2016 March Madness Comic Grading Tournament - Round of 64

[Dark Knight]

It was a big gamble giving this book a 7.0 because I thought it was an 8.0 but thought that tear on the back could hammer the grade.

 

Saved by the bell. Live to fight another day.

 

Good match Dark Knight

 

Yep a close match indeed IncredibleHauck. Congrats on making it to the next round I didn't even see the tear on the back. Oh well. It was great to be in this contest. Thanks also BlowuptheMoon for doing this for us

[kav]

IncredibleHauck - 7.0

Dark Knight - 9.2

 

 

 

How are people able to see the grade in this post-it's whited out

[sckao]

It's a double cover so the grade is in the middle in small text...

[Dark Knight]

I wonder if the inner cover was graded a 9.2..

[musicmeta]

Forgot to send in my grades! Got side tracked with work and other life issues. Oh well! I'll shoot for next year..Good luck to all

[BlowUpTheMoon]

I wonder if the inner cover was graded a 9.2..

 

 

 

[Dark Knight]

I wonder if the inner cover was graded a 9.2..

 

 

 

Hey that should be extra points for me for grading the inner cover correctly without seeing it!

[01TheDude]

I wonder if the inner cover was graded a 9.2..

 

 

 

Hey that should be extra points for me for grading the inner cover correctly without seeing it!

 

sure thing-- you are matched up against Kav next round

[kav]

Grades submitted

[Hado]

[kav]

Apparently Toro sandbagged the first round cause he wanted to be pitted against a strong competitor!

That's Navy Seal stuff man.

[trmoore54]

It was a big gamble giving this book a 7.0 because I thought it was an 8.0 but thought that tear on the back could hammer the grade.

 

Saved by the bell. Live to fight another day.

 

Good match Dark Knight

 

What was the grade? It's whited out on my scan

[kav]

Everyone knows you look a the small print description....

[JollyComics]

Dark Knight vs Kav

 

Good fighting round!