2016 March Madness Comic Grading Tournament - Round of 16

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Welcome March Madness Grading Tournament - Round of 16

 

Rules for this and future rounds:

 

1. Do not talk about the books in this thread or any other thread. Do not talk to your wife about these books. Do not talk to your friends about these books. Do not talk to your dog about these books.

 

2. Four books will be posted. PM me all grades in the order they are listed. Use the template I provided to send the grades

 

3. Submit your grades in standard CGC recognized increments.

 

4. Due date for grades for this round is Tuesday, March 22nd at 10:00p (EST) or when the last team submits its grades. All grade submissions are final.

 

5. No conditional grades will be accepted. Please ask questions to seek clarification before submitting grades.

 

6. The following is a list of things I will always disclose when posting the scans.

A. Any defects not clearly visible. (ie. NCB creases)

B. Moisture Stains not apparent on the scan.

C. Damage to a book which was not present at the time of grading.

D. Any damage/ scratches on the CGC case which may appear as flaws on the book.

 

7. Your score will be tallied based on the sum of the points awarded for the grades assigned each book based on the chart below:

 

Spot on= 20 points

.2 or closer = 18 points

.5 or closer= 15 points

.7 or closer= 10 points

1 or closer = 7 points.

1.2 or closer= 5 points.

1.5 or closer= 2 points

2 or closer = 0 points

Over 2 grades off= Technical Foul -5 points

 

 

Bonus (cumulative):

2 books spot on= 5 points

3 books spot on=10 points

 

 

The Team with the highest score wins the game and advances. There will be an overtime book posted in the event of a tie.

 

Good Luck to everyone.

 

The brackets:

 

 

 

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Small scans:

 

 

 

AF

 

 

 

DCP

 

 

 

MIS

 

 

 

Warlock

 

 

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Large scans:

 

 

AF

 

 

 

DCP

 

 

 

MIS

 

 

 

Warlock

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Large Scans (click on them a couple of times to get the maximum size):

 

 

 

AF

 

 

DCP

 

 

 

MIS

 

 

 

Warlock

 

 

 

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Please use this format when replying:

 

AF

DCP

MIS

Warlock

[kav]

Small scan AF 15 b/c is wrong

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Small scan AF 15 b/c is wrong

 

Fixed in the small scans. Thanks for the heads up.

[kav]

Small scan AF 15 b/c is wrong

 

Fixed in the small scans. Thanks for the heads up.

Does this mean I'm back in the contest?

Ps weird I just read that Adam Strange story about 2 hours ago

There was a serious flaw in the story too

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Give me a minute to fix the second set of large scans.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Give me a minute to fix the second set of large scans.

 

Fixed.

[TheGeneral]

Another repeat set! Good luck to everyone!

[Mio]

Grades sent. I hope my luck continues.

[Shadow]

Grades are in.

[W16227]

IN

[427Impaler]

Grades in.

 

These insidious repeat title rounds have melted my brain

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Grades in.

 

These insidious repeat title rounds have melted my brain

 

I promise I won't do it again.

[KPR Comics]

In

[BlowUpTheMoon]

I've replied to all PMs.

 

Only waiting on six contestants.

[Still Only 35c]

Grades in. Pleasantly surprised to still be in the running, one round further than last year; I can keep going.

 

Best of luck everyone remaining.

[W16227]

grades in!

 

got one of these for my effort-----

 

 

 

figure it is better than...

 

[Richard The Man]

Grades in