Same grade but which do I keep? 0

[mheyman89]

Hey there!

I've been in possession of two CGC 9.2 Giant-Size X-Men #1s and am trying to decide which to hang on to and which to let go. Both have differing types of damage and overall I cannot decide which one I like more. One has a bit of damage to the bottom corner and the other has damage to the top right corner.

Well here are two albums showcasing the books with details on the condition. I know in the end it will be my decision to make but I was hoping to get some insight from others as to which one you would hold onto.

Comic A:

https://imgur.com/a/RCDtouM

Comic B:

https://imgur.com/a/vAvOXVs

 

Also if I did not post this in the appropriate place or if this is not an appropriate post please do let me know.

Thank you in advance for any help! It is much appreciated!

Edited November 5, 2019 by mheyman89

[csaag]

I'll say it first - why can't you keep both?

 

to me A) looks more pleasing overall.  Seems like most of the defects are concentrated in that LLC

[PunisherPunisherPunisher]

Keep the better 9.2 

Dam nice books by the way 

[Krismusic]

I would keep both personally... but if your keeping one and selling one. I would keep A as I like the centering better on that but the spine looks wavy to me. kind of tough I wonder if either of those would benefit from a press. 

What are the grader notes on both. 

I would keep the one that might benefit from a press and clean more and see if I can get a grade bump.

Just my .. 

nice books maybe one day I will get a GSX 1 too.. 

[comicginger1789]

I will be the first to say I would keep B. That ding on the bottom left corner is super noticeable and that is all I can stare at. Sure the centering is a bit better but I think B looks structurally better overall. 

[The Lions Den]

I would sell both of them and go for an upgrade...