2017 Green Eggs Grading Contest Round 5 4 4

[01TheDude]

ok=--- time for the big reveal so we can get on with our Friday night!

[thirdgreenham]

Jo-Jo Comics #7 CGC 3.0

Gay Comics #31 CGC 4.0

 

[Azkaban]

[01TheDude]

woo hoo!

[porcupine48]

no bulls,but a surprisingly low amount of butthurt.I just couldn't see that Gay getting more than a 3.5 with the 'defacing!'.

Oh well.

[ss5rmp]

and I whiff again...

[01TheDude]

[trmoore54]

Ouch.  Bullseye on the Gay and the grade on the JOJO (?).  Scratching my head on that one...

[mr_highgrade]

Another double bullseye! 

 

[kav]

ouch

 

[01TheDude]

golden age bumps!

[Ron C.]

I was going to say 3.0 on the Jo-Jo comics since that is the only low graded CGC comic on the CGC census, but I figured you would not be that obvious. 

[Sandflea]

Over-graded the Gay Comics book...really confused me with the writing on it... 

[Point Five]

3 minutes ago, porcupine48 said:

no bulls,but a surprisingly low amount of butthurt.I just couldn't see that Gay getting more than a 3.5 with the 'defacing!'.

Oh well.

I said 3.5 as well. Imagine buying this book sight unseen as a 4.0 OW/W... surprise! Yikes. 

 

[AnthonyTheAbyss]

Dang it.  I didn't know what to do with the "coloring".  Learned something

[Larryw7]

I got the Jo Jo right, overgraded the Gay. 

[AnthonyTheAbyss]

What do you do with coloring like that?  2 grade drop?  3 grade drop?

[porcupine48]

1 minute ago, Point Five said:

I said 3.5 as well. Imagine buying this book sight unseen as a 4.0 OW/W... surprise! Yikes. 

 

for sure a case of buy the book,not the grade.

[kav]

Without the coloring it looks like a solid 8.0 so 4 full grade drop for writing.

[Senormac]

2 minutes ago, AnthonyTheAbyss said:

Dang it.  I didn't know what to do with the "coloring".  Learned something

I thought it was a 7.0 or a 6.5 if the red smear writing was not there, so I just started subtracting till I got to 5.5