PGM Green Lantern #59(Added Staples) 0

[billbrown7080]

Hoping for advice on the grade of my GL 59...Its got 3 extra staples someone has added...

not sure exactly how to grade it and how much the Staples effect the grade

thank

 

Edited January 9, 2019 by billbrown7080

[Kromak]

I think it deserves to be on the fine range, even with the smaller flaws, but hard to estimate it.... 5.0-5.5?

[billbrown7080]

8 hours ago, Kromak said:

I think it deserves to be on the fine range, even with the smaller flaws, but hard to estimate it.... 5.0-5.5?

does the added staples not effect that grade much?

I look up another thread a while ago where someone said, If a comics has added staples it cant be graded higher than a 4.0?

IMO this book would probably be a 5.5 to 6.0....but I just dont know what the added staples does to the grade

someone else told me that most books with added staples are in 2.0 range? that the book would need to be 8.5 to 9.0 to get a 4.0 with added staples.

 

thanks

[billbrown7080]

sorry to bump this...just hoping for more responses

[csaag]

I'd call it a 5.0 Sorry - no idea what the extra staples due to it