• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Miracleman #1 "Gold" Club
4 4

156 posts in this topic

Updated @Neeidea's Miracleman #400 Gold List:

  • *** CBCS 7.0 #19-3FF69EB-001 (Alan Moore signature on inside, 1st page) [unknown]
  • *** CBCS 9.0 #16-1EE8EB3-007 (Alan Moore signature) [unknown]
  • *** CBCS 6.0 #21-3569129-015 (Alan Moore signature) [unknown]
  • *** CBCS 8.0 #20-0C32E75-002 (Alan Moore signature) [unknown]
  • 000. CBCS 9.6 #22-4244A8F-001 [unknown]
  • 002. [blank]
  • 007. CGC 9.8. Owned by Chasehasadog82, original purchase from eBay (comicopolis) [unknown]
  • 011. Featured in Comics Buyer's Guide #1535, page 41, sold for $1,500 by Excalibur Books & Comics circa 2003 [blank]
  • 019. Sold on eBay for an unknown amount in VF condition [blank]
  • 022. Sold on eBay for $449.99 in May 2016. [blank]
  • 040. Previously sold by mycomicshop.com [blank]
  • 055. CBCS 9.6 #00-0000405-AA-001 Owned by Tropean, previously PGX 9.8 [blank]
  • 057. Featured on fourcolorheroes.com [blank]
  • 063. CGC 9.6 #4037852013 currently on sale for $1,795.00 by mycomicshop [unknown]
  • 093. DOUBLE? Owned by Mucher_dk, original purchase from either New England Comics or Mile High Comics [blank]
  • 093. DOUBLE? Owned by Bart Allen, original purchase from eBay in March 2023. [Sunrise Comics, unreadable signature 8/24/85]
  • 108. Sold on eBay for $1,998.88 by MadeofMiracles925 in 2021/22 [blank]
  • 109. CBCS 9.0 #18-2D645AF-004 Owned by KMiracleman [lost]
  • 113. Owned by Skizz [blank]
  • 116. CBCS 9.0; Owned by JGELL [blank]
  • 117. CGC 9.6 #0979887001 Sold on eBay Jul 2009 [blank]
  • 122. Original purchase from eBay (comicopolis) [blank]
  • 123. CGC 9.0 #0714931001 For sale on eBay May 2016 $1,200 [American Comics, Daniel Gus 2/14/86]
  • 124. CGC 9.8 #1232276005 Original purchase from eBay (comicopolis) [blank]
  • 128. CGC 9.8 #1256144001 Owned by Jjeanius, was for sale on ebay, original purchase from ebay (comicopolis) [blank]
  • 131. Original purchase from eBay (comicopolis) circa Jun 2013 [blank]
  • 134. CGC 9.8 #0198245001 Previously owned by Woregul, original purchase from ebay (comicopolis) [blank]
  • 136. Original purchase from eBay (comicopolis) May 2014 [blank]
  • 137. Sold on eBay (sagacitynow) circa mid Oct 2014 [blank, James Morrison Franco 8-4-85]
  • 139. CGC 9.4. Previously owned by Woregul (sold to an unknown CGC user), original purchase from eBay (comicopolis) [blank]
  • 141. CGC 9.8 #0192301002 Owned by Mschmidt [blank]
  • 149. CGC 9.8 #2380024004 Owned by Woregul, original purchase from eBay (comicopolis) [blank]
  • 155. [blank]
  • 161. CGC s/s Garry Leach 9.8 #1231281006 Original purchase from eBay (comicopolis) May 2014 [Sunrise Comics]
  • 162. Owned by Mschmidt, purchased from mycomicshop.com [blank]
  • 163. Sold on eBay (comicopolis) in Mar 2016 for $516.98 [blank]
  • 164. CGC 9.4 #4189715003 on sale on eBay (ddoa4666) from Mar 2024 for $2,499 [blank]
  • 165. CGC 8.5 #0098682001 Owned by HowardHallis since 2004 [blank]
  • 169. CGC 9.8 #1332529002 COA CGC #01333121001 Owned by Kapzilla, original purchase from eBay (comicopolis) [blank]
  • 178. Original purchase from eBay (comicopolis) Mar 2013 [blank]
  • 179. [Sunrise Comics]
  • 181. CGC 9.6 #1006822002 [blank]
  • 182. CGC 9.6 #1000183001 [unknown]
  • 183. CBSC 9.4 22-1E59A11-013 Owner Faircomics, as of March 2013, still listed on eBay.
  • 184. CGC 9.8 #1006822001 [blank]
  • 185. CGC 9.8 #1006822005 Sold on eBay Jan 2014 [Sunrise Comics]
  • 186. Sold on eBay for an unknown amount in Fine condition [#400 COA lost]
  • 187. CGC 9.8 #0186693003 Original purchase from eBay (comicopolis) [blank]
  • 188. Featured on 4colorheroes.com [Sunrise Comics]
  • 190. Owned by Mschmidt [blank]
  • 191. CGC 9.2 #1006822003 [Sunrise Comics]
  • 214. CGC 9.2 #2015164008 Owned by JollyComics, purchase from eBay Jul 2014. Mar 2016 on eBay for $600. Ryan had for sale @ $575. Owner as of 2020: Hcanes [blank]
  • 215. Sold via mycomicshop.com for $330 as VF 8.0 
  • 217. CGC 9.6 #0750997011 [unknown]
  • 226. CGC 9.8 #1006822004 Sold on eBay for US $1,999.99 Mar 2015 [blank]
  • 234. CGC 9.4 #4013628001 Owned by Adult Kid Toys and Services on Facebook [blank]
  • 236. Sold on eBay for US $300.00 on Sep 2016 [Sunrise Comics]
  • 242. CGC 9.4 #1035897001 For sale on eBay Feb 2017 $968.88 and later sold for $998.88 by MadeofMiracles925 in 2020 [Sunrise Comics, Leo Bahuaud, Brian Morton 8/4/85 and 8/10/85 ]
  • 246 On sale on eBay UK for £675 in Jan 2024 [blank]
  • 251. Sold for £430 on eBay Oct 2014 [Sunrise Comics, the Fortune Bookie, 8/4/85 John Franco]
  • 252. On sale on eBay UK for £700 - at some stage was in the possession of EwanUK [American Comics, Michael Lagrone 9/23]
  • 261. CBCS-VS 9.4 #0001066-AA-001 For sale on eBay Feb 2017 $87 [American Comics, Ray Faeth 9/23/85]
  • 268. [blank]
  • 271. [blank]
  • 288. Sold as a 9.6 raw on eBay for $474 on Apr 2015 [Best of 2 Worlds, Brian Cox 9/6/85]
  • 298. CGC 9.8 #0278339001 COA CGC #0278339002 NG Ryan selling on eBay in Feb 2016 (previously raw sold by mycomicshop.com for $450) [blank]
  • 304 Sold on eBay Sep 2023 £360 [blank]
  • 312. CGC 9.6 #0262610008 Originally owned by Deathtohemingway. Sold on eBay for $750 on Nov 2015 [blank]
  • 315. DOUBLE? CGC 9.6 #1056931007 For sale on eBay Feb 2017 $2,200 with offers [blank]
  • 315. DOUBLE? Owned by Bart Allen, original purchase from eBay in Jan 2024. [blank]
  • 317. Sold on eBay for an unknown amount (includes a small sketch of Maxwell the Magic Cat by Moore) [Sunrise Comics, Eric Vogt 8/3/85]
  • 322. CGC 9.4 #0280296005 For sale on eBay Feb 2017 $1,200 with offers [Fact, Fiction & Fantasy]
  • 326. Sold on eBay Feb 2014 $199 [Sunrise Comics, David Erickson 8/3/85]
  • 323. For sale on eBay April 2015 as "VG+" [Sunrise Comics, Douglas ?, 8/10/85]
  • 335. CGC 9.4 #Unknown Sold on eBay Nov 2008 [unknown]
  • 336. For sale on eBay Aug 2016 as "VF-" for $351 [Sunrise Comics]
  • 353. For sale on eBay (UK) Feb 2017 £900 [Sunrise Comics, Mathew A? 8/3/85]
  • 359. CGC 9.4 #0747447001 For sale on eBay Feb 2017 $875 (previously owned by woregul.) [Sunrise Comics]
  • 360. Pictured in Overstreet & Comics Buyer's Guide #1535 [American Comics, Ray Johnson 9/30/85]
  • 367. CGC 9.8. Owned by Patmcq [Bob Overstreet 8/3/85]
  • 368. CGC 9.8 #0919903002 Pedigree: Don/Maggie Thompson Collection Oct 2014 Sold $1,792.50 Heritage [Fact, Fiction & Fantasy and Sunrise comics; Don Thompson 3 August 1985]
  • 385. CGC 9.4 #0214635002 For sale on eBay Feb 2017 $850 [The Best of Two Worlds, unreadable signature]
  • 391. CGC 9.8 #1201704001 COA CGC #1257905001 NG For sale on eBay Feb 2017 $4K taking offers [Fact, Fiction & Fantasy]
  • 394. [Fact, Fiction & Fantasy, Becky Denn 8/3/85]
  • 399. CBCS 9.6 #22-4244A8F-002 [unknown]
Edited by Bart Allen
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 3/18/2023 at 11:46 PM, Bart Allen said:

Just bought #93 and it's in the UK :x

@mucher_dk has a 93/400 as well? lol Either his is actually a 43 or they messed up the numbers ~

Wow, that's UNSANE :cheers:

Mine is a bit more "golden" - but it's definitely a 93.

mm-1-93.jpg.b8f9d9bea4403de67ef847400b79ead6.jpg

mm-1-93-sign.jpg.94ed274303f14e42c5bf2433cb935059.jpg

Edited by mucher_dk
Added 2nd pic
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 3/19/2023 at 11:02 PM, Bart Allen said:

093. DOUBLE? Owned by Mucher_dk, original purchase from either New England Comics or Mile High Comics [blank]

New England or Mile High are only best guesses, but it could have been another one of the shops that advertised heavily in the comics back in 1985. It's possible that only one or two offered the gold and blue MM, but which one(s) is a good question. I wish the paperwork had survived.

Edited by mucher_dk
Typo
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/18/2023 at 6:45 PM, mucher_dk said:

Wow, that's UNSANE :cheers:

Mine is a bit more "golden" - but it's definitely a 93.

 

Spoiler

mm-1-93.jpg.b8f9d9bea4403de67ef847400b79ead6.jpg

 

mm-1-93-sign.jpg.94ed274303f14e42c5bf2433cb935059.jpg

Welcome back! lol

Also RC stated Moore signed more than 400 as someone messed the numbering ~

On 4/18/2023 at 7:35 PM, mucher_dk said:

New England or Mile High are only best guesses, but it could have been another one of the shops that advertised heavily in the comics back in 1985. It's possible that only one or two offered the gold and blue MM, but which one(s) is a good question. I wish the paperwork had survived.

Awww :(

On 4/18/2023 at 7:47 PM, mucher_dk said:

Well that wasn't the price unfortunately haha ~

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's probably not helpful because Ebay title lines allowed so few characters back then, I didn't have the room to list what serial number it was, but here's the email from Ebay with the sale details. The name of the person I sold it to is not in the list above, so I'm not sure if he passed it on, or still has it. If I'm remembering correctly, this book was raw when I got it in a lot purchased from Ebay for, I believe, $40 or so, sometime in the early to mid 2000's.

There were several comics in the lot, seemingly unrelated, and there wasn't much to the description of any of them, it just mentioned something like "Miracleman #1 signed". I'm not even sure it said who had signed, but I really wanted the lot for the copy of "Spidey Super Stories #1" that was in it, so I didn't worry much about the MM. Obviously, I thrilled to find it was the Gold Edition with certificate, which I was aware of, being a big Moore fan since the mid 80's.

I was even happier when I sold it, which I did at that point only because I'd acquired other Moore signatures by then. My seller name on Ebay is/was "jdandns", which is the same as my name here. As you can see, this was before we were highly incentivized to offer free shipping on all items, so I actually charged $6 for the shipping on this, which I think mostly covered priority mail with signature confirmation, which I certainly would've used on a book that sold for this much.

MIRACLEMAN #1 Gold ALAN MOORE Autograph w/ CERTIFICATE
Sale price: $536.59
Quantity sold: 1
Sale date: Jan-20-10 00:56:24 PST
MIRACLEMAN #1 Gold ALAN MOORE Autograph w/ CERTIFICATE
Item# 370319834525
$536.59 USD 1 $536.59 USD
image.gif.183aa50eb7d9cc56f505e16f4fbeaebc.gif
Shipping and handling $6.00 USD
Insurance - not offered ----
Total $542.59 USD
Payment $542.59 USD

 

 

image.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/20/2023 at 8:42 AM, jdandns said:

It's probably not helpful because Ebay title lines allowed so few characters back then, I didn't have the room to list what serial number it was, but here's the email from Ebay with the sale details. The name of the person I sold it to is not in the list above, so I'm not sure if he passed it on, or still has it. If I'm remembering correctly, this book was raw when I got it in a lot purchased from Ebay for, I believe, $40 or so, sometime in the early to mid 2000's.

There were several comics in the lot, seemingly unrelated, and there wasn't much to the description of any of them, it just mentioned something like "Miracleman #1 signed". I'm not even sure it said who had signed, but I really wanted the lot for the copy of "Spidey Super Stories #1" that was in it, so I didn't worry much about the MM. Obviously, I thrilled to find it was the Gold Edition with certificate, which I was aware of, being a big Moore fan since the mid 80's.

I was even happier when I sold it, which I did at that point only because I'd acquired other Moore signatures by then. My seller name on Ebay is/was "jdandns", which is the same as my name here. As you can see, this was before we were highly incentivized to offer free shipping on all items, so I actually charged $6 for the shipping on this, which I think mostly covered priority mail with signature confirmation, which I certainly would've used on a book that sold for this much.

MIRACLEMAN #1 Gold ALAN MOORE Autograph w/ CERTIFICATE
Sale price: $536.59
Quantity sold: 1
Sale date: Jan-20-10 00:56:24 PST
MIRACLEMAN #1 Gold ALAN MOORE Autograph w/ CERTIFICATE
Item# 370319834525
$536.59 USD 1 $536.59 USD
image.gif.183aa50eb7d9cc56f505e16f4fbeaebc.gif
Shipping and handling $6.00 USD
Insurance - not offered ----
Total $542.59 USD
Payment $542.59 USD

 

 

image.gif

Woah, interesting stuff :O

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Didn't expect to get this, so I can finally share my second book of the Gold Club :x 

Though it appears to be a double, yet again, as it corresponds with CGC 9.6 #1056931007 which was for sale on eBay during Feb 2017 -- unless it's the same book, but was unslabbed and kept in bad condition for nigh-seven years whilst travelling across the North Atlantic to England  lol

image.thumb.png.4ac83a9baaf0b49ebe265a68afa3f427.pngimage.thumb.png.d389a22344cad58f8b92cf6047d8b918.pngimage.thumb.png.b44baac91cbcf3a72364b20163905ac9.pngimage.thumb.png.e677316900ee6d03594a6c14f9529364.png

Edited by Bart Allen
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/31/2024 at 3:09 PM, Bart Allen said:

Didn't expect to get this, so I can finally share my second book of the Gold Club :x 

Though it appears to be a double, yet again, as it corresponds with CGC 9.6 #1056931007 which was for sale on eBay during Feb 2017 -- unless it's the same book, but was unslabbed and kept in bad condition for nigh-seven years whilst travelling across the North Atlantic to England  lol

image.thumb.png.4ac83a9baaf0b49ebe265a68afa3f427.pngimage.thumb.png.d389a22344cad58f8b92cf6047d8b918.pngimage.thumb.png.b44baac91cbcf3a72364b20163905ac9.pngimage.thumb.png.e677316900ee6d03594a6c14f9529364.png

I was a bidder though didn't go aggressive. I'm happy you got it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/31/2024 at 9:52 PM, Ryan. said:

I was a bidder though didn't go aggressive. I'm happy you got it.

Cheers, Ryan -- there'll be more surely as one was only sold a few weeks prior :x

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'll have to dig them out and check, but I don't remember the surface of my certificates (also have the blue) being this "textured". Did they switch to a different paper type at some point, or am I merely confused?

From recent ebay auction:

mm-1-gold-246-texture.thumb.jpg.6a52126c6bed3a73b1a07ff697958c6c.jpg

Not the sharpest photos in the world, but the best I can do right now (click on thumbnails to expand).

IMG-2045-2.png IMG-2046-2.png

PS: And, sorry, not color corrected either. Thoughts, anyone?

PPS: Wow, this topic is even deader than I thought. No intellectual curiosity whatsoever. Well, never mind ...

Edited by mucher_dk
Added pics
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 2/1/2024 at 11:01 AM, mucher_dk said:

PS: And, sorry, not color corrected either. Thoughts, anyone?

PPS: Wow, this topic is even deader than I thought. No intellectual curiosity whatsoever. Well, never mind ...

Well another one has been listed on eBay: 164/400:

https://www.ebay.com/itm/186349834743

But, alas, there isn't any curiosity as of late, though it'll change at some point - as, for the most part, the Miracleman/Marvelman is still rather underrated ~

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 3/18/2024 at 5:30 AM, Bart Allen said:

Well another one has been listed on eBay: 164/400:

https://www.ebay.com/itm/186349834743

But, alas, there isn't any curiosity as of late, though it'll change at some point - as, for the most part, the Miracleman/Marvelman is still rather underrated ~

I thought it would've been interesting to research why the texture of the surface of the certificates can look so different in photos & scans, and had hoped for a reaction or two, esp. from experts who've handled multiple copies over the years.

The #164 certificate looks badly faded, but that could be due to lighting conditions (although I guess it can't be ruled out that saturation was reduced in an effort to hide discoloration).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 3/21/2024 at 2:34 AM, mucher_dk said:

I thought it would've been interesting to research why the texture of the surface of the certificates can look so different in photos & scans, and had hoped for a reaction or two, esp. from experts who've handled multiple copies over the years.

The #164 certificate looks badly faded, but that could be due to lighting conditions (although I guess it can't be ruled out that saturation was reduced in an effort to hide discoloration).

Yeah, I noticed such a thing when you brought the subject to attention with the difference in surface ~

Also, not sure whether this'll effect the books that are encapsulated (with Moore's signature):

https://www.cgccomics.com/news/article/12753/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
4 4