Ever had a high dollar book damaged by CGC?
0

14 posts in this topic

Kelmonster   
  • Member
  • 171 posts

Ever had a high dollar book damaged by CGC either in grading or re slabbing? If so, what was the extent of the damage and was there an adequate reimbursement?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


nearmint   
  • Member: Seasoned Veteran
  • 28,981 posts
  • Location: Jeff in Newport Beach, CA

They damaged one of my books in their first year of operation. They'd graded the book 5.0. The book was damaged during encapsulation. I had them regrade it with the damage, and it went down to 4.5. Steve Borock and I talked on the phone and worked out a fair market refund for the .5 difference.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Comicdey   
  • Member: Seasoned Veteran
  • 23,269 posts
  • Location: North to Alaska....going North the Rush is on

They damaged a not so high value book of mine. Warlock 2 should have been a 9.8 but ended up with a right edge thumb color breaking crease and graded 9.2.

 

I still have it. Never asked for anything but chocked it up as a lesson that anything can happen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bighaley21   
  • Member
  • 1,835 posts

I sent in a stack of xfactor 6s 2 years ago for a 9.2 prescreen and all came back ungraded. I was confused because these were sure 9.6/9.8 candidates. Looked over the books closely and saw each one had a blunted corner on the bottom of the spine. Im guessing someone dropped the stack and smashed them all in the same spot. Contacted CGC and they pressed each book and regraded each on their dime. All came back 9.6-9.8.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jharvey   

I recently submitted a Daredevil #30, with Thor on the cover, which should have graded somewhere between 9.0 - 9.4. When I got it back it was graded 8.5, and had a small tear along the top edge that wasn't there before. I contacted Brittany McManus with CGC and she asked if I had a picture of the comic before I sent it in. I did have a picture, without the tear, that I took before I sent the comic in.

I e-mailed Brittany the picture, and she offered me two choices:

1.  CGC can replace the book for you in a higher grader, or 

2. We can credit you your grading fees.

I accepted choice #1, mailed in the 8.5 grade copy of the comic, and Brittany mailed me a 9.4 grade copy of Daredevil #30. 

Thank you CGC for standing behind your product and making things right with this comic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
nearmint   
  • Member: Seasoned Veteran
  • 28,981 posts
  • Location: Jeff in Newport Beach, CA
37 minutes ago, jharvey said:

I accepted choice #1, mailed in the 8.5 grade copy of the comic, and Brittany mailed me a 9.4 grade copy of Daredevil #30. 

 

Thank you CGC for standing behind your product and making things right with this comic.

Wow.  Good for them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
comicquant   
  • Member
  • 2,134 posts
  • Location: Wherever I go, there I am

Awhile ago I started taking scans of the front and back covers prior to submission in The event a book was damaged during the process.  It's awesome CGC replaced the book  but should they have contacted you at the time the damage occurred?  Seems like in most cases they wait until the customer complains.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Tony S   
  • Member
  • 2,730 posts
  • Location: Evansville, Indiana

No. I don't believe so anyway. Low or high dollar. The closest to this is a book - Detective 400 - that was a CGC 9.2 Universal  that I sent to Matt back when he was Classics Inc. He pressed it and it came back 9.4. Qualified with bottom staple pulled through FC.  He thought CGC probably caused the staple pop. I had no way of knowing of course.  I chalked it up to anything can happen. The restoration check does indeed require the book be opened up good and flat to look for repairs. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Tony S   
  • Member
  • 2,730 posts
  • Location: Evansville, Indiana
9 hours ago, Kelmonster1 said:

Cool...does this mean CGC has a bunch of back issues they use to replace damaged books?

I think that CGC just goes out and buys such

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Readcomix   
  • Member
  • 3,780 posts
19 hours ago, jharvey said:

I recently submitted a Daredevil #30, with Thor on the cover, which should have graded somewhere between 9.0 - 9.4. When I got it back it was graded 8.5, and had a small tear along the top edge that wasn't there before. I contacted Brittany McManus with CGC and she asked if I had a picture of the comic before I sent it in. I did have a picture, without the tear, that I took before I sent the comic in.

I e-mailed Brittany the picture, and she offered me two choices:

1.  CGC can replace the book for you in a higher grader, or 

2. We can credit you your grading fees.

I accepted choice #1, mailed in the 8.5 grade copy of the comic, and Brittany mailed me a 9.4 grade copy of Daredevil #30. 

Thank you CGC for standing behind your product and making things right with this comic.

Didn't happen to me, but my LCS owner shared a story of them doing the same thing with a mid-grade 181 that he submitted on behalf of a customer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
My young Padawan   
  • Member
  • 143 posts

I recently received a reholdered Swamp Thing #1 from CGC.  A small piece of the top-right corner of the cover was torn.  Unfortunately, there is very little that can be done about it. 

Reholder Damage?

Edited by My young Padawan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Buzzetta   
  • Member
  • 20,671 posts
  • Location: Long Island, New York

Yes, but I believe it was more from my decision to test the book.  The book in question was worth a couple of hundred dollars.  I had purchased it as a 4.5 Light Tan to Off White.  I then decided to test the book with the company across the street.  The book went from a 4.5 to a 4.0.  Then I decided to have it reholdered in a CGC slab and it went to a 3.5.

 

There the book stays as a 3.5.  The book in question? 

 

Side note... in order to meet the size requirements of uploaded images I had to scan the book then shrink it and take a screen cap of it.  Photobucket is looking better... and better lol 

 

 

Screen Shot 2017-02-09 at 10.59.04 PM.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Calamerica   
  • Member: Seasoned Veteran
  • 11,115 posts
  • Location: Running the CGC Forums..HaHaHa
On 2/5/2017 at 4:28 PM, Kelmonster said:

Ever had a high dollar book damaged by CGC either in grading or re slabbing? If so, what was the extent of the damage and was there an adequate reimbursement?

Yes. No re-imbursement, either. 

I bought a SWEET Silver Surfer # 1 from Harley Yee at the SD Con, sold to me as NM- 9.2/possible NM 9.4. Paid 550, which I still feel was a discounted price, and it had the WHITE pages I am willing to pay a little more than usual for.

But I am getting ahead of myself:

I had bought the 3-Free Submission Voucher from another great Bordie, Joanna, and I used said Voucher to send in 3 OTHER Norrin Radds.

The # 2 had a 1/4" blue strip of color discoloration by the spine, a true printing oddity, and me and my "associates" were offering cases of brew to who had the closest grade. 

One said VF/NM 9.0, I said NM- 9.2, the other said NM 9.4/possible NM+ 9.6.

When it came back VF 8.0 I flipped my lid. 

Now mind you that Borock had left, and the Haspel Hammer was running things during this time.

I called and somehow got Haspel without the usual runaround.

He was arrogant, dismissive, and stood by his " there was some sort of discoloration at the price box". That alone knocked this from the NM classes to VF classes.

The next shipment in( I used to send in books regularly) had the coveted SS # 1.

Came back VF 8.0, WHITE pages. EIGHT-POINT OH???

I could clearly see the ding/blunting on the bottom of the spine. Did not have to crack it out to see this.

This time I was on hold forever, and Haspel did not want to talk to me.

I persisted, PMed, Posted, etc.

Now angry, he takes the call, however, as this was years ago I don't remember word-for-word exactly.

Paraphrasing here:

CAL(C): " Did you or one of your pre-graders drop this great book?"

Haspel( H): " Umm.. uh, accidents happen".

C: "And you didn't; have the decency or courtesy to call me and tell me?"

H;" We are seven months behind and don't have that sort of, um, time..."

C: " I am asking point blank: did you or one of your pre-graders drop this book?"

Silence

C" "Yes or no?"

H: " Probably".

C: "Not even a courtesy call or notice. You have my number and email..."

Silence.

C: " Now what can you do about this now?"

H: " I would have to go to xyz, then he has to go to xyz"

I had had enough. I hung up, and can't believe now that I did not rail like I usually do. Never spoke to him ever again nor will I ever speak to him ever.

I had already slated a few more shipment of Pre-screens( what a rip-off) and other books for Customers of mine, but the die was cast:

I would be getting out of the submission business.

Then when my Sales Threads kept getting hijacked, other deals nixed by Scott Bono and others, I called Harshen a few times to no avail, they ignore me now and blame ME for the troubles I have had here.

So they don't get any more of my business. I also stop steering people their way.

Bottom line: Yes, strange things happened to me during my submission days. Lessons learned too well.

CAL who does mostly raws now...

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited by Calamerica

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
0

  • Welcome! Sign up and jump in!

    Membership and use of the boards is FREE! The knowledge available on these boards about comic collecting is an amazing resource for less experienced collectors. It's also a great place to talk about expert comic collecting topics with other experienced collectors. We hope that you find what you came looking for here, but more than that, we hope you find your new comic collecting home.

    Don't let the friendly banter and close knit community put you off. You're only a few posts from being part of the gang!

    After you sign up, introduce yourself! We'd love to know more about your collecting.

  • Upcoming Events

    • 28 January 2018 03:00 PM Until 10:00 PM
      0  
      Orlando Toy and Comic Con is coming to a new location on Jan 28th 2018.

      Location:
      The Florida Hotel
      1500 Sand Lake Rd Orlando FL 32809 (in the Florida Mall)
       
      Featured guests include: Tony Moore, Nick Bradshaw, Ryan Stegman, Ryan Ottley, Billy Tucci, Frank Tieri and more.
       
      This is Florida's best 1 day show!
      www.orlandotoyandcomiccon.com
       
       
       
    • 28 January 2018 03:00 PM Until 09:00 PM
      0  
      On January 28th join us from 10-4 at the Hasbrouck Heights Holiday Inn, 283 Rt 17 South (directly on the highway).for the ONLY comicon in Bergen County, NJ! Access from Rts 3, 46, 80, the GSP and the NJ Tpk is quick and easy!
      Admission is only $3, or buy 5 show passes that can be used at either of our hotel shows for only $10 (Admission is still free for kids under 12 and non-collecting partners). Parking is on site, easy and free.
      We'll have tons of comics as always! Your favorite dealers will be there, including some that ONLY do this show… and some new guys!
      Our notorious no minimum bid auction is at noon.  
      More info is on our website at http://www.njcomicbookshows.com
      “Like us” on Facebook at NJ Comic Book Shows
      NJ’s ONLY monthly comicons since 1991!
      Seeya at the show!
      JP
      Other upcoming shows:
      Clifton 2/11
      Old Bridge 2/18
      Clifton 3/11