advice for new collectors
5 5

180 posts in this topic

2,207 posts
Ask away, I am up.

 

You obviously know CGC. You know PGX is badbadbad, right?

 

 

 

-slym

 

I saw a thread about some guy there stealing peoples' books and stuff.

I'm in Canada, so I keep hoping CGC will open a division in the north here.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
52,480 posts

CGC needs at least one more facility, on the west coast of America. One in the northeast wouldn't be a bad idea, either...

 

 

 

-slym

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
188 posts
88 posts

If you are a completionist like me collect the hardest books to find first.This is so that you do not feel like you will pay more for them in order to complete the set.It is easier to fill in easy finds at the end.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
306 posts

so sorry been so long forgot about this thread....

 

well its best on ebay to be very careful, even here on the board there is a thread of questionable business practice of one seller. basically high end books let one gain the most money with the least amount of work....

 

i recommend if you find a high end book look at what the seller recently bought say last 6 mths on ebay to see if its a flip. if not there then look at books fron comiclink or comicconnect and again compare to recently sold items. most high end books have telltale signs, folds, scratches dots even the trim or spine ticks. compare look closely and decide if questionable... scammers are too lazy they like quick turnarounds...

 

also google search for thei ids some are notorious robojo or more recently

 

Seller User Id: all_things_comics

Feedback: 100% positive, 1,713 reviews

 

he looks to be the old cdpaolli but he is more consistantly marking books as restored...

 

just be aware ask lots of question use the internet as a good tool to search and be thorough.... once big money can be made sure enough scammers will follow!

 

cheers

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
283 posts

I've started collecting two years ago and the best lessons I learned were.

#1. Be prepared to be ripped off once or twice. I got taken in by seemingly nice dealers who sold me comics way above their grade. Lucky I had shallow pockets so I only loss $80 after reselling them. So I never buy raw comics now.

 

#2. Fees, understand them well when dealing with auction houses. I remember buying a few books for what I thought were below GPA n FMV but was surprised at CL n Pedigrees buyers premium, Paypal forex fee and shipping. The deal was almost equivalent to simply paying local prices. Keep the grand total in mind when cateloging your comics.

 

#3. Buy within your means and don't get too caught up in the 9.8W craze. When I was calculating down the pennies how to pay off my CC I knew I had over indulged.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4,943 posts
Does anyone know where I can buy white cotton gloves?
Welcome to the boards!

 

If you're wanting gloves for safer handling of collectibles try Amazon or Archivalgloves.com.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
215 posts

Check out your local estate sales. Do a search type in your city and estate sale. You will get a listing of your local estate sales and be there early. Usually comic book dealers are already there early in the morning. I found a whole box of Sgt. Fury and His Howling Commandos starting from #1-167 for $150.00. This was totally by total accident and in my neighborhood. In fact, I was leaving the house with the estate sale and turned quickly when I saw the long box. The box was sealed and it stated Sgt Fury in bad ink and $150.00 in pencil. The first 10 issues in very good category and then got better. Also, scout storage bins up for auction. Those long boxes are usually visible. Outta here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 posts
Go to a comic book convention! Rummage through the bargain bins! This can be a lot of fun for the new collector.

 

 

I second this! As a recent newbie to collecting, this was and is so much fun to do. Attending local conventions allows you to jump right in. And the prices are reasonable, plus you can get a good look at the condition.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3,113 posts
Go to a comic book convention! Rummage through the bargain bins! This can be a lot of fun for the new collector.

 

 

I second this! As a recent newbie to collecting, this was and is so much fun to do. Attending local conventions allows you to jump right in. And the prices are reasonable, plus you can get a good look at the condition.

 

Sometimes you can find serious gold in those dollar or 50 cent bins too. I've pulled a handful of books out of those bins that were modern keys in great shape. Plus, yeah.. it's fun (if tedious sometimes) to flip through 40 long boxes full of out-of-order comics in hopes of finding something needed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
119 posts
purchase books unslabbed from reputable dealers as the prices are usually much more "beginner friendly". Purchase Overstreet Guide to Grading. Purchase supplies from either Bill Cole or E Gerber. Read up on how to store your comics. Don't buy stuff you know nothing about. If something seems to good to be true, it usually is. Check for Marvel Value stamps on issues that contain them (Hulk 181).

 

Brian

 

Overstreet Guide to Grading is undoubtedly the single most important book I bought as a (beginning/&) collector... Amazing resource to truly understand grading, re. which 90% of people don't have a clue and, so, resort to a guess on grade from how pretty they think it looks and counting color breaks on the spine.

 

Also, find the fun.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
119 posts
Don't rip your comics or mommy will kill ya smile.gifcool.gifblush.gif

Especially don't let your mother-in-law rip a cover of Action Comics #1 should you be so lucky to find a copy which was used as insulation in the wall of a house you're refurbishing, after finding yourself in a disbelief-driven tug-of-war with the found treasure. And, don't play tug-of-war with the comics, in general, a bad idea! doh!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
254 posts

Hey guys, Im new to the boards and I thought I'd come here for some advice. Im considering purchasing a CGC 9.9 Itchy and Scratchy comics #1 but before I send an offer, what do you guys think is a fair price for this book from 1993. CGC 9.8's usually go for around $40-$50.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
745 posts
In general I don't like the idea of CGC grading modern books as I consider them common in high grade. There are lots of people building high grade CGC modern sets who would disagree with me.

 

As a general rule it doesn't make sense to pay for grading on a book that will be worth less than the cost of grading. The newer the book the higher the grade needed to justify the cost.

lol, planning on slabbing a modern worth probably less than $5. I really, really, really like the variant cover. Comic looks NM to me. Will see if CGC concurs. Would've bought a graded copy (at a reasonable price) to save myself the hassle but alas, I couldn't find any. :P

 

I normally wouldn't slab since I like being able to read my comics but in this case, I want to have it preserved. I've got a copy of the regular cover for reading anyway. :)

 

Any packaging/shipping tips for submitting to CGC?

 

As a relative "newbie," a great way to start a collection full of enjoyables is to stay within the modern/copper age for the first little bit unless you absolutely MUST have an older book.

 

Why, do you ask? Apart from a few noted examples, most collectible books in this range are under $200 slabbed 9.0+ (X-men 135, 136 pop to mind). As well, books should be easier to find as this is the age when comic book sales shot through the roof and supply is out there. Again, however, there are noted examples of rarity (misprints, valuable variant covers, 1-in-1000 variants, etc).

 

I have found that staying newer than 1980 has made my hobby eminently affordable

lol, agree. I'm grateful the stuff I like reading are moderns so it's been relatively affordable. Most I've paid for a single issue is $20 with shipping. Majority of my purchases is at cover price or less. :)

 

I've read a few GA/SA keys on Marvel Unlimited and thus far, I haven't felt the need to purchase single issues at current market price ($400+). Maybe if I ever get to the point where I'm making $1 million a year (inflation-adjusted) but that's highly unlikely.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 posts
On 7/14/2002 at 2:16 PM, aardvark88 said:

Dan,

Back in 1985, u would have had to deliver a heck of a lot of newspapers to come up w/ $1,500 for FF #1 or say $1k for ASM #1 vf-. Else trade in your run of X-men 94 up, Hulk 181, laugh.gif & set of Howard Duck to come up w/ the scratch.

 

On 7/14/2002 at 2:16 PM, aardvark88 said:

Dan,

Back in 1985, u would have had to deliver a heck of a lot of newspapers to come up w/ $1,500 for FF #1 or say $1k for ASM #1 vf-. Else trade in your run of X-men 94 up, Hulk 181, laugh.gif & set of Howard Duck to come up w/ the scratch.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 posts
Just now, Danno777 said:

Back in 1966, I delivered a LOT of newspapers to by new Marvels at the Squirrel Hill Newstand in Pgh.  When they went from 15c to a quarter, I bailed.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,324 posts
On 6/24/2002 at 12:56 PM, AlexH said:

- Always start by purchasing books that you enjoy (or think you would like) reading.

- Don't start collecting to try and make money

- Don't make a large purchase unless you are well informed about the book

- Don't let someone tell you what is good to read, unless of course you value their opinion.

 

I'm sure I'll come up with some later, but here is a start...

That's an amazing start man...Thank you

Much to the chagrin of everyone in my life,I started collecting in February of this year,2019.

I can see this thread was started 17 years ago,pretty cool how far the comic universe...er multiverse has come.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
221 posts

Best tip for new collector:

:news: Buy Adventure Comics #260. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
5 5