POINT FIVE'S "LIGHTNING ROUND" GRADING CHALLENGE: SLAB REVEALS & FINAL SCORES! 3 3

[Point Five]

Thanks for playing, guys! This was a lot of fun.

OK, here we go!

 

[Point Five]

I'll post the slabs one by one, then a chart with final scores at the end.

--
Book 1: Air Ace V2 #1

[Point Five]

Book 2: Batman #227

In hand, I was guessing this was a 7.5/8.0 tweener by CGC's current standards. Was hoping for the 8.0 but alas.

[thirdgreenham]

 

[Point Five]

Book 3: Black Cat Mystery #47 copy A

[WolverineX]

Too many gift grades.

[Point Five]

...and if you liked that one... you'll love this one.

Book 4: Black Cat Mystery #47 copy B

[WolverineX]

Just now, Point Five said:

...and if you liked that one... you'll love this one.

Book 4: Black Cat Mystery #47 copy B

Bulleye.

[comicquant]

Lesson learned...  Never grade ANYTHING after a few drinks...

[WolverineX]

I must live in an alternate universe where CGC always gives everyone else 1 more higher than I guess, but always gives me 1 point less on the books I submit. 

[ADAMANTIUM]

I have 10 points so far I think no bullseye though

[Point Five]

And for the record, I don't have a vast inventory and it was completely random that I had two of these to submit and they came back the same grade. (It's not like I sat around saying "wow, I've got a BCM #47 in 4.0, better go grab another one before the contest!")

 

[WolverineX]

Well if you sell, those, I'll take copy A

[Point Five]

Book 5: Captain Science #6

Was thinking 4.5 on this, but I guess 4.0 is reasonable. Great colors for the grade tho.
 

[TheTallGuy]

I was overthinking it... I said to myself "there is no way two copies of the same book would get exactly the same score..."

[WolverineX]

Just now, Point Five said:

Book 5: Captain Science #6

Was thinking 4.5 on this, but I guess 4.0 is reasonable. Great colors for the grade tho.
 

Damn< I said 4.5 too. 

[comicginger1789]

I was with ya on the 4.5 for Captain Science...and shot too low on the Batman 227

I bullseyed the Black Cats though

Edited February 24, 2020 by comicginger1789

[speedcake]

3 Bullseyes so far 

[flashlites]

I'm doing surprisingly well so far?! 

[Point Five]

Book 6: Famous Crimes 1