PGM second copy of Avengers #4 0

[Cherami]

I have two copies of this one.  I recently posted the better one here: 

I have a second, more beat up version of it. In rougher shape, but I'm wondering how bad...

 

Thanks!

[JLot123]

I have very little credibility here, but I'll call it a 2.5?  Curious how that holds up to some of the board's more established members.  Hoping they have a better grade in mind for you

[Cherami]

8 minutes ago, JLot123 said:

I have very little credibility here, but I'll call it a 2.5?  Curious how that holds up to some of the board's more established members.  Hoping they have a better grade in mind for you

I suspect that’s probably in the ballpark... 

There’s an ink stain on the cover that bleed into the first page. A rip on the top of the back cover. The top and bottom of the cover are tearing, with lots of smaller tears the whole way up the spine. 

[Cherami]

These are the two copies side by side. Better version is on the left, the one in this thread is on the right 

[The Lions Den]

I'd give this one a 2.0...

12 hours ago, JLot123 said:

I have very little credibility here, but I'll call it a 2.5?  Curious how that holds up to some of the board's more established members.  Hoping they have a better grade in mind for you

Sorry, but I can't do it. There's just too much going on here for me to be comfortable with anything higher than the Good range...

[Deadpoolica]

1.8

[Glassman10]

2.0- 2.5 I'm always amazed at what gets a 3.0

[theCapraAegagrus]

2.0 IMO.