Robert Doggett

Member
  • Content Count

    112
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Robert Doggett

  • Boards Title
    Collector is an understatement.

Personal Information

  • Hobbies
    Comics, of course!
  • Location
    Maryland

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. That makes sense to me! Thanks for the comments and insight on the point system.
  2. Hey Matt, Comic Connect auction realized prices for the following books. Marvel Team-Up 9 CGC 9.8 $560 Score Increased Marvel Team-Up 10 CGC 9.8 $1,000 Score not changed. Marcel Team-Up 18 CGC 9.8 $398Score not changed. @Robert Doggett, Thank you for your due diligence. Please note that I will not be reviewing and updating scores every time one book is sold. In order to properly determine the scores we require multiple sales in multiple grades. #10 and #18 do not warrant an increase as the sales for one 9.8 book seem skewed and will throw off our scoring formula for all other grades. Could you please take a look at these? I will provide links To the books tomorrow. I think these prices are a wee bit inflated, especially issue 10. It appears that two people with sheer determination to win were bidding on this book and one finally came to their senses. LOL This shouldn't be more than a $600 book. Bottom line is that someone actually paid this $1K.
  3. Hey Matt, Here's the next installment of Marvel Team-Ups. I went through issues 31-50 plus the annuals. Title / Issue 9.8 pts GPA 90 avg/last sale Notes Marvel Team-Up 31 64 $245/May 2020 Marvel Team-Up 32 64 $400/Jun 2019 Rarity: Two 9.8's exist Marvel Team-Up 33 64 $203/May 2016 Old sale; Two 9.8's exist Marvel Team-Up 34 64 $158/Oct 2019 Marvel Team-Up 35 64 $150/Jun 2019 Marvel Team-Up 36 64 $153/Oct 2019 Marvel Team-Up 37 64 N/A Rarity: One 9.8 exists; Never been sold on open market that GPA monitors Marvel Team-Up 38 64 $215/Mar 2019 Marvel Team-Up 41 64 $123/Jul 2019 Marvel Team-Up 43 64 $200/Mar 2018 Marvel Team-Up 44 64 $132/Jul 2018 Marvel Team-Up 45 64 $139/Mar 2020 Marvel Team-Up 46 72 $144/Aug 2019 Marvel Team-Up 47 64 $117/Aug 2018 Marvel Team-Up 48 64 $200/May 2020 Marvel Team-Up annual 1 320 $615/Mar 2020 2018 average was $404 w/ four sales Marvel Team-Up annual 3 50 $135/Aug 2019 Marvel Team-Up annual 4 50 $111/Apr 2020 Marvel Team-Up annual 6 48 $110/Oct 2017 Thanks for taking a look at these, Matt! I appreciate anything you can do with these registry points. Again, apologies for my absent mindedness! Scores updated slightly. Thank you
  4. Matt, I don't know what I'm doing wrong. I swear I think I'm in the right thread when I post this stuff. I'll be more aware of my surroundings from now on. My apologies!!
  5. Hey Matt, Here's the next installment of Marvel Team-Ups. I went through issues 31-50 plus the annuals. Title / Issue 9.8 pts GPA 90 avg/last sale Notes Marvel Team-Up 31 64 $245/May 2020 Marvel Team-Up 32 64 $400/Jun 2019 Rarity: Two 9.8's exist Marvel Team-Up 33 64 $203/May 2016 Old sale; Two 9.8's exist Marvel Team-Up 34 64 $158/Oct 2019 Marvel Team-Up 35 64 $150/Jun 2019 Marvel Team-Up 36 64 $153/Oct 2019 Marvel Team-Up 37 64 N/A Rarity: One 9.8 exists; Never been sold on open market that GPA monitors Marvel Team-Up 38 64 $215/Mar 2019 Marvel Team-Up 41 64 $123/Jul 2019 Marvel Team-Up 43 64 $200/Mar 2018 Marvel Team-Up 44 64 $132/Jul 2018 Marvel Team-Up 45 64 $139/Mar 2020 Marvel Team-Up 46 72 $144/Aug 2019 Marvel Team-Up 47 64 $117/Aug 2018 Marvel Team-Up 48 64 $200/May 2020 Marvel Team-Up annual 1 320 $615/Mar 2020 2018 average was $404 w/ four sales Marvel Team-Up annual 3 50 $135/Aug 2019 Marvel Team-Up annual 4 50 $111/Apr 2020 Marvel Team-Up annual 6 48 $110/Oct 2017 Thanks for taking a look at these, Matt! I appreciate anything you can do with these registry points.
  6. I didn't purchase it myself rather a Mr. Schmell bought it in hopes of it getting a 9.8 with a press. He bought it, cracked it, pressed it, resubmitted it to no avail. If it came back a 9.8, he was going to sell it to me.
  7. Pedigree sold one a couple of months ago for about the same price range. It was a 9.6 with a possibility for a 9.8 (w/ press) but came back a 9.6. That was mine otherwise! One will come to me eventually!
  8. I'll do my best to use my better judgement. LOL I went through all of the books that you adjusted and didn't have any complaints whatsoever. I appreciate what you do! I'll only list books that are selling for at least twice the point value that they're listed at in 9.8. GPA is my source. So without further ado... Title/issue 9.8 registry pts Avg/last sale Marvel Team-Up 11 120 $432/Jul 2018 Marvel Team-Up 15 180 $370/Mar 2020 Marvel Team-Up 16 120 $227/Feb 2017 (I know it's not doubled but there are only 3 9.8s in existence out of 68 total graded: 4.41%) Marvel Team-Up 17 120 $250/Jan 2010 (Last sale was a decade ago, I know) Marvel Team-Up 18 120 $260/Sep 2018 Marvel Team-Up 21 75 $326/Aug 2015 (Too stale?) Marvel Team-Up 22 75 $125/Dec 2013 (Only one 9.8 exists out of 28 total graded: 3.57%) Marvel Team-Up 23 75 $248/Nov 2019 Marvel Team-Up 25 75 $360/Aug 2019 Marvel Team-Up 26 75 $151/Feb 2020 Marvel Team-Up 27 75 $275/Jun 2018 Marvel Team-Up 28 75 $225/Feb 2011 (Western Penn pedigree) Only two 9.8 exist out of 31 total graded: 6.45% Marvel Team-Up 30 75 $360/Nov 2017 (Only one 9.8 exists out of 22 total graded: 4.76%) I'll stop at issue 30 and pick up after you had a chance to look over these. Since I was putting down percentages, I'd like to revisit Marvel Team-Up 1 where there are a mere three 9.8's that exist out of 994 graded. That's a staggering 0.30% success rate! Thanks for any and all considerations Scores Updated. Thank you
  9. Hey Matt, Could you please review the below Marvel Team-Ups. I have omitted issues 12&13 and annuals 2&7 as they appeared to be pretty spot on. Title/issue # 9.8 points 90 day avg/last sale Notes Marvel Team-Up 11 120 $432/Jul 2018 Only three 9.8s in existence Marvel Team-Up 14 120 $225/Sep 2019 Marvel Team-Up 15 180 $370/Mar 2020 90 day avg (2 sales) $369 Marvel Team-Up 16 120 $227/Feb 2017 Marvel Team-Up 17 120 $250/Jan 2010 Only three 9.8s in existence Marvel Team-Up 18 120 $260/Sep 2018 Marvel Team-Up 19 120 $200/Sep 2019 Marvel Team-Up 20 120 $200/Aug 2019 Marvel Team-Up ann 1 320 $615/Mar 2020 Four sales before this averaged $414 Marvel Team-Up ann 3 50 $135/Aug 2019 Marvel Team-Up ann 4 50 $105 avg Last sale $111/Apr 2020 Marvel Team-Up ann 5 48 $85/Sep 2017 Marvel Team-Up ann 6 48 $110/Oct 2017
  10. Thanks, Matt! I plan on going through all 157 books, ten at a time so I don't overwhelm the system. Plus, I enjoy doing the research. All of the latter ones are 32-40 points for 9.8s. They usually don't go for less than $75 each, but I'll get to those in due time. Thanks again! Hello @Robert Doggett, I am happy to review the books that are grossly under valued. Please note that I did not change the point values for all books in your initial post as some were scored correctly or lacked recent/multiple sale data. Please try your best to limit your requests to those that meet the criteria stated above if possible. Thank you!
  11. Hey Matt, I believe I know what you need to adjust scores so I'm going to list some Marvel Team-Ups (1972) Title/issue # 9.8 points 90 day avg/ last sale Notes Marvel Team-Up 1 1400 $5000/Apr 2008 Three 9.8's in existence Marvel Team-Up 2 440 $725/Oct 2018 Marvel Team-Up 3 520 $655/Jan 2019 Marvel Team-Up 4 520 $913/Sep 2019 Marvel Team-Up 5 190 $263/Feb 2017 I don't have an explanation for the lucky sap who got this book for $35 so this one might be OK. Marvel Team-Up 6 190 $405/Apr 2018 Marvel Team-Up 7 190 $319/2018 average Two sales in 2018 Marvel Team-Up 8 190 $273/Oct 2019 Marvel Team-Up 9 190 $385/Jun 2018 Marvel Team-Up 10 190 $450/Jun 2011 Three 9.8's in existence. This list doesn't have drastic changes with the exception of issue 1 but I feel they're all a little lower than they should be. Thanks for any love you can give this list! Some of the scores have been slightly increased but not all of them. Please note that some of the books are lacking recent sales so we are not able to make changes.
  12. I'm always buying more books! It's an addiction!
  13. Thanks, Randall! I looked there but $75 for 5 boxes seems pretty steep in my opinion. If they're already in Mylite bags and acid free boards, what's the purpose of the box being acid free? I realize it's another layer of protection, but I can't justify it. I live close enough to Gerber to pick up from their shop and often do. I love their product! Many thanks for the suggestion!
  14. I like the creativity, shadroch, but I just want a box to fit my silver age FF books in.