PGM and PPO War Comics #33 (two of them!) 0

[JollyComics]

Please grade my two books and Please pick one (PPO) that I will keep the higher grade copy.

I am trapped and torn between them because they looked so similar in grade.

Help me and pick one for me. Thanks for the advance.

Copy A

Front Cover

Back Cover

Spoiler

Copy B

Front Cover

Back Cover

Spoiler

 

[Deadpoolica]

copy A is the winner imo 

Edited November 15, 2019 by Deadpoolica

[JollyComics]

45 minutes ago, Deadpoolica said:

copy A is the winner imo 

I totally agreed with you. Can you share the grade?  Wink! Wink!

[Deadpoolica]

1 hour ago, JollyComics said:

I totally agreed with you. Can you share the grade?  Wink! Wink!

A: 5.5 maybe 6.0

B: 5.0

[mrd160]

A. 6.0

B. 5.0

both nice books but a is the winner imo 

[rjpb]

Copy A 5.5-6.0, copy B 5.0-5.5 (dropped for the white blotch on knee). CGC generally seems a little tougher on spine wear than minor edge chipping, so I wouldn't be entirely shocked if they came back the same grade if you sent them to CGC.

Interesting that they have nearly identical top corner chips. 

I would go with copy A, unless copy B has distinctly superior page quality. That's usually the decider for me when two books have similar eye-appeal. 

[JollyComics]

Hey to all who gave the estimate grades (I am little shocked about it).

You can compare my books to Heritage grade - War Comics #33

BTW, thanks for your honest grade.