PGM- Xmen 12--Grade In!! Thanks everybody 0

[ADAMANTIUM]

PGM- Xmen 12

Howdy--

Curious what others thought, considering it is SA, didn't know if sometimes they catch a break....

Edited August 23, 2017 by ADAMANTIUM

[SteppinRazor]

First answer is wayyyy better than mine .

Looks great.  Uneducated opinon is (5.5).

[kevhtx]

My first gut was 5.0...But I have a couple silvers that are 5.5/6.0 and this one looks close to those.

[ADAMANTIUM]

Much thanks and appreciated!!

[poppy73]

6.5

[STORMSHADOW_80]

I'm at 5.5/6.0 as well. Nice looking book!

[Primetime]

4.5

[ADAMANTIUM]

28 minutes ago, Primetime said:

4.5

That's what I thought or 4.0....

I had a Xmen 101 that looked this bad on the outside but on the inside too. This one looks nice on the inside, no ruffles or bends and no pesky pinholes etc....touching cream to OW pages...

Anyway my Xmen 101 came back a 4.5; and that is a BA book, I don't know what kind of grace I'd get on a SA book if any 

Edited June 8, 2017 by ADAMANTIUM

[sorb3t]

5.5/6.0

[ADAMANTIUM]

I guess 4.5 is the outlyer  and a bit conservative... but it's hard looking at the census. 5.5 would be over the hump but not by much. Only 184 SS out of 1301 total graded. Of course, the whole 184 is probably Stan! I may do the same, good ole Stan, seal of approval oarr oarr oarrh!! Idk I'm surprised there aren't more blue labels...or many slabs period

I bought it for the Juggernaut forgot about it being the "origin of professor X"

[1950's war comics]

Looks "fine" to me !

[poppy73]

6.0. Great book!

[ADAMANTIUM]

@porcupine48

you seem to be having fun with these today  want to give it a gander and tell me what you think?

[porcupine48]

I'm thinking the top right corner crease could bring it to a 4.5,but I wouldn't be mad if someone sold it to me as a 5.0.

Definately nicer than aVG imho.

[ADAMANTIUM]

Well the grade came back I'll put it in spoiler, feel free to take a look or wait till I have it in hand and I may post a pic

Spoiler

5.5

 

[ADAMANTIUM]

Very anti-climactic without a picture of the book... I'll do better next time and wait to reveal with a pic!

[1Cool]

46 minutes ago, ADAMANTIUM said:

Well the grade came back I'll put it in spoiler, feel free to take a look or wait till I have it in hand and I may post a pic

  Hide contents

5.5

 

Dammit!  I had it - can't pick a bullseye to save my life on the grading contest but here I'm doing great.

Edited August 23, 2017 by 1Cool

[TC33]

Nice! It looks like you caught the graders on a fairly good day.   I swear I always catch them on bad days.

[STORMSHADOW_80]

Congrats on the grade! Can't wait to see it in the case

[Michelangelo]

5.5 ... nice!

I was thinking 5.0