A-level panel page valuations by artist/run - thoughts/additions/changes? 5 5

[Dick O.]

Fantastic resource Lago32 (thumbs u

 

You may want to consider pasting the latest list in the first post for ease of reference

 

 

[buttock]

I'd recommend dropping Kubert war/Hawkman one notch also. I just bought a 2X splash in that range, and the best war panel page I can recall seeing went for less than $5k on Clink.

[mtlevy]

Oops, just saw Mark's qualification. He is talking about percent WITHIN the range, whereas I was talking percent of the HIGH part of the range. I think it's easier to do it the way I'm doing it, as no one is going to memorize these ranges, just where the peak is.

 

I like it the way I suggest as there is a range on Bs, just as there is on As...actually would remove the +/- 5% instead.

 

Any way it is done, would be nice to have the spread between A (Top 10%) and D (Bottom)

 

I am not sure if you feel the %s I floated are too low or too high?

 

 

[westform]

There are no EC artists/pages on the list? Also, no Barks?

[Hekla]

Must be sobering for those getting started

 

 

Interesting list & a lot of artists/series that I would love to have in the nostalga side my collection, but I'm priced out of most tiers. Even for one piece in the lower tiers I can get several cool Modern covers and splashes.

 

Good to see a price break-down, especially as it relates to B and lower pages. It gives me a good reference point moving forward.

[chromium]

There are no EC artists/pages on the list? Also, no Barks?

 

Very good point. Where do the Wood, Ingels, Davis, Feldstein, Krigstein panel pages fall ?

[mtlevy]

I don't believe it was meant to be an exhaustive list - I mean no Everett Subby either

[heartened]

You know, what's funny is that there was a time when we all sat around and wondered whether anyone would ever cross the 1K barrier, and then the barrier rose and rose. I remember vividly people saying that we can count on one hand the number of people who would spend 10K on a piece of comic OA (covers, even!). Boy have times changed - and rather quickly!

 

[drdroom]

There are no EC artists/pages on the list? Also, no Barks?

 

Very good point. Where do the Wood, Ingels, Davis, Feldstein, Krigstein panel pages fall ?

 

I'm not the expert but I think only Wood, Frazetta & possibly Kurtzman will make it into the +3K club for an A interior panel page.

[Lago32]

I'd recommend dropping Kubert war/Hawkman one notch also. I just bought a 2X splash in that range, and the best war panel page I can recall seeing went for less than $5k on Clink.

 

Thank for the feedback however I know of at least a handful of sales (public and private) of A-level Kubert B&B Hawkman pages in the $5-10k range.

[Lago32]

There are no EC artists/pages on the list? Also, no Barks?

 

Hey Dan, as I mentioned in the thread title, I encourage anyone to provide feedback on any additions or changes.I only included those artists/runs for which I felt I had a semi-good grasp of the market. I am not an EC guy and will leave it up to those that know that market much better than I to chime in with their thoughts. Thanks!

[Lago32]

I don't believe it was meant to be an exhaustive list - I mean no Everett Subby either

 

I did see the Everett Subby GA page in Heritage sell for $86k a while back but hesitated to include it in the list as I don't really know that market. Where would he and his various popular runs fall in the list Mark? Thanks.

[buttock]

I'd recommend dropping Kubert war/Hawkman one notch also. I just bought a 2X splash in that range, and the best war panel page I can recall seeing went for less than $5k on Clink.

 

Thank for the feedback however I know of at least a handful of sales (public and private) of A-level Kubert B&B Hawkman pages in the $5-10k range.

 

Sounds good to me, I thought the price on my page was very reasonable. Do you know of any war pages going in this range?

[chromium]

There are no EC artists/pages on the list? Also, no Barks?

 

Very good point. Where do the Wood, Ingels, Davis, Feldstein, Krigstein panel pages fall ?

 

I'm not the expert but I think only Wood, Frazetta & possibly Kurtzman will make it into the +3K club for an A interior panel page.

 

I wouldn't disregard Ingels, I know of two panel pages that sold for over $3K, one I think on Heritage back in 2010 or 2009 ( can't seem to find it at the moment)

 

Also this Jack Davis page sold for $3350 in 2010 http://comics.ha.com/c/item.zx?saleNo=7021&lotNo=92055

 

And I don't even think it's an A page ( no host )

[drdroom]

There are no EC artists/pages on the list? Also, no Barks?

 

Very good point. Where do the Wood, Ingels, Davis, Feldstein, Krigstein panel pages fall ?

 

I'm not the expert but I think only Wood, Frazetta & possibly Kurtzman will make it into the +3K club for an A interior panel page.

 

I wouldn't disregard Ingels, I know of two panel pages that sold for over $3K, one I think on Heritage back in 2010 or 2009 ( can't seem to find it at the moment)

 

Also this Jack Davis page sold for $3350 in 2010 http://comics.ha.com/c/item.zx?saleNo=7021&lotNo=92055

 

And I don't even think it's an A page ( no host )

 

Its not a A page, its an A+ page! Hatchet in the head. For Ingels, I'd consider reanimated dead tissue pages to be A+. (choke)

[chromium]

 

Its not a A page, its an A+ page! Hatchet in the head. For Ingels, I'd consider reanimated dead tissue pages to be A+. (choke)

 

 

It's all about the hosts for me.

[Nexus]

There are no EC artists/pages on the list? Also, no Barks?

 

Very good point. Where do the Wood, Ingels, Davis, Feldstein, Krigstein panel pages fall ?

 

I'm not the expert but I think only Wood, Frazetta & possibly Kurtzman will make it into the +3K club for an A interior panel page.

 

I wouldn't disregard Ingels, I know of two panel pages that sold for over $3K, one I think on Heritage back in 2010 or 2009 ( can't seem to find it at the moment)

 

Also this Jack Davis page sold for $3350 in 2010 http://comics.ha.com/c/item.zx?saleNo=7021&lotNo=92055

 

And I don't even think it's an A page ( no host )

 

Its not a A page, its an A+ page! Hatchet in the head. For Ingels, I'd consider reanimated dead tissue pages to be A+. (choke)

 

One's collecting dollar goes so much further with panel pages (relative to covers/splashes) and that seems to be especially true with EC.

[delekkerste]

One's collecting dollar goes so much further with panel pages (relative to covers/splashes)

 

That's true, and it's also why I think some of the art on the list is in too high a bracket, as that would imply very compressed ratios vis-a-vis splashes and covers from the same artist/run.

[heartened]

One's collecting dollar goes so much further with panel pages (relative to covers/splashes)

 

That's true, and it's also why I think some of the art on the list is in too high a bracket, as that would imply very compressed ratios vis-a-vis splashes and covers from the same artist/run.

 

Not sure about that. In general, an A level splash (assuming it has the character on it, nice image, etc) would likely be 2-3 times the price of an A list panel page, and a cover would be 4 to 5 times the price. A+ splashes and covers would be even higher.

[heartened]

By the way, this was a great idea making this list . It helps us understand artists that we don't really collect. I for one am certainly learning something about some of the other artists and character combinations out there. Let's keep this going. I shudder to think about doing a splash and cover art list, but you know we'll have to take a crack at that at some point.