2018 Green Eggs Grading Contest - Round 6 5 5

[1Cool]

2 minutes ago, Warlord said:

Would have expected the Pep spine to be completely split before it would get down to 1.5.... 

Detached covers are almost always a 1.5 with the new rules.  Easiest book so far.

[Warlord]

1 minute ago, thirdgreenham said:

I chose it cause it’s GIJoe #1  

granted, I was surprised to get a 6.0

i thought it was a 5.0 and I didn’t even know about the detached centerfold. 

Yeah, I might have called it a 5.5 without the loose centerfold.  If I was feeling generous.

[HighStakesComics]

4.0 and 1.0 here. Not my best work?

[JohnFranklin]

G.I. Joe a 6.0......that hurts my feelings...

[Hudson]

That GI Joe is a 6.0????????

What is he dating that Millie girl from round 2????

I wish CGC would grade the few books I have sent in so kindly (I am sure I am not alone in that desire).

[kav]

I'm forced to just stop grading and take wild stabs.  

[Warlord]

1 minute ago, 1Cool said:

Detached covers are almost always a 1.5 with the new rules.  Easiest book so far.

Then I scoff at those new rules   What's that make a completely split spine, always a .5?

[Dino-Mutt]

Nailed the PEP but way off on the JOE with a 4.0!

[thirdgreenham]

Just now, Warlord said:

Then I scoff at those new rules   What's that make a completely split spine, always a .5?

1.0 

 

[Warlord]

Just now, thirdgreenham said:

1.0 

 

Well, I must scoff at that too! 

[JohnH19]

4.0 and 2.0...quite a letdown after double bullseyes.

[thirdgreenham]

I wanna know the answers to @sckao‘s number game.  

[thirdgreenham]

Just now, JohnH19 said:

4.0 and 2.0...quite a letdown after double bullseyes.

Nobody...I repeat, nobody, gets double bullseyes two rounds in a row!  

[DeadOne]

2 minutes ago, Dino-Mutt said:

Nailed the PEP but way off on the JOE with a 4.0!

+1

[Larryw7]

That book ain't a 6.0. I gave it a 4.5

But I did get a bullseye on the Pep!

 

 

[eddly]

Weird how the 4.5 on the GI JOE book looks like a 6.0, scanner smudges maybe? Clean your scanner.

[Dino-Mutt]

If it's Galactus coming, I hope he gets here after round 10!

[Hudson]

1 minute ago, JohnH19 said:

4.0 and 2.0...quite a letdown after double bullseyes.

That is the same scores I gave them

Maybe we need to start our own grading company.   

[trmoore54]

MY FIRST BULLSEYE!!   The PEP book.  As for the GI JOE I recalled a thread conversation where divad (who I respect a lot grading-wise) said the highest blue label grade a book could get would be a 5.0 with a detached CF...and that was probably a nice book.  So I went 4.5 other factors weighing in.  Pretty surprised at the 6.0 and looks like there could be a considerable amount of inconsistency in this regard with detached CFs.  Oh well...would've been nice if they gave it a 5.5 so I could get the 1 point...

[Sandflea]

3 minutes ago, JohnH19 said:

4.0 and 2.0

Same here...