• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

2020 "I WANT THIS TO BE ADDED TO A SET" REQUEST
19 19

Started by Matt G,

756 posts in this topic

MrWalkingDead

MrWalkingDead

Posted
Posted
On 1/4/2020 at 10:33 PM, Sensei Ryan said:

Hello - can we please get the following issues added to the following sets?

Set: Walking Dead (2003 Complete with Variants)

Walking Dead: The Alien #nn Local Comic Shop Day Edition added. CGC has only graded this variant. 

Walking Dead #1 The Last Wine Variant. This book cannot be added at this time. It has yet to be graded by CGC and the variant was only available, initially, produced for a wine company and packaged with their products. This may end up being too rare of an item to add to the set as it may not be possible for others to obtain. I suggest that we revisit this one later on down the road. I apologize for any inconvenience this has caused. 

Set: Walking Dead (2003)

Walking Dead: The Alien #nn  Local Comic Shop Day Edition added. CGC has only graded this variant. 

This request was made a while back in the 2019 thread but was skipped over from what looks to be a couple of times.  Both books are valid as one contains storyline material (The Alien) and the other is a reprint of #1.  Please consider adding these issues to the following sets as graded copies of both have shown up on the secondary market.

Thank you for the time and consideration!

Ryan

The Last Wine variant should definitely be added to the Walking Dead set (i have one about to grade)-  it is a number 1 reprint- and apparently 1000 were printed-  which is more than any of the 15th ann books or many of the comic con variants which are ALL in the set-  i dont think print count should stop a book from being entered into a set-  the Hyundai variant is extremely rare but it is in the set- and it is obtainable-  i have seen more Wine books for sale in the last few months than the Hyundai in 5 years-  not adding a book because of a low print run doesn't seem fair to the dedicated collector, plus it is in-fact a legit book and it belongs in the set- i too have already seen some graded-  so not sure why that book would get denied. (just my 2 cents)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
kuddy

kuddy

Posted
Posted

Please add the following to Old Man Logan (2016):

32 - 1262594006
32 Variant - 1262594008
33 - 1262591014
34 - 1262587020
35 - (no CGC number)
35 Variant - 1990679006
36 - 1262563020
36 Variant - 1262563022
37 - 2022005015
38 - (no CGC number)
38 Variant - (no CGC number)
39 - 2022005016
40 - 2022005017
41 - 2022005018
42 - 2022005019
43 - 2022005020
44 - 2042620016
45 - 2042620019
46 - 2042620022
47 - 2022005024
48 - 2022005025
49 - 2022006001
50 - 2022006002
50 Variant - 2022006003
50 Zaffino Variant - 2022006004
50 NYCC Variant - 2008138007

Slots created. Thank you

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jason Milburn

Jason Milburn

Posted
Posted

Hello! I am having some trouble with this House of X #5 I just bought from Ebay (pic attached).

Cert # 2081375005.

I believe it is the Sara Pichelli variant, but you can see in the picture that the label appears to state that it is the main cover.

I tried to add it to the #5 main cover slot in the "House of X (complete)" set (since there was no Pitchelli variant slot), but it didn't take it. So, I think what needs to happen is the #5 Pichelli variant needs added to the set, and hopefully it will accept this number even though the label is wrong. Or maybe I am having a brain fart. Let me know what you think - Thanks! 

house-of-x-5.jpg

House of X #5 slot created. If you believe that this is labeled incorrectly please reach out to our team at submissions@cgccomics.com and provide the images. They will be able to assist you with having the book reholdered (free of charge) if it is labeled incorrectly. Thank you

Link to comment
Share on other sites
jgrace4219

jgrace4219

Posted
Posted

Can you please add the following issues to the Star Wars (2015) set? Thanks.

Star Wars (2015) #22 (Mile High Comics Edition) Slot Created

Star Wars (2015) #23 (Mile High Comics Edition) Slot Created

Star Wars (2015) #24 (Mile High Comics Edition) Slot Created

Star Wars (2015) #26 (Mile High Comics Edition) Slot Created

Star Wars (2015) #30 (Mile High Comics Edition) Slot Created

Star Wars (2015) #34 (Mile High Comics Edition) None graded by CGC at this time

Star Wars (2015) #37 (Mile High Comics Edition) None graded by CGC at this time

Star Wars (2015) #38 (Mile High Comics Edition) None graded by CGC at this time

Star Wars (2015) #39 (Mile High Comics Edition) None graded by CGC at this time

Star Wars (2015) #41 (Mile High Comics Edition) None graded by CGC at this time

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
GAM

GAM

Posted
Posted

Please add Captain Marvel Adventures #101 to the Seduction of the Innocent (SOTI) registry set.

Slot created. Thank you for providing the details as it speeds up things on my end!

This comic is referenced in the text on pages 87-88 of the Seduction of the Innocent. Beginning on page 87, Wertham recounts his experience with a boy that was brought to him as a patient and how comics influenced his behavior. On page 88, the boy makes a statement about a Captain Marvel story: “I don’t think they should read Captain Marvel. Look at this one with all the pictures of the man without his head!’”. The boy is referring to the story “The Invisibility Trap” contained in Captain Marvel Adventures #101. In this story, Captain Marvel is splashed with an invisibility potion that renders his head and other body parts invisible. The identification of Captain Marvel Adventures #101 as the source material came from Carol L. Tilley, an associate professor at the University of Illinois. Tilley extensively researched Wertham’s archives stored at the Library of Congress to produce her paper “Seducing the Innocent: Fredric Wertham and the Falsifications That Helped Condemn Comics”.

 

Pulling from Wertham’s archives, Tilley describes the background for the SOTI passage on pages 87-88 as follows, “Richard, an eleven-year-old Caucasian boy, was brought to Lafargue by his mother, who claimed the boy had ‘wild imaginations’ and engaged in rough play with neighborhood children. In Seduction, Wertham painted a picture, colored with copious quotations from the boy, of a life debased by comics: he delighted in depictions of bondage, mock-threatened playmates with eye gouging and hanging, and scratched a child in the face. All of these actions, Wertham proposed, could not be explained adequately in existing books on child psychiatry or guidance; instead, comics were ‘a new kind of bacillus’ for which psychiatrists could provide a prophylaxis. In the case notes, Richard himself supported the idea that comics promote problematic behaviors: ‘I think something else about story and adventure comics. I think they shouldn’t have them on the stands, it is bad for children. When they buy the comic books they start thinking all sorts of things, playing games. I played such games because I got them from comic books. That’s why I think children shouldn’t have them.’ That Richard engaged in the activities that Wertham described or even that he spoke many of the words Wertham attributed to him is not in dispute, but a careful comparison of his case as presented in the Seduction of the Innocent with the archival notes demonstrates how Wertham manipulated evidence to persuade readers of the ill effects of comic book reading on children’s behavior. For instance, in the book Richard says, ‘If I had a younger brother… I wouldn’t want him to read the horror comic books like Weird Science, because he might get scared. I don’t think they should read Captain Marvel. Look at this one with all the pictures of the man without his head!’ In the case notes, however, Richard referred not to ‘horror comic books’ but to ‘fiction comic books,’ and Captain Marvel is not mentioned until a later session. Although Richard did remark about a headless man, he indicated only a page in Captain Marvel #101 (October 1949); the case notes include Wertham’s comments that ‘there are 5 pictures like this on one page.’ Readers of Seduction are free to use their own ‘wild imaginations’ in visualizing what could be a potentially gory decapitated man. In reality, though, it is simply Captain Marvel himself; he has been splashed in the face with an invisibility potion”.

Captain Marvel Adventures 101 Page 4 - SOTI Page 88.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Taxmick1

Taxmick1

Posted
Posted

Hi!  Please add to the "Wormwood: Gentleman Corpse" set:

Wormwood: Gentleman Corpse #1 Convention Edition  (1587589010) This Cert is for Batman #1 8/16 ComicConBox Edition. We have both CGC graded books listed in the set which are the standard issue and the Retailer Incentive Edition.

Wormwood: Gentleman Corpse Christmas Special #nn (1967818015) This is not a valid certification number and we have not graded this book, therefore I am not able to add it to the set. 

Thanks - Mike

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Taxmick1

Taxmick1

Posted
Posted

Please add to the "Liberty Meadows" set:

Liberty Meadows #2 Second Printing (1505782008)

Liberty Meadows #3 Second Printing (1505782011)

Liberty Meadows #3 Third Printing (1505782009)

Thanks - Mike

 

Slots Created. Thank you

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Taxmick1

Taxmick1

Posted
Posted

Please add to the "Preacher #1-66" set:

Preacher #1 Retailer Incentive Edition (1607308006)

Preacher #1 Comicon Box Variant Cover (1461400004)

Preacher #1 Comicon Box "Virgin" Edition (1405780006)

Preacher 20 Jahre Jubilaums Special #NN German Edition (1607308011)

Thanks - Mike

Slots Created. Thank you

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
kuddy

kuddy

Posted
Posted

Please add the following to Amazing Spider-Man (Complete with Variants):

Slots added. Please note that multiple slots were changed as the cert numbers provided were for different variants. Please use the cert verification tool to confirm the variants. Thank you! 

#5 3rd Printing - 2065651004
#16 - 2054259003
#16 Variant - 2042233009
#16 2nd Printing - 2042619024
#16.HU - 2054259008
#16.HU 2nd Printing - 2042620002
#17 - 2054259012
#17 Variant - 2037049009
#17 Smith Variant - 2037049008
#17 Sketch Edition - (I don't have a CGC number)
#17 2nd Printing - 2042620006
#18 - 2054259016
#18 Variant - 2042391005
#18 Shavrin Variant - 2036925006
#18.HU - 2054259021
#18.HU 2nd Printing - 2065764005
#19 - 2054260003
#19 Variant - 2065764008
#19 Henrichon Variant - 2054260004
#19.HU - 2054260008
#20 Bagley Variant - 2040218008
#20 Yu Variant - (I don't have a CGC number) We have not graded this variant so I am unable to add it. 
#20.HU Variant - 2054260014
#21 - 2054260019
#21 Jo Variant Cover - 2047360001
#21 Comic Mint Edition - 2045523001
#21 Comic Mint Virgin Edition - 2056482005
#21 Yu Variant Cover - (I don't have a CGC number) We have not graded this variant so I am unable to add it. 
#21 2nd Printing - 2065764023
#22 - 2054260021
#22 Kuder Variant Cover- 2054333002
#22 2nd Printing - 2065764024
#23 - 2054260024
#23 Acuna Variant - 2054261005 - Variant Edition Added
#23 2nd Printing - 2065764014
#24 - 2054261009
#24 Variant - 2054261007 - Quesada Variant Cover Added
#24 Brown Variant - 2054580013 - Comics Elite Edition Added
#25 - 2054261014
#25 Nauck Variant Cover- 2054261016
#25 Simonson Variant Cover - 2054261018
#25 Hipp Variant Cover- 2054261019
#25 Brown Variant Cover - 2059568006
#25 Brown Virgin Edition - 2069749010

Link to comment
Share on other sites
StephenWA

StephenWA

Posted
Posted
On 1/16/2020 at 2:41 PM, MrWalkingDead said:

The Last Wine variant should definitely be added to the Walking Dead set (i have one about to grade)-  it is a number 1 reprint- and apparently 1000 were printed-  which is more than any of the 15th ann books or many of the comic con variants which are ALL in the set-  i dont think print count should stop a book from being entered into a set-  the Hyundai variant is extremely rare but it is in the set- and it is obtainable-  i have seen more Wine books for sale in the last few months than the Hyundai in 5 years-  not adding a book because of a low print run doesn't seem fair to the dedicated collector, plus it is in-fact a legit book and it belongs in the set- i too have already seen some graded-  so not sure why that book would get denied. (just my 2 cents)

I originally requested that this book (The Walking Dead #1 The Last Wine Variant) should be added to the two applicable sets (TWD 2003 and TWD 2003 with variants) on 12 December 2019. I was told that the book had not been graded by CGC yet.

Since then Sensei Ryan (5 January 2020) and Mr WalkingDead (16 January 2020) have both requested that this book should be added to those sets.

CGC has now graded the book - e.g. # 2546065003.

Please add the book as requested.

Kind regards

Stephen

Hi Stephen,

This slot has been added. Thank you for your patience. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
19 19
Go to topic listing