Need help grading my Batman 251! 0

[sidewaysgun]

Debating whether or not to submit this. It's got a good amount of interior wiring with ink, but none on the cover.

Edit: It will be pressed and cleaned! 

Edited November 8, 2018 by sidewaysgun

[theCapraAegagrus]

Tough one. Amateur says... 7.0

[Gnasher]

5.0 at best for me with that amount of interior writing. Front cover looks fine but soiling  and corner creasing on back cover drop the grade too. 

[KobaltDog]

On 11/8/2018 at 2:08 PM, Gnasher said:

5.0 at best for me with that amount of interior writing. Front cover looks fine but soiling  and corner creasing on back cover drop the grade too. 

Without the interior writing,  what would u give it?  I was thinking 7.5

[Point Five]

On 11/8/2018 at 3:08 PM, Gnasher said:

5.0 at best for me with that amount of interior writing. Front cover looks fine but soiling  and corner creasing on back cover drop the grade too. 

Well said; that feels about right. That amount of writing should probably take it out of the Fine range. Still, a really nice 5.0!

 

[1950's war comics]

i have no idea on interior writing , an issue similar to this would be a good one for Andy's grading contest

i think it would still be "fine"

[joeypost]

Don't forget the water stain.. 

Edited November 11, 2018 by joeypost

[sidewaysgun]

I appreciate everyone's input. The book is currently with the presser and i'll submit it to CGC once it's back in my hands. I'll update then. 

[sidewaysgun]

Alright so it's finally back from grading! Pretty happy with the outcome. Thanks for everyone's input, most of you guessed around a fine range!

This one is gonna be for sale so if anyone's interested, lmk.

[RedKryptoniteSuperman]

Hey, 

Maybe you should contact Robert Fernandez and see if he is interested in purchasing it. It’s worth a shot as you already have his address. LOL

-RKSM