1
  4. Batman #1
  5. Captain America Comics #1

Silver Age:

  1. Amazing Fantasy #15
  2. Fantastic Four #1
  3. Avengers #1
  4. Iron Man #1
  5. Thor #126

Bronze Age:

  1. The Incredible Hulk #1
  2. Doctor Strange Vol. 2 #1
  3. Black Panther #1
  4. Giant-Size X-Men #1
  5. Iron Man #55

Copper Age:

  1. The Dark Knight Returns #1
  2. The Dark Knight Returns #2
  3. The Dark Knight Returns #3
  4. The Dark Knight Returns #4
  5. The Killing Joke

Modern Age:

  1. Spawn #1
  2. Superman Vol. 2 #75
  3. Infinity Gauntlet #1
  4. Avengers Vol. 4 #12
  5. Guardians of the Galaxy #1

Some really tough calls... :flamed:

I dont agree on so many levels.

For one Hulk #1 is a Silver Age key so I agree it goes in the S.A. category. 

Besides GSX 1, and IM 55 your bronze category is empty.

Copper age is a miss , maybe Killing Joke.

Modern? I dont agree , thank God I really dont care. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, oakman29 said:

I dont agree on so many levels.

For one Hulk #1 is a Silver Age key so I agree it goes in the S.A. category. 

Besides GSX 1, and IM 55 your bronze category is empty.

Copper age is a miss , maybe Killing Joke.

Modern? I dont agree , thank God I really dont care. 

:pullhair:

I accidentally read "181" as "1" when looking at other lists. I was pretty sure it's Silver.

These are the books I want, you jabroni!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, TwoPiece said:

:pullhair:

I accidentally read "181" as "1" when looking at other lists. I was pretty sure it's Silver.

These are the books I want, you jabroni!

Oh I'm sorry I didn't even read the threads title. I'm such a dummy. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, oakman29 said:

Oh I'm sorry I didn't even read the threads title. I'm such a dummy. 

lol

I'm not all about first appearances (somewhat obvious from my list). I like self-titled #1 issues more.

TDKR series is at the top of my Copper Age list over potentially "valuable" books.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Okay so now that I know what this is I will play too!

Golden Age

1.Detective 27 (ultimate grail)

2. Batman 1

3. Captain America 1

Silver Age

1. S.A. Hulk 1 ( had to sell mine to pay for daughters wedding)

2. Fantastic Four 1

3. Showcase 4

Bronze Age

1. Anything signed by Frank Frazetta 

2. Psycho 1 and 14

3. Blazing Combat 1 (anything above 7.5)

4. Cerebus 1 ( any grade)

5. Finish my Eerie run 

Copper age

1.Men in Black 2 and 3 [ need to finish my run)

2.Gobbledygook 1

Modern  age

1.Bone 1 ( is this a modern?)

2.Y The last man 1

3. That's about it.

My bronze and copper goals should be done by years end.

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, oakman29 said:

Okay so now that I know what this is I will play too!

Golden Age

1.Detective 27 (ultimate grail)

2. Batman 1

3. Captain America 1

Silver Age

1. S.A. Hulk 1 ( had to sell mine to pay for daughters wedding)

2. Fantastic Four 1

3. Showcase 4

Bronze Age

1. Anything signed by Frank Frazetta 

2. Psycho 1 and 14

3. Blazing Combat 1 (anything above 7.5)

4. Cerebus 1 ( any grade)

5. Finish my Eerie run 

Copper age

1.Men in Black 2 and 3 [ need to finish my run)

2.Gobbledygook 1

Modern  age

1.Bone 1 ( is this a modern?)

2.Y The last man 1

3. That's about it.

My bronze and copper goals should be done by years end.

Just FYI...

You played this game before... Your post from 2013 is at the top of this page. lol

"These are tops on my want list"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, TwoPiece said:

Just FYI...

You played this game before... Your post from 2013 is at the top of this page. lol

"These are tops on my want list"

But I completed all my bronze, copper, and modern goals already.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
2 2