pease grade my mister miracle #8

[topofthetotem]

hello the pages are "white" you'll notice the pages extend a little past the edge the centerfold is a little off kilter but it is firmly attached just stapled a little crooked, no tears or splits, the yellow in the white lettering is not that visible with the naked eye I didnt even notice it until I took the scan now for your grading pleasure

 

the back cover has a stain by the bottom staple that is rust migration the top part of the top staple has rust

[Aces]

Water damage by bottom staple?

[topofthetotem]

the pages don't show any water damage at all it's just on the back outside of the cover not on the inside

[Aces]

I just couldn't go higher than 6.5 with that water spot right by the staple.

Just as bad to me as a small piece of tape.

Rust is a coming...

[KingOfRulers]

I'd go with 6.5-7.0.

[Flaming_Telepath]

Rust is a big, bad no-no as far as CGC are concerned...

 

6.5

[dc eng]

6.5

[divad]

Rust is a big, bad no-no as far as CGC are concerned...

 

6.5

 

Yup - just clean those staples up a bit, and put it back in its Mylar Not a bad copy to cover that spot in the run

[topofthetotem]

how would I clean up the staples? would I have to remove it?

I've come to realize that I like the books event if they are not all 9.4/9.6/9.8 they are still cool to look at I've seen many books posted by other forum members that are low grade but are still cool as long as they present nice

[KingOfRulers]

I would leave it how it is. I agree that it could still be low grade and still present nicely. I don't get the obession that so many have with getting a 9.8 and not a 9.6, or something like that. As long as it looks nice I'll go for it. I say, keep this book how it is.