2018 Annual March Madness CGC Grading Tournament - Sweet Sixteen 2 2

[BlowUpTheMoon]

@BorderlineHoarder

[BorderlineHoarder]

I'm in 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

This Round is closed. 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

The CGC grades:

Spoiler

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

The result of the match-ups:

Spoiler

9	iXr184 12-10 [47]
6	spidermanbeyond 14-7 [34]
5	canickus 16-8 [44]
3	bighairjer 16-5 [49]
12	letsgrumble 6-12 [52]
3	ComicQuant 17-7 [39]
1	Point Five 18-4 [37]
7	timern 12-8 [32]
1	szavisca 27-3 [44]
2	Tsp99 23-7 [36]
5	BorderlineHoarder 14-7 [42]
2	SonOfWolf 15-4 [57]
9	mattn792 12-10 [30]
3	AJD 19-8 [50]
1	Betty-Bates 21-5 [39]
10	youfoundjake 10-10 [19]

 

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

A side bet:

Spoiler

 

 

 

Edited March 19, 2018 by BlowUpTheMoon

[comicquant]

1 minute ago, BlowUpTheMoon said:

The result of the match-ups:

  Reveal hidden contents

 

9	iXr184 12-10 [47]
6	spidermanbeyond 14-7 [34]
5	canickus 16-8 [44]
3	bighairjer 16-5 [49]
12	letsgrumble 6-12 [52]
3	ComicQuant 17-7 [39]
1	Point Five 18-4 [37]
7	timern 12-8 [32]
1	szavisca 27-3 [44]
2	Tsp99 23-7 [36]
5	BorderlineHoarder 14-7 [42]
2	SonOfWolf 15-4 [57]
9	mattn792 12-10 [30]
3	AJD 19-8 [50]
1	Betty-Bates 21-5 [39]
10	youfoundjake 10-10 [19]

 

 

Congrats @letsgrumble!  Good luck in the fateful eight!

[BlowUpTheMoon]

The Elite Eight has started here:

 

[Point Five]

Man, that Cap 117 looks trampled for a 6.0.

 

[AJD]

2 minutes ago, Point Five said:

Man, that Cap 117 looks trampled for a 6.0.

 

Agreed - I had it at 5.0

But I really overgraded the HOM. I had it at 9.2 - musta missed something.

[comicquant]

1 minute ago, AJD said:

Agreed - I had it at 5.0

But I really overgraded the HOM. I had it at 9.2 - musta missed something.

I had the same.  5.0 on the cap and a 9.2 on the HOM.  Really interested in what I missed there.  

[Point Five]

Ditto... had the Cap at 4.5, the HOM at 9.2.  

[letsgrumble]

9 minutes ago, comicquant said:

Congrats @letsgrumble!  Good luck in the fateful eight!

What the heck! I thought this was my last stop!

Thank you @comicquant. I've been getting very lucky with my grading guesses!

[BorderlineHoarder]

Tough round...whiffed pretty bad on the Hawkman.  It looked nice, but didn't think it could go 9.x with that upper right corner.  Good luck to all the remaining graders!

[Tsp99]

12 minutes ago, Point Five said:

Man, that Cap 117 looks trampled for a 6.0.

 

Completely agree.  BC is fugly and creasing at the top bc puts it in the VG range for me.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

The CGC books:

 

Spoiler

 

[comicquant]

Did anyone guess anywhere near an 8.0 on the HOM?  If you did, what did you see?

[Betty-Bates]

Wow. Just... BUTM, tell the truth! Do you get a book back & think "ya know what, I am going to hold on to that for the grading competition because that is a total mind spoon" ???? wow! Just wow.

[letsgrumble]

My guesses were:

 

CAP = 5.5 originally had 6.0 but changed it.

HAWK = 9.2 
 

HOM = 9.4  Whiffed, big time!
 

SECRET = 3.0 

[timfinz]

15 minutes ago, Point Five said:

Ditto... had the Cap at 4.5, the HOM at 9.2.  

Double Ditto...had the Cap at 4.5, the HOM at 9.2.  

Congrats .5!! May you march straight to the top from here on!

Cheers!