Todd McFarlane CGC Private Signing December 2019
12 12

1,036 posts in this topic

162 posts

How does CGC census work? say for example before the signing there were 1000 ASM #300 graded total (SS or otherwise combined) and with this signing about 200 of those graded blue label were resubmitted for get the SS. Does that main that on the Census it will read as 1200 ASM #300 graded, making that number not real?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
520 posts
26 minutes ago, Ladic said:

How does CGC census work? say for example before the signing there were 1000 ASM #300 graded total (SS or otherwise combined) and with this signing about 200 of those graded blue label were resubmitted for get the SS. Does that main that on the Census it will read as 1200 ASM #300 graded, making that number not real?

What I posted was the difference between the two census updates. CGC would subtract the previous Universal (blue) label  if and only if the resubmitter included the blue label .For example, on what I posted,  ASM 299 9.8  has -5 for Universal blue label. Yes, the graded census can be false if the resubmitter cracks open the graded book does not send back the blue label to CGC.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
35 posts

Morning all.  Just finally got an update on my books....4 total - 3 getting pressed, 1 not.  There's no movement on the 3 getting pressed (not even a date change or anything) but the 1 that's not getting pressed is scheduled for grading.  Small victories!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
162 posts
39 minutes ago, catch21 said:

What I posted was the difference between the two census updates. CGC would subtract the previous Universal (blue) label  if and only if the resubmitter included the blue label .For example, on what I posted,  ASM 299 9.8  has -5 for Universal blue label. Yes, the graded census can be false if the resubmitter cracks open the graded book does not send back the blue label to CGC.

Thank you, so in reality the census is not really accurate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
121 posts

So CGC must be lacking submissions, the book that I just sent In to get graded was delivered by usps on Monday and today they received it! Wow it normally takes a week to be received! I was originally going to bet this book which I Just submitted for standard would arrive before my mcfarlane books but now I think my signatures will come First, maybe next week so we will see. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
520 posts
43 minutes ago, Wadezky said:

Morning all.  Just finally got an update on my books....4 total - 3 getting pressed, 1 not.  There's no movement on the 3 getting pressed (not even a date change or anything) but the 1 that's not getting pressed is scheduled for grading.  Small victories!

what was the original date received? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
805 posts

Anyone with a received date of 12/9/19 have any news with your submissions? I’ve got none. Not in a rush to get back, just more curious as to their status with the pressing requested.

Probably didn’t help that one of the slabs I sent in I accidentally left omitted one of the numbers on the form so it’s missing a digit. Hopefully it doesn’t slow things down too much.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
121 posts
4 minutes ago, rogue14 said:

Anyone with a received date of 12/9/19 have any news with your submissions? I’ve got none. Not in a rush to get back, just more curious as to their status with the pressing requested.

Probably didn’t help that one of the slabs I sent in I accidentally left omitted one of the numbers on the form so it’s missing a digit. Hopefully it doesn’t slow things down too much.


hey bud, if u look at the previous comments in this thread U will see the hints they give us as to ur progress But here’s the order I’ve seen so far. 
 

- declared value increase means signed

- ccs email means sent to pressing 
- changed received date on ur submission means the books were pressed. 
- cgc submission email means ur in line for grading 

 

and that’s as far as I’ve gotten so I assume it will be updated and changed as it normally would from here 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
34 posts
55 minutes ago, rogue14 said:

Anyone with a received date of 12/9/19 have any news with your submissions? I’ve got none. Not in a rush to get back, just more curious as to their status with the pressing requested.

Probably didn’t help that one of the slabs I sent in I accidentally left omitted one of the numbers on the form so it’s missing a digit. Hopefully it doesn’t slow things down too much.

Mine were received on 12/11 (delivery of 12/9 by USPS) and grades were posted this morning.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
121 posts
10 minutes ago, mrbinkelstein said:

Mine were received on 12/11 (delivery of 12/9 by USPS) and grades were posted this morning.

Dude I wonder if those of us who wanted pressing get graded after everyone who didn’t want it!  NOOOOOOOO

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
34 posts
7 minutes ago, hachimaull said:

Dude I wonder if those of us who wanted pressing get graded after everyone who didn’t want it!  NOOOOOOOO

I thought I had read in the thread that b/c of the delay with TM gettting sick that the pressings were done prior to him arriving in Florida to sign, instead of after. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
35 posts
1 hour ago, catch21 said:

what was the original date received? 

Marked as received on 12-12 (actually received per customer service on 12-6)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
354 posts
12 minutes ago, mrbinkelstein said:

I thought I had read in the thread that b/c of the delay with TM gettting sick that the pressings were done prior to him arriving in Florida to sign, instead of after. 

That would suck seeing how he was handling the comics during the signing...

All of my books arrived on 11/27 and are still in received with no movement and all needed presses. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
520 posts

12-11 received now says schedule for grading,..... 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
121 posts
18 minutes ago, Wadezky said:

Marked as received on 12-12 (actually received per customer service on 12-6)

Yeah takes a week normally from Usps drop off at cgc to get input into their system. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13,716 posts
48 minutes ago, hachimaull said:

Dude I wonder if those of us who wanted pressing get graded after everyone who didn’t want it!  NOOOOOOOO

Of Course they do :foryou: pressing takes a minute, those who didn't want pressing went straight to the grading room, the one's with pressing got pressed after singing and will take a second to get to the grading room...

39 minutes ago, mrbinkelstein said:

I thought I had read in the thread that b/c of the delay with TM gettting sick that the pressings were done prior to him arriving in Florida to sign, instead of after. 

I don't remember that being mentioned, but CGC wouldn't do that  :) 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
34 posts
29 minutes ago, YouFoundDonon said:

That would suck seeing how he was handling the comics during the signing...

All of my books arrived on 11/27 and are still in received with no movement and all needed presses. 

I saw all the videos but don't recall him specifically mishandling them. Does anyone have a link? Now I'm nervous. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
354 posts
24 minutes ago, mrbinkelstein said:

I saw all the videos but don't recall him specifically mishandling them. Does anyone have a link? Now I'm nervous. 

Certainly not pointing towards an extreme case, but there were videos of him leaning his elbows on comics and handling a couple comics unboarded that were flopping around. 

Not an issue if they weren't pressed IMO, but can potentially take a 9.8 and make it a 9.6 if already pressed. 
 

In before grader notes on a 9.6: "Finger Prints and Slight Indents to Cover"

Edited by YouFoundDonon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
48 posts
2 hours ago, hachimaull said:


hey bud, if u look at the previous comments in this thread U will see the hints they give us as to ur progress But here’s the order I’ve seen so far. 
 

- declared value increase means signed

- ccs email means sent to pressing 
- changed received date on ur submission means the books were pressed. 
- cgc submission email means ur in line for grading 

 

and that’s as far as I’ve gotten so I assume it will be updated and changed as it normally would from here 

6 in "Received" with a 12/6 date. Three for pressing. No changes to declared value. 

I called cgc and they said the three for pressing where there and I didn't see an email from them.

Also, all the books should have been signed so if declared value increase means signed, then shouldn't all declared values go up? Maybe not?

Either way, I think those progression points are good guides but doesn't seem to mean that there's no progression if you don't see them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
121 posts
13 minutes ago, 315008 said:

6 in "Received" with a 12/6 date. Three for pressing. No changes to declared value. 

I called cgc and they said the three for pressing where there and I didn't see an email from them.

Also, all the books should have been signed so if declared value increase means signed, then shouldn't all declared values go up? Maybe not?

Either way, I think those progression points are good guides but doesn't seem to mean that there's no progression if you don't see them.


yeah, it could be a flawed system but if u see one of the progress points I stated it should give u an idea where ur book is. Also at this point all books are signed maybe they only upped value in the beginning or maybe ur submission being both pressed and not pressed changed it up a bit.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
12 12