• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

FS: Misc Massachusetts Pedigree CLOSED

Started by nochips,

150 posts in this topic

nochips

nochips

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I do have a certificate/letter that CGC will and does accept. These books can all be traced back to a board member who bought them directly from the Mass OO. CGC has slabbed books with this proof.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
The Silver-Age

The Silver-Age

Posted
Posted
I do have a certificate/letter that CGC will and does accept. These books can all be traced back to a board member who bought them directly from the Mass OO. CGC has slabbed books with this proof.

 

Sweet. When do all the Marvel's show up?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Bomber-Bob

Bomber-Bob

Posted
Posted
I do have a certificate/letter that CGC will and does accept. These books can all be traced back to a board member who bought them directly from the Mass OO. CGC has slabbed books with this proof.

 

I am the Board Member that Stuart is refering to. I bought these books in the mid-90's. It started with an Ad in the Comic Buyer's Guide(a weekly publication) for some Wonder Woman. Needless to say I was impressed with the books and bought more over the next couple of years. Stuart failed to mention that nearly all of these books have WHITE pages.

I have slabbed over 150 Mass books with CGC. I always included a letter explaining the heritage. I remember waiting a long time for my early Mass submissions to be graded. They told me Mark Haspel was checking out the heritage before he finalized them. It's rarely mentioned but maintaining the integrity of a pedigree is another service provided by CGC. I was told Mark personally looks at every pedigree that comes to CGC.

Stuart bought these books from me about three years ago. They are genuine Mass but unfortunately there are no COA's. At the time I was buying them they weren't a pedigree yet, they were just nice books.

Enjoy.............................

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Green

Green

Posted
Posted
I do have a certificate/letter that CGC will and does accept. These books can all be traced back to a board member who bought them directly from the Mass OO. CGC has slabbed books with this proof.

 

I am the Board Member that Stuart is refering to.

:hi:
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Bomber-Bob

Bomber-Bob

Posted
Posted

If there is any doubt about how nice these Mass books are, here are the results of my very first Mass submission. Please note these grades were obtained without

the benefit of any Pressing.

Flash 206 9.8 White Mass

Flash 207 9.4 White Mass

Flash 210 9.6 White Mass

Flash 212 9.6 OW/W Mass

Action 402 9.8 White Mass

Captain Marvel 33 9.4 White Mass

Sub-Mariner 35 9.6 White Mass Qualified

Daredevil 89 9.6 White Mass

Daredevil 91 9.6 White Mass

Link to comment
Share on other sites
awe4one

awe4one

Posted
Posted
I do have a certificate/letter that CGC will and does accept. These books can all be traced back to a board member who bought them directly from the Mass OO. CGC has slabbed books with this proof.

 

I am the Board Member that Stuart is refering to. I bought these books in the mid-90's. It started with an Ad in the Comic Buyer's Guide(a weekly publication) for some Wonder Woman. Needless to say I was impressed with the books and bought more over the next couple of years. Stuart failed to mention that nearly all of these books have WHITE pages.

I have slabbed over 150 Mass books with CGC. I always included a letter explaining the heritage. I remember waiting a long time for my early Mass submissions to be graded. They told me Mark Haspel was checking out the heritage before he finalized them. It's rarely mentioned but maintaining the integrity of a pedigree is another service provided by CGC. I was told Mark personally looks at every pedigree that comes to CGC.

Stuart bought these books from me about three years ago. They are genuine Mass but unfortunately there are no COA's. At the time I was buying them they weren't a pedigree yet, they were just nice books.

Enjoy.............................

 

So all these comics being Mass is secondhand info? Not doubting you at all but if the chain has been broken then I'm not sure the pedigree designation is legit....

 

That's why I won't buy "pedigrees" without the cert....

 

Jim

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Bomber-Bob

Bomber-Bob

Posted
Posted
I do have a certificate/letter that CGC will and does accept. These books can all be traced back to a board member who bought them directly from the Mass OO. CGC has slabbed books with this proof.

 

I am the Board Member that Stuart is refering to. I bought these books in the mid-90's. It started with an Ad in the Comic Buyer's Guide(a weekly publication) for some Wonder Woman. Needless to say I was impressed with the books and bought more over the next couple of years. Stuart failed to mention that nearly all of these books have WHITE pages.

I have slabbed over 150 Mass books with CGC. I always included a letter explaining the heritage. I remember waiting a long time for my early Mass submissions to be graded. They told me Mark Haspel was checking out the heritage before he finalized them. It's rarely mentioned but maintaining the integrity of a pedigree is another service provided by CGC. I was told Mark personally looks at every pedigree that comes to CGC.

Stuart bought these books from me about three years ago. They are genuine Mass but unfortunately there are no COA's. At the time I was buying them they weren't a pedigree yet, they were just nice books.

Enjoy.............................

 

So all these comics being Mass is secondhand info? Not doubting you at all but if the chain has been broken then I'm not sure the pedigree designation is legit....

 

That's why I won't buy "pedigrees" without the cert....

 

Jim

 

Before CGC I don't think anyone thought of COA's. I'm sure Chuck didn't issue

them when he sold the Mile High Books.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
awe4one

awe4one

Posted
Posted
I do have a certificate/letter that CGC will and does accept. These books can all be traced back to a board member who bought them directly from the Mass OO. CGC has slabbed books with this proof.

 

I am the Board Member that Stuart is refering to. I bought these books in the mid-90's. It started with an Ad in the Comic Buyer's Guide(a weekly publication) for some Wonder Woman. Needless to say I was impressed with the books and bought more over the next couple of years. Stuart failed to mention that nearly all of these books have WHITE pages.

I have slabbed over 150 Mass books with CGC. I always included a letter explaining the heritage. I remember waiting a long time for my early Mass submissions to be graded. They told me Mark Haspel was checking out the heritage before he finalized them. It's rarely mentioned but maintaining the integrity of a pedigree is another service provided by CGC. I was told Mark personally looks at every pedigree that comes to CGC.

Stuart bought these books from me about three years ago. They are genuine Mass but unfortunately there are no COA's. At the time I was buying them they weren't a pedigree yet, they were just nice books.

Enjoy.............................

 

So all these comics being Mass is secondhand info? Not doubting you at all but if the chain has been broken then I'm not sure the pedigree designation is legit....

 

That's why I won't buy "pedigrees" without the cert....

 

Jim

 

Before CGC I don't think anyone thought of COA's. I'm sure Chuck didn't issue

them when he sold the Mile High Books.

 

Sure...and I bet these are legit as well....but when it becomes a "he said so" situation it just begs for fraudulence...

 

Jim

Link to comment
Share on other sites
awe4one

awe4one

Posted
Posted
I do have a certificate/letter that CGC will and does accept. These books can all be traced back to a board member who bought them directly from the Mass OO. CGC has slabbed books with this proof.

 

I am the Board Member that Stuart is refering to. I bought these books in the mid-90's. It started with an Ad in the Comic Buyer's Guide(a weekly publication) for some Wonder Woman. Needless to say I was impressed with the books and bought more over the next couple of years. Stuart failed to mention that nearly all of these books have WHITE pages.

I have slabbed over 150 Mass books with CGC. I always included a letter explaining the heritage. I remember waiting a long time for my early Mass submissions to be graded. They told me Mark Haspel was checking out the heritage before he finalized them. It's rarely mentioned but maintaining the integrity of a pedigree is another service provided by CGC. I was told Mark personally looks at every pedigree that comes to CGC.

Stuart bought these books from me about three years ago. They are genuine Mass but unfortunately there are no COA's. At the time I was buying them they weren't a pedigree yet, they were just nice books.

Enjoy.............................

 

So all these comics being Mass is secondhand info? Not doubting you at all but if the chain has been broken then I'm not sure the pedigree designation is legit....

 

That's why I won't buy "pedigrees" without the cert....

 

Jim

 

Before CGC I don't think anyone thought of COA's. I'm sure Chuck didn't issue

them when he sold the Mile High Books.

 

Sure...and I bet these are legit as well....but when it becomes a "he said so" situation it just begs for fraudulence...

 

And I'm sure Chuck did issue a cert for the Mile High 2 Collection which pre-dates this one a number of years...

 

Jim

Link to comment
Share on other sites
nochips

nochips

Posted
  • Author
Posted
I do have a certificate/letter that CGC will and does accept. These books can all be traced back to a board member who bought them directly from the Mass OO. CGC has slabbed books with this proof.

 

I am the Board Member that Stuart is refering to. I bought these books in the mid-90's. It started with an Ad in the Comic Buyer's Guide(a weekly publication) for some Wonder Woman. Needless to say I was impressed with the books and bought more over the next couple of years. Stuart failed to mention that nearly all of these books have WHITE pages.

I have slabbed over 150 Mass books with CGC. I always included a letter explaining the heritage. I remember waiting a long time for my early Mass submissions to be graded. They told me Mark Haspel was checking out the heritage before he finalized them. It's rarely mentioned but maintaining the integrity of a pedigree is another service provided by CGC. I was told Mark personally looks at every pedigree that comes to CGC.

Stuart bought these books from me about three years ago. They are genuine Mass but unfortunately there are no COA's. At the time I was buying them they weren't a pedigree yet, they were just nice books.

Enjoy.............................

 

So all these comics being Mass is secondhand info? Not doubting you at all but if the chain has been broken then I'm not sure the pedigree designation is legit....

 

That's why I won't buy "pedigrees" without the cert....

 

Jim

 

Before CGC I don't think anyone thought of COA's. I'm sure Chuck didn't issue

them when he sold the Mile High Books.

 

Sure...and I bet these are legit as well....but when it becomes a "he said so" situation it just begs for fraudulence...

 

Jim

 

Jim, you are entitled to your opinion. In this case you are dead wrong and a bit out of line. You basically called Bob and I liars.Bob bought these books in the mid 1990s, before certs really came into existence. Bob bought them from the original owner of the Mass collection, the guy who bought them off the news stand and put them in a box, the OO. I bought them from Bob. How is any chain broke here? You need some glossy cert to make you feel better? Great, please derail some other threads with your certificate paranoia.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Bomber-Bob

Bomber-Bob

Posted
Posted
I do have a certificate/letter that CGC will and does accept. These books can all be traced back to a board member who bought them directly from the Mass OO. CGC has slabbed books with this proof.

 

I am the Board Member that Stuart is refering to. I bought these books in the mid-90's. It started with an Ad in the Comic Buyer's Guide(a weekly publication) for some Wonder Woman. Needless to say I was impressed with the books and bought more over the next couple of years. Stuart failed to mention that nearly all of these books have WHITE pages.

I have slabbed over 150 Mass books with CGC. I always included a letter explaining the heritage. I remember waiting a long time for my early Mass submissions to be graded. They told me Mark Haspel was checking out the heritage before he finalized them. It's rarely mentioned but maintaining the integrity of a pedigree is another service provided by CGC. I was told Mark personally looks at every pedigree that comes to CGC.

Stuart bought these books from me about three years ago. They are genuine Mass but unfortunately there are no COA's. At the time I was buying them they weren't a pedigree yet, they were just nice books.

Enjoy.............................

 

So all these comics being Mass is secondhand info? Not doubting you at all but if the chain has been broken then I'm not sure the pedigree designation is legit....

 

That's why I won't buy "pedigrees" without the cert....

 

Jim

 

Before CGC I don't think anyone thought of COA's. I'm sure Chuck didn't issue

them when he sold the Mile High Books.

 

Sure...and I bet these are legit as well....but when it becomes a "he said so" situation it just begs for fraudulence...

 

Jim

 

Marnin Rosenberg originally brought this collection to market. He also obtained

his books via an ad in the CBG. Marnin did not care about Bronze so he only took the books through 1970. I once called Marnin and checked out a couple titles. My first issue in a run started exactly where his run left off.

Many of the titles went well in to the mid-80's. At some point in the early 80's (I never did obtain an exact cutoff) CGC will no longer recognize the pedigree.

Jim, I understand what you are saying, you have a good point. But, so far, the books Stuart have listed are genuine Mass. I believe the integrity of the Mass pedigree is important to maintain, I know Stuart feels the same.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
awe4one

awe4one

Posted
Posted
I do have a certificate/letter that CGC will and does accept. These books can all be traced back to a board member who bought them directly from the Mass OO. CGC has slabbed books with this proof.

 

I am the Board Member that Stuart is refering to. I bought these books in the mid-90's. It started with an Ad in the Comic Buyer's Guide(a weekly publication) for some Wonder Woman. Needless to say I was impressed with the books and bought more over the next couple of years. Stuart failed to mention that nearly all of these books have WHITE pages.

I have slabbed over 150 Mass books with CGC. I always included a letter explaining the heritage. I remember waiting a long time for my early Mass submissions to be graded. They told me Mark Haspel was checking out the heritage before he finalized them. It's rarely mentioned but maintaining the integrity of a pedigree is another service provided by CGC. I was told Mark personally looks at every pedigree that comes to CGC.

Stuart bought these books from me about three years ago. They are genuine Mass but unfortunately there are no COA's. At the time I was buying them they weren't a pedigree yet, they were just nice books.

Enjoy.............................

 

So all these comics being Mass is secondhand info? Not doubting you at all but if the chain has been broken then I'm not sure the pedigree designation is legit....

 

That's why I won't buy "pedigrees" without the cert....

 

Jim

 

Before CGC I don't think anyone thought of COA's. I'm sure Chuck didn't issue

them when he sold the Mile High Books.

 

Sure...and I bet these are legit as well....but when it becomes a "he said so" situation it just begs for fraudulence...

 

Jim

 

Jim, you are entitled to your opinion. In this case you are dead wrong and a bit out of line. You basically called Bob and I liars.Bob bought these books in the mid 1990s, before certs really came into existence. Bob bought them from the original owner of the Mass collection, the guy who bought them off the news stand and put them in a box, the OO. I bought them from Bob. How is any chain broke here? You need some glossy cert to make you feel better? Great, please derail some other threads with your certificate paranoia.

 

 

Neg, theres no difference between this and the recent Mile High 2 collection Chuck found under some stairs a couple years ago which CGC now won't certfiy as It tainted the whole collection. How is this any different? I'm not doubting you but the question begs to be asked....and I'm not out of line for asking it...

 

Jim

Link to comment
Share on other sites
nochips

nochips

Posted
  • Author
Posted
I do have a certificate/letter that CGC will and does accept. These books can all be traced back to a board member who bought them directly from the Mass OO. CGC has slabbed books with this proof.

 

I am the Board Member that Stuart is refering to. I bought these books in the mid-90's. It started with an Ad in the Comic Buyer's Guide(a weekly publication) for some Wonder Woman. Needless to say I was impressed with the books and bought more over the next couple of years. Stuart failed to mention that nearly all of these books have WHITE pages.

I have slabbed over 150 Mass books with CGC. I always included a letter explaining the heritage. I remember waiting a long time for my early Mass submissions to be graded. They told me Mark Haspel was checking out the heritage before he finalized them. It's rarely mentioned but maintaining the integrity of a pedigree is another service provided by CGC. I was told Mark personally looks at every pedigree that comes to CGC.

Stuart bought these books from me about three years ago. They are genuine Mass but unfortunately there are no COA's. At the time I was buying them they weren't a pedigree yet, they were just nice books.

Enjoy.............................

 

So all these comics being Mass is secondhand info? Not doubting you at all but if the chain has been broken then I'm not sure the pedigree designation is legit....

 

That's why I won't buy "pedigrees" without the cert....

 

Jim

 

Before CGC I don't think anyone thought of COA's. I'm sure Chuck didn't issue

them when he sold the Mile High Books.

 

Sure...and I bet these are legit as well....but when it becomes a "he said so" situation it just begs for fraudulence...

 

Jim

 

Jim, you are entitled to your opinion. In this case you are dead wrong and a bit out of line. You basically called Bob and I liars.Bob bought these books in the mid 1990s, before certs really came into existence. Bob bought them from the original owner of the Mass collection, the guy who bought them off the news stand and put them in a box, the OO. I bought them from Bob. How is any chain broke here? You need some glossy cert to make you feel better? Great, please derail some other threads with your certificate paranoia.

 

 

Neg, theres no difference between this and the recent Mile High 2 collection Chuck found under some stairs a couple years ago which CGC now won't certfiy as It tainted the whole collection. How is this any different? I'm not doubting you but the question begs to be asked....and I'm not out of line for asking it...

 

Jim

 

Jim, you win.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Go to topic listing