J.Sid

Have to disagree with this. Take a step back and look again. Miller. Elektra. Vintage. An absolutely fantastic image. If drawn on one board it would have gone for 2x the result. Probably much more. Actually if this were drawn on one board the consignor probably would not have selected it to consign. It would take a 7-figure offer to pry it away. Just my

I have often wondered why Kirby Avengers pages were so "low." Between the great character content, the surge of Avengers popularity, and the scarcity of issues he penciled (8, compared with 100 FF books for example) I always felt these should cost more.

Anyone know the story with the water damage on all these? https://comics.ha.com/itm/original-comic-art/story-page/scott-mccloud-understanding-comics-story-page-36-original-art-tundra-publishing-1993-/p/322410-63003.s?ic4=ListView-ShortDescription-071515

Great thread. I used to think I would be strong, but then a grail-ish piece from my childhood showed up for sale from "Seller/Dealer/Website X" It was bad. I held out for a long while. But it was one of those stupid scenarios where they raised the price a couple times after it didn't sell. In the end I swallowed my pride and paid up. It was during the pandemic surge and I didn't want the price to get raised even higher!

And this one doesn't suck either. Normally I like my WM pages to be nine panels and have word balloons on them, but in this case I'd make an exception: Watchmen

That Moebius is awesome!

Don't forget the first appearance of Alpha Flight! And while I wasn't a huge fan of the Proteus storyline, friends (along with the Artist Edition) have been able to convince me that those issues are the actual artistic peak of the run.

Nobody asked, but I'll weigh in: Did ANY of the Byrne X-Men pages get live bids? Maybe the 2nd page got one? It seems like all three were "price discovered" before the auction. I don't think Rob posted any wins to Facebook. Could be a factor. I'd take the 137 cover over the 141 cover. 141 cover is better drawn, but doesn't give me chills the way 137 does. When I started collecting (early 2000s) here was a small mini-cabal of Byrne collectors who tried to convince the world that DoFP was equal or superior to the Dark Phoenix Saga... I never bought what they were selling. I LOVED the 137 page from this auction. Was 100% as good as it gets without being some key very specific A+ moment. (maybe this is why the DD181 went so high... no DD or Elektra, but very memorable scene)

What's the story with his Killing Joke Prelims? And by that I mean specifically, did Brian do multiple prelims per page for that story? (I've seen a bunch over the years each flushed out at very different levels of detail.)

Don't know if it's more marketable, but I know a lot of people who would rather have #96

This one is very nice, and the published cover is iconic. I think Bolland was the best cover artist of the decade, but I am shocked that someone will be paying 10k+ (including tax) for a prelim. Thoughts? Is his work so scarce that people will fight for whatever they can get? Bolland Wonder Woman Prelim

I have to admit, I was skeptical about this show given the price and airfare/hotel required.... but it looks like it's shaping up pretty well. I think East Coast in January was the way to go. Collectors eager for a break from winter?

Thanks for posting this. I don't like reading Conan comics... but I LOVE looking at Conan OA pages.

Somebody sought him out and presented that cover to him to sign.... let's give him kudos for not signing it across the characters as has happened in the past with other celeb signatures

There was an earlier thread on this board and also on FB regarding this one. The consensus was that it was not OA.

It may seem like it on this board, but not everyone in this hobby pays attention to Hertiage. Also, I know not all items are archived on Heritage forever. Not sure how it goes down, but there are auctions I bid on which no longer show up in a search or in my bidding archives.

This is interesting because as we all know, possession of the OA does not grant reproduction rights. There are many collectors who like for their stuff to be as hidden as possible, beginning the moment they win the piece... I can imagine these types would not want HA distributing scans, and thus I can imagine HA not wanting to irk their customers. Legally though? If Scott has the rights to do the book, does it matter which of the five previous owners the scan came from? Probably not.

Success rate goes up greatly if you target pieces that have been on the dealer's website for a while (1+years).

Yet another Sienkiewicz piece I hated at the time, but now love:

Send the artist a copy of this book. He clearly needs to be retrained to draw like collectors on this board are accustomed to seeing their characters drawn.

So.... after any fees, tax and shipping, what will the winner have paid for this one?

Maybe... maybe not. On one hand, we all know people utilize friends to win their own pieces back when things aren't going as planned. On the other hand, we're so used to "price discovery" in OA auctions that we get surprised when people actually wait until the last day to put their bid in. In many other collectibles areas, people don't jack things up the first 24 hours of the auction.

Very surprised the Star Wars cover stalled where it did.

What he was getting at is that guidelines for this particular forum require a price be listed as a starting point.