PGM ASM 2 0

[Aliens]

Hey Guys I have my ASM 2 graded by cgc already but I have always thought that CGC was being too generous for what this book got and what it looks like so as a test I just want to know what you guys think it should be and then I will compare now don't get me wrong I trust cgc but I'm just curious thanks, ps I will say that it was graded with OW/W pages 

 

 

Edited March 18, 2018 by Aliens

[Hibou]

From what I can see, personally, I'd say a 3.0 but I'll say the CGC grade is a 3.5.

[conan09279]

It's hard to tell from the picture, but I'd guess 4.0.

[Ride the Tiger]

Yah i'm pretty much anywhere in the 3.0 - 4.0 range so i'll say 3.5 also

[timfinz]

4.0 IMHO

[Primetime]

2.5 - 3.0

I'll guess CGC said 3.5

[Aliens]

thanks guys for all the feedback the grade given by CGC was a 3.5 i'm happy with the grade, i guess it was not so over graded 

[Hibou]

 

I'm also guessing a scan would show some nice eye appeal that's not being picked up by the picture.

[Aliens]

1 hour ago, Hibou said:

 

I'm also guessing a scan would show some nice eye appeal that's not being picked up by the picture.

It looks nice in person thanks 

[1950's war comics]

i was guessing a 3.5 too......

[Ride the Tiger]

I guessed 3.5 on the nose. CGC will be getting my resume for a grader which so far just consists of this thread.

[James J Johnson]

On ‎3‎/‎17‎/‎2018 at 9:21 PM, Hibou said:

From what I can see, personally, I'd say a 3.0 but I'll say the CGC grade is a 3.5.

This. Looks like the majority of CGC 3.0 graded books.

[BuscemasAvengers]

I'd call it a 2.5-3.0 ... did they originally give a 3.5?

[Aliens]

there is a photo of the book with its grade, thanks guys

[1Cool]

Yep - looks like your typical 3.0/3.5 coin flip. Presents pretty nice