PGM Batman Adventures #12 - Harley Quinn First Appearance 0

[pnelson86]

Hi everyone,

I stumbled across the first appearance of Harley Quinn. Your thoughts on the grade?

[Terrapin]

7.5 cb stress lines and ticks around top staple. Bottom left corner wear, crease bottom right corner and slight spine roll.

Edited July 13, 2017 by Terrapin
Typo

[Sabersaw]

2 hours ago, Terrapin said:

7.5 cb stress lines and ticks around top staple. Bottom left corner wear, crease bottom right corner and slight spine roll.

I was actually thinking higher like an 8.0. The length of the stress lines are really you short and the rest of the book looks pretty good. Removing the spine issues and it would be a 9.0 for bumped corners.

[Terrapin]

It presents like an 8.0 but I think the accumulation of all the small defects will bring it under 8 especially for a newer book.

[seanfingh]

No way that book grades out that low.  it's an 8.5 at least as it sits and it will maybe press to a 9.0

[joeypost]

17 minutes ago, seanfingh said:

No way that book grades out that low.  it's an 8.5 at least as it sits and it will maybe press to a 9.0

I'm in the same boat. Post press ( a proper pressing) this would be at least 8.5.

[Sabersaw]

1 hour ago, Terrapin said:

It presents like an 8.0 but I think the accumulation of all the small defects will bring it under 8 especially for a newer book.

I see where you are coming from but a press fixes the roll. miracle would be 9.0. 8.5 is a win but I think it will sit as a 8.0 for a modern.