Help grade these books part II

[tod09]

Hi all. Two more books. I didn't want to post more that 2 at one time or it'll crash/freeze all the old dial-ups. Please help me with the grades that you think CGC would give on these. I'm only considering CGC grading if I can get 9.6 or better since I'd hate to part with my books but 5 times+ guide it too hard to resist.

 

Tod

[supapimp]

where's the pic?

[murph0]

where's the pic?

 

He's waiting for Highlite to post them

 

Brian

[LordRahl]

[LordRahl]

[murph0]

Umm... 9.4... 9.0 respectively..I guess

 

Brian

[supapimp]

send them in, they're worth it.

[Warlord]

I'd guess about 9.4 and 9.2. Definitely sharp books, but without image clarity you have to wonder what is being missed.

 

 

[ninanina]

From what I can see, both books are perfect except for that lower left corner on the Kull comic, but as mentioned, it's what you don't see. The first has a chance at a 9.6, but it's a big maybe. Don't think the Kull qualifies as a 9.6 but it's up there. They are definitly worth slabbing even if they don't get that elusive 9.6.

[Foolkiller]

I would say a 9.4 on the Marvel Premiere and a 9.0 possibly even an 8.5 on the Kull only because I can see some more defects even in the somewhat blurred picture. Judging a 9.6 just from these pics is really, really tough. If you hold the book in your hand, then at least you can a better idea of all the defects (for better or for worse) because I might be too harsh here, cause I'm guessing.

[doyle033]

well i would try out both of them. the premiere looks like a possible 9.6 heck maybe even 9.8. hard to guess from pic. could be a 9.4 as well. but close enough to try. the creatures is a bit less, i am guessing 9.2-9.4 range. but a 9.6 could happen on both and what the heck, its worth it. if one comes back a 9.8 and the other a 9.2 then you know what to do with the 9.8 dont you? you can flip it for more that 5x and keep the other!!