THE AMAZING FANTASY #15 CLUB 39 39

[The lips]

On 5/1/2021 at 7:28 AM, fishbone said:

 

That has blew my mind. 
I so so need to see that myself 

[peewee22]

4 hours ago, NoMan said:

New CGC 7.0 coming up for auction on CL. Although I haven’t seen GNs or back cover, front cover-wise it’s one of the tightest 7.0 I’ve ever seen. Could easily be a 8.5 - 9.0. Price?

pic?

[Cushing Fan]

Seems like a good deal if it is legit:

AF15 CGC 2.0

https://www.facebook.com/marketplace/item/139565934857647/?ref=facebook_story_share

[DST]

I believe the AF15 7.0 auction referenced above is on Comicconnect, not Comiclink.  CL always has their auction dates listed where as CC are usually TBD.  Assuming I’m right, the 7.0 is very nice but in no way an 8.5-9.0.  I think it’s graded accurately.  Anyway here is a pic of the AF15 7.0 that will be on CC sometime in the near future:

[Mr bla bla]

3 hours ago, DST said:

I believe the AF15 7.0 auction referenced above is on Comicconnect, not Comiclink.  CL always has their auction dates listed where as CC are usually TBD.  Assuming I’m right, the 7.0 is very nice but in no way an 8.5-9.0.  I think it’s graded accurately.  Anyway here is a pic of the AF15 7.0 that will be on CC sometime in the near future:

Id say from the scan it looks 7.5ish

[NoMan]

Nah, it’s a 9.0. I’m gonna be an Overstreet Advisor. You’ll see. 

[NoMan]

I think all af15s should start at 9.0, you know just on principle. Like on the high school SAT tests where you get 200 points for putting your name down 

[Heronext]

Anyone take note of this result?  Looks low, am I missing something?

ComicConnect - AMAZING FANTASY #15 - CBCS VG/F: 5.0

[Sweet Lou 14]

4 minutes ago, Heronext said:

Anyone take note of this result?  Looks low, am I missing something?

ComicConnect - AMAZING FANTASY #15 - CBCS VG/F: 5.0

It has two major things going against it -- chipping and the CBCS label.  I have no data to back this up but I imagine in this market that the price gap between CGC and other grading companies has grown considerably. 

[Jaydogrules]

2 hours ago, Sweet Lou 14 said:

It has two major things going against it -- chipping and the CBCS label.  I have no data to back this up but I imagine in this market that the price gap between CGC and other grading companies has grown considerably. 

It has.

-J.

[Mr bla bla]

4 hours ago, Heronext said:

Anyone take note of this result?  Looks low, am I missing something?

ComicConnect - AMAZING FANTASY #15 - CBCS VG/F: 5.0

Its due to chips

[jeffreyk]

The cgc 4.5 on comiclink has chips and is already at 39k with 5 days to go.

[UncleBEN]

That was a pretty good deal on the CBCS book IMHO. In my personal experience every crossover I have done have come back 1 to 2 grades higher.

Just comes full circle to buying the book and not the label.

Don't be surprised when you see this book in a CGC holder soon :P

 

[Heronext]

I agree, it hasn't seemed chips or PQ affect auction results much & this grade "should" have sold for twice as much.  This closed at 6:17 pm and I missed it thinking the auction was at 8.  (I missed a couple of Bronze Spideys I was interested in which I thought went for low too).  I'm putting this down to holder and choice of venue but wow what a steal.  CC didn't deliver for the consignor here IMHO.

This is coming from someone who misses my old AF 15 and am recently on the hunt again.

[jeffreyk]

I thought it would go for 50k.  I think the cgc 4.5 on comiclink will hit mid 40s easily.

[WarZoneSpider]

Joined the club today! I’m so pumped!

[innocuous]

6 hours ago, WarZoneSpider said:

Joined the club today! I’m so pumped!

 

Now that's a new comic day smile. Congrats. 

[DST]

21 hours ago, UncleBEN said:

That was a pretty good deal on the CBCS book IMHO. In my personal experience every crossover I have done have come back 1 to 2 grades higher.

Just comes full circle to buying the book and not the label.

Don't be surprised when you see this book in a CGC holder soon :P

 

Not saying that the person didn't get a deal, but that's your experience.  Every book I've sent to CGC for crossover they've all come back the same grade or lower

Edited May 21, 2021 by DST

[SpideyFein]

Here we go... I just received this beauty from @comicbookkid21 and couldn’t be happier. Thank you!!!!!!!
 

In January, I had sold my copy that I’d never thought I’d sell, and my collection wasn’t the same without it. I know people sometimes say that, but it literally did not feel the same. Thank you to all of you who sent me leads and that I almost did deals with. I’m proud to be back in one of the best clubs on the planet. Spidey’s home safe. Yeah baby!!!!!!!!! 

[Dark Knight]

Welcome back to the club Dan!  Yeah I know the feeling of not having an AF #15 in your collection.. It was a big hole for me too, but luckily managed to buy another copy.