Please grade my avengers 4 1 1

[Unstoppablejayd]

So stoked to finally get this book... opinions are very much appreciated 

thank you ! 

 

[Mucheee1]

5.0

[conan09279]

5.0 as well.

[Bomber-Bob]

First off, nice book. I like the whiteness of this book. The 'old school grader' in me wants to give this a 4.5, the grade generally given to a well read book with no major flaws but I suspect CGC would give it a 5.0, maybe even a 5.5 with a press/clean.

[JollyComics]

High Five!  Hawaii Five-O!

 

Edited September 8, 2018 by JollyComics

[marmat]

6.0

[James J Johnson]

 

[The Lions Den]

For some reason I'm thinking it's around a 5.0...    

[James J Johnson]

48 minutes ago, The Lions Den said:

For some reason I'm thinking it's around a 5.0...    

(Spoken with my best Bela Lugosi imitation) Don't stop me, I want to count, I have 5, 5, 5 beautiful notches on the CGC grading scale; 1,2,3,4,5,5,5,5,5!!

[Unstoppablejayd]

Awesome! thank you for the response... 6 would be fantastic but I will be more then happy in the 5s... off to the presser it goes and I will post when it returns

[James J Johnson]

5 minutes ago, Unstoppablejayd said:

Awesome! thank you for the response... 6 would be fantastic but I will be more then happy in the 5s... off to the presser it goes and I will post when it returns

Hopefully, on the day of your submission's grading, the number of the day at CGC will be 6 and not 5!   

[bondtrader54]

I guess the 100 or so books i have had graded don't give me the experience  the other posters have because i see a better book than they do. Some small flaws but only the lower spine scuffing seems to detract from the book. Everything else looks minor to me.At the risk of sounding like an amateur i was thinking 6.5-7 as i scrolled.

[Unstoppablejayd]

1 minute ago, bondtrader54 said:

I guess the 100 or so books i have had graded don't give me the experience  the other posters have because i see a better book than they do. Some small flaws but only the lower spine scuffing seems to detract from the book. Everything else looks minor to me.At the risk of sounding like an amateur i was thinking 6.5-7 as i scrolled.

HAHAHA Hopefully you are right! I wonder if the other members will chime in on there reasoning?

[thunsicker]

I'm at a 6.0 as well.  But the back cover photo is a bit fuzzy and I can't decide if that is a large fold, a stain or dirt on the lower left.  Which it is would affect the grade.

[The Lions Den]

On ‎9‎/‎12‎/‎2018 at 1:55 PM, bondtrader54 said:

I guess the 100 or so books i have had graded don't give me the experience  the other posters have because i see a better book than they do. Some small flaws but only the lower spine scuffing seems to detract from the book. Everything else looks minor to me.At the risk of sounding like an amateur i was thinking 6.5-7 as i scrolled.

White cover books are always tough to grade, because most of the flaws don't break color, therefore they don't diminish the eye appeal. And this book falls into that "Bermuda Triangle" area of grading because it's somewhere in the middle. But there is a fairly significant amount of general wear, especially on the spine. The best I could see here is a 5.5, but who knows?