Is your collection more EXCITING or more THRILLING??? 1 1

[Frisco Larson]

Cool thread idea!

 

These are mine.

 

 

 

 

 

If you check the issues I posted, you'll see that you & I are fishing the same pond quite resolutely my friend (thumbs u

[Frisco Larson]

WOW ..... my fellow boardies have some AWESOME books Keep 'em coming gang!!! I have more, just don't have pics of them yet

[Robot Man]

[cheetah]

I posted a thumbnail but thought this one deserved its own post.

 

[Frisco Larson]

 

I've ALWAYS loved this cover!!! Still haven't been able to land one yet ..... Nice copy Robot Man

[Frisco Larson]

I posted a thumbnail but thought this one deserved its own post.

 

 

WHOA

[adamstrange]

I can tell from the front cover scan that this is clearly over-graded. No way that it is any better than a 9.7999999.

 

I posted a thumbnail but thought this one deserved its own post.

 

[Robot Man]

 

I've ALWAYS loved this cover!!! Still haven't been able to land one yet ..... Nice copy Robot Man

 

Thanks, aside from it being kinda hard to get, I've always loved the cover. It was in the "Paul" collection and I happily grabbed it the minute I saw it. It's really not as nice as it appears though. Note the off trim at the top right. When you open it up, the interior pages have a pretty uneven trim. They are a little wider and less wide inside. I thought maybe Paul trimmed it. But it looks like it probably was a printing defect. It is a little severe on some pages but doesn't go into the art. Always wondered how CGC would grade it? Got a great price because of it.

[cheetah]

I can tell from the front cover scan that this is clearly over-graded. No way that it is any better than a 9.7999999.

 

I posted a thumbnail but thought this one deserved its own post.

 

 

You don't know what you are talking about. It is clearly a 9.8000000000001.

[cheetah]

Here's a couple if exciting Excitings.

 

 

[Marty Mann]

Two THRILLING...Zero EXCITING.

 

mm

[keever]

Jeff, I can't believe nobody has commented on the jaw-dropping, stunning quality of the Exciting 58 and 60. I know you have some equally thrilling copies of Thrilling. Show everybody your #75, and throw in a scan of your #15 is you get a chance.

[Frisco Larson]

Still leaning more toward Exciting ....

 

 

[Frisco Larson]

Tipping toward Thrilling ....

 

[circumstances]

Recent Thrilling acquisition!

 

[Cat-Man_America]

Snagging this eye-popper was EXCITING...

 

 

[AJD]

Thrilling 2 v Exciting 1 for me

[circumstances]

New acquisition. The Nedor kick continues! Thrilling Comics #32, January, 1943.

8 copies on the census, all universal.

[path4play]

Exciting two vs. Thrilling one.  Frankly, its Startling!

 

 

 

[Frisco Larson]