Phantasm (Andrea Beaumont) 1st Appearance? 0

[Mendi1769]

Can anyone please help me out and tell me which of these is the OFFICIAL 1st Appearance:

Mask of the Phantasm NNO (1994)

Batman & Robin Adventures Annual #1 (1996)

Batman Beyond Universe #13 (2014)

Batman/Catwoman #1 (2020) 

 

Tom King recently said that his 2020 comic was the 1st time Phantasm would be in the continuity of the DC comic world which made me think then which one is the 1st appearance.

[awakeintheashes]

I believe it is Mask of the Phantasm 

[Lazyboy]

1 hour ago, Mendi1769 said:

Can anyone please help me out and tell me which of these is the OFFICIAL 1st Appearance:

What does this mean?

1 hour ago, Mendi1769 said:

Mask of the Phantasm NNO (1994)

Batman & Robin Adventures Annual #1 (1996)

Batman Beyond Universe #13 (2014)

Batman/Catwoman #1 (2020)

How is this a question? The earliest appearance is obviously the first appearance, though only in comics.

[ExNihilo]

4 hours ago, Lazyboy said:

What does this mean?

How is this a question? The earliest appearance is obviously the first appearance, though only in comics.

He pretty much answered his own question.  Mask of the Phantasm would be the first comic appearance.  Batman/Catwoman #1 is the 1st in continuity.  It's the same as how 1st Harley Quinn is Batman Adventures #12 and 1st in continuity is Batman: Harley Quinn.

[Danny Anderson]

First appearance.

[kimik]

Pick them all up and don't worry about it. 

[kimik]

However, based on pricing, it looks like the market has decided that it is:  Batman & Robin Adventures Annual #1 (1996)

 

[LDarkseid1]

Aww man, mask of the phantasm, what an awesome animated movie.

[Old_Man_Adam]

18 minutes ago, LDarkseid1 said:

Aww man, mask of the phantasm, what an awesome animated movie.

I’m a marvel fanboy and I still think Batman : the animated series is the best comic cartoon series . Period . 

[LDarkseid1]

1 hour ago, Old_Man_Adam said:

I’m a marvel fanboy and I still think Batman : the animated series is the best comic cartoon series . Period . 

It’s very tough to consider anything else better. The creators of that did just an unbelievable job. Was the highlight of my life when I met Kevin Conroy 😊

Edited January 17, 2021 by LDarkseid1

[Kevin76]

I think Mask Of The Phantasm is but the Batman And Robin Adventures Annual 1 is more expensive. So get both.