PGM Thor 126 2 2

[phineas_horton]

Hi folks, I found another copy of Thor #126 in one of my comic book stashes. Cover and pages are all attached to both staples, all pages are there, no missing pieces from inside pages. There is just a small rectangular piece missing (3/8 inch wide and 6/8 inch long) on the back cover, at the spine area (see the last 2 photos). Thanks for all your grading opinions!

   

Edited April 9, 2021 by phineas_horton
Better description

[Glassman10]

5.5

 

[MPH1964]

5 minutes ago, Glassman10 said:

5.5

 

Agreed, but would grade higher if not for the missing piece...

[Galen130]

49 minutes ago, MPH1964 said:

Agreed, but would grade higher if not for the missing piece...

[Galen130]

6.0

[Glassman10]

1 hour ago, MPH1964 said:

Agreed, but would grade higher if not for the missing piece...

well, that's what grading is all about essentially. All the pieces need to be right if you want a specific grade.  It's why I gave the grade I did.  If someone scribbled a mustache on Thor, you aren't supposed to say- "jeez" a 9.2 except for the moustache. , if he'd only done a goatee."

 

Graders are sort of "Gotcha" People sometimes.

[MatterEaterLad]

5.0

[MPH1964]

1 hour ago, Galen130 said:

 

1 hour ago, Glassman10 said:

well, that's what grading is all about essentially. All the pieces need to be right if you want a specific grade.  It's why I gave the grade I did.  If someone scribbled a mustache on Thor, you aren't supposed to say- "jeez" a 9.2 except for the moustache. , if he'd only done a goatee."

 

Graders are sort of "Gotcha" People sometimes.

It sounded good when I wrote it and was totally not meant as a gotcha. Ultimately, what I meant to say is that this book would grade much higher if the spine was still intact.  Apologize for the missing qualifier...

 

[Galen130]

1 hour ago, MPH1964 said:

 

It sounded good when I wrote it and was totally not meant as a gotcha. Ultimately, what I meant to say is that this book would grade much higher if the spine was still intact.  Apologize for the missing qualifier...

 

No worries.  Just having fun with it.  Everyone makes a Freudian slip every now and then.  I do it every 5 minutes...

Edited April 9, 2021 by Galen130

[shadroch]

5.0

[Deadpoolica]

5.0

[Funnybooks]

12 hours ago, MPH1964 said:

Agreed, but would grade higher if not for the missing piece...

Disagree...

would grade lower if not for the complete wraps 

please don't send your goblin after me

[Galen130]

2 minutes ago, Funnybooks said:

Disagree...

would grade lower if not for the complete wraps 

please don't send your goblin after me

Bad monkey!!!

[I Am The Answer!]

5.0 for me.

[phineas_horton]

I'm counting more 5.0s than the other grades, so 5.0 seems to be the consensus so far. Thank you everyone for your grading opinions!

[MPH1964]

1 hour ago, Funnybooks said:

Disagree...

would grade lower if not for the complete wraps 

please don't send your goblin after me

Hang on I’m ordering some new emojis...

Sharks circling the blood in the water emoji 

Sasquatch sized foot in the mouth emoji

Dogpile on Captain Obvious emoji (Thanks, @Galen130)

Look on the bright side, it’s not the dumbest thing I ever said... but it’s close. emoji

Any others?  I’m trying to get free shipping...

[Funnybooks]

7 hours ago, MPH1964 said:

Hang on I’m ordering some new emojis...

Sharks circling the blood in the water emoji 

Sasquatch sized foot in the mouth emoji

Dogpile on Captain Obvious emoji (Thanks, @Galen130)

Look on the bright side, it’s not the dumbest thing I ever said... but it’s close. emoji

Any others?  I’m trying to get free shipping...

Master of disguise emoji?