6th Annual March Madness CGC Grading Tournament-Round of 6

[thehumantorch]

Good luck gents, start your engines

[Comicdey]

grades begrudgingly sent...

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Waiting on Toro

[trmoore54]

Waiting on Toro

 

C'mon toro!

[toro]

Waiting on Toro

 

C'mon toro!

 

Sorry my internet is down, grades guesses are in.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Answer Key

 

ASM - 9.0

DOC - 9.2

WF - 8.5

XMEN - 5.5

[BlowUpTheMoon]

I don't have the scoring spreadsheet in front of me so I'll be posting the results when I get home at 5p.

 

 

[sckao]

(You should keep everything in Dropbox.)

 

Looks like I blew that round... 27 points.

 

Way off on the water damage...

[Comicdey]

See you all next tourney. I fouled out

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Yeah, that's probably true. Or Google Docs.

 

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Since I have all the grades and there are only six contestants left, I can probably do the math manually.

[porky]

Got the xmen right. Think my total is a 60

[toro]

I changed two grades before I submitted them. I had the Spidey at 9.0 but down graded to 8.5. I was just a little off on the X-Men, I had it at 5.0 and downgraded it to 4.5. AUGGHH!

 

At least I got the other 2 right, but at this stage it may not be good enough.

[porky]

I changed two grades before I submitted them. I had the Spidey at 9.0 but down graded to 8.5. I was just a little off on the X-Men, I had it at 5.0 and downgraded it to 4.5. AUGGHH!

 

At least I got the other 2 right, but at this stage it may not be good enough.

 

Two right is enough to beat me

[Tsimanga]

See you all next tourney. I fouled out

 

I doubt it - I way under-graded every book. I'd be shocked if I even scored one point.

[Tsimanga]

 

My grades.... I think I scored minus 20 or something like that...

 

ASM - 7.0

DS -8.0

WF - 7.0

XMEN - 4.0

[toro]

My grades.... I think I scored minus 20 or something like that...

 

ASM - 7.0

DS -8.0

WF - 7.0

XMEN - 4.0

 

I think you got 11 points, if my math is correct. Did you grade mostly from the big scans? Only asking because they really make little things look really bad. But I think you were closer on the XMEN then CGC was. I had no idea what to do with a book that had an 8.5 cover and a back cover like that.

[Tsimanga]

Yeah, I always grade from the big scans if possible - and I'd sure be upset if I bought that X-men at say, Comiclink, and then got it home and looked at the back cover... that's a prime example of why Clink should give back cover scans.

 

 

[toro]

Yeah, I always grade from the big scans if possible - and I'd sure be upset if I bought that X-men at say, Comiclink, and then got it home and looked at the back cover... that's a prime example of why Clink should give back cover scans.

 

 

I agree, I was bummed when Heritage stopped giving the back cover scans too.

[Comicdey]

My grades.... I think I scored minus 20 or something like that...

 

ASM - 7.0

DS -8.0

WF - 7.0

XMEN - 4.0

 

My grades

 

ASM - . 7.0

DOC - 9.2

WF - 7.5

XMEN - 4.5

 

Wow and I thought I was out

 

Less you're messing with me. ...